Page 1 of 19

Possible Trades

PostPosted: Wed Aug 19, 2009 7:06 pm
by hearts on fire
What are some of the rumors or possible trades you have heard floating around the place?

i would be very interested to hear what everyone else has been hearing.

Re: Possible Trades

PostPosted: Wed Aug 19, 2009 7:26 pm
by the joker
I have heard Seaby will seak a trade to Port Adelaide.
Matty Campbell to west coast for their First round pick.
St Kilda very kean on Jordan Mcmahon.
Brett Peake and Paul Haselby want to leave Fremantle.
Sandilands maybe Hawthorn

Re: Possible Trades

PostPosted: Wed Aug 19, 2009 8:22 pm
by the big bang
the joker wrote:Sandilands maybe Hawthorn



if fremantle let sandilands go, they need to pack up shop and leave the AFL.

IMO pav is there most important player, followed closely by the big fella, then daylight....

i know kids like broughton and the like are up-and-coming stars and possible future leaders, but freo need to keep pav and sandilands for the entirety of their careers.

Re: Possible Trades

PostPosted: Wed Aug 19, 2009 8:31 pm
by GWW
the joker wrote:Matty Campbell to west coast for their First round pick.
St Kilda very kean on Jordan Mcmahon.


First round pick for Campbell sounds over the odds to me, and I'd be intrigued why St Kilda would be interested in someone like McMahon given the way their current backline plays.

Re: Possible Trades

PostPosted: Wed Aug 19, 2009 9:22 pm
by stan
GWW wrote:
the joker wrote:Matty Campbell to west coast for their First round pick.
St Kilda very kean on Jordan Mcmahon.


First round pick for Campbell sounds over the odds to me, and I'd be intrigued why St Kilda would be interested in someone like McMahon given the way their current backline plays.


He would play as a very attacking wingman because the defense is solid.

Re: Possible Trades

PostPosted: Wed Aug 19, 2009 9:23 pm
by GWW
I still don't think he'd offer them anything they particularly need.

Re: Possible Trades

PostPosted: Wed Aug 19, 2009 10:49 pm
by JK
GWW wrote:
the joker wrote:Matty Campbell to west coast for their First round pick.
St Kilda very kean on Jordan Mcmahon.


First round pick for Campbell sounds over the odds to me, and I'd be intrigued why St Kilda would be interested in someone like McMahon given the way their current backline plays.


Agree with both of those GWW

Re: Possible Trades

PostPosted: Wed Aug 19, 2009 10:55 pm
by Pup
stan wrote:
GWW wrote:
the joker wrote:Matty Campbell to west coast for their First round pick.
St Kilda very kean on Jordan Mcmahon.


First round pick for Campbell sounds over the odds to me, and I'd be intrigued why St Kilda would be interested in someone like McMahon given the way their current backline plays.


He would play as a very attacking wingman because the defense is solid.

Re: Possible Trades

PostPosted: Wed Aug 19, 2009 11:02 pm
by Pup
the joker wrote:I have heard Seaby will seak a trade to Port Adelaide.
Matty Campbell to west coast for their First round pick.
St Kilda very kean on Jordan Mcmahon.
Brett Peake and Paul Haselby want to leave Fremantle.
Sandilands maybe Hawthorn


Seaby is seeking a trade anywhere for more game time as is Ashley Hansen and possibly Brent Staker with all expected to get next to nothing.

First round pick for Campbell is way over the odds and will not happen, Worsfold has stated that the first round pick may be on the table if the Eagles can get something worth while. No thanks to Campbell at that price.

Sandilands wont leave IMO and Haselby wants to leave every year except he then realises he is not worth the price his manager puts on his head so he stays. Expect the same this year.

Reported on radio last week that Surjan wants out and wants to return to WA. Would rather play at Freo apparently but that is just the rumour.

Re: Possible Trades

PostPosted: Thu Aug 20, 2009 9:34 am
by Dirko
Wouldn't be surprised if Carlton made a bit of a play for Seller. He played all his school / junior footy with Gibbsy & Striker so would have a couple of good mates at Blue land....

Salopek would be worth a look at too....

Re: Possible Trades

PostPosted: Thu Aug 20, 2009 2:52 pm
by Benchwarmer
Mentioned on TV here in the West last week that Ashley Hanson could be on his way to Carlton.

Worst-fold dismissed talk of it and I doubt it would happen unless the Blues decided to forego a first round pick - even then after the niggle between the clubs during and in the aftermath of the Judd trade, the Eagles are very cool on making deals with Carlton.

Wouldn't you when you got their best player?

Re: Possible Trades

PostPosted: Thu Aug 20, 2009 3:46 pm
by Pup
Benchwarmer wrote:Mentioned on TV here in the West last week that Ashley Hanson could be on his way to Carlton.

Worst-fold dismissed talk of it and I doubt it would happen unless the Blues decided to forego a first round pick - even then after the niggle between the clubs during and in the aftermath of the Judd trade, the Eagles are very cool on making deals with Carlton.

Wouldn't you when you got their best player?


How original

I would think the Eagles would certainly take a second round pick for Hansen. His career at the Eagles is over especially given the form and improvement of Kennedy.

Re: Possible Trades

PostPosted: Thu Aug 20, 2009 3:57 pm
by Bum Crack
Matty Stokes from Geelong to West Coast in exchange first round draft pick.

Re: Possible Trades

PostPosted: Thu Aug 20, 2009 4:13 pm
by Pup
Bum Crack wrote:Matty Stokes from Geelong to West Coast in exchange first round draft pick.


Stokes is not worth a possible pick 6 in the draft.

Re: Possible Trades

PostPosted: Thu Aug 20, 2009 4:21 pm
by Booney
Jonathon Brown and a Premiership medallion for Nathan Buckley to Collingwood in exchange for a 4th Round pick,Alan Didak and Christy Malthouse.

Aaron Sandilands to Sydney in exchange for the Centre Point Tower

Cameron Mooney to Melbourne in exchange for Jack Watts and picks 1,2,33,56,59 and a new Range Rover

Kurt Tippett to the Gold Coast in exchange for nothing

Hey, everyone else has had a go at making this stuff up.... :lol:

Re: Possible Trades

PostPosted: Thu Aug 20, 2009 7:50 pm
by whufc
the_big_bang wrote:
the joker wrote:Sandilands maybe Hawthorn



if fremantle let sandilands go, they need to pack up shop and leave the AFL.

IMO pav is there most important player, followed closely by the big fella, then daylight....

i know kids like broughton and the like are up-and-coming stars and possible future leaders, but freo need to keep pav and sandilands for the entirety of their careers.


Not all trades are instigated by the clubs and in some cases the clubs have no other option but to trade.

Hyperthetically if Sandilands told Fremantle that if they make him stay next season he will treat everything half a55ed and put no effort in would Fremantle be crazy for trading him.

Re: Possible Trades

PostPosted: Fri Aug 21, 2009 9:31 am
by the joker
you have to think 15 clubs will be ringing Luke Ball, about what he is doing next year after he was dropped again

Re: Possible Trades

PostPosted: Fri Aug 21, 2009 9:53 am
by Booney
Agreed, Ball is good quality who is out of the mix at St.Kilda. We'll have him!!

Ball for Pearce. Straight swap. ;)

Re: Possible Trades

PostPosted: Fri Aug 21, 2009 9:55 am
by JK
Personally I've never been a Luke Ball fan, that's not to say the bloke can't play and most clubs would have to be interested in him.

Re: Possible Trades

PostPosted: Fri Aug 21, 2009 10:53 am
by CK
Pup wrote:
Benchwarmer wrote:Mentioned on TV here in the West last week that Ashley Hanson could be on his way to Carlton.

Worst-fold dismissed talk of it and I doubt it would happen unless the Blues decided to forego a first round pick - even then after the niggle between the clubs during and in the aftermath of the Judd trade, the Eagles are very cool on making deals with Carlton.

Wouldn't you when you got their best player?


How original

I would think the Eagles would certainly take a second round pick for Hansen. His career at the Eagles is over especially given the form and improvement of Kennedy.


Would have thought that a) the Eagles would be reasonably happy with the outcome of the Judd trade in light of Kennedy's big upside and b) a deal with Port involving Seaby and Hansen for Surjan and a pick could have currency (all assuming that Surjan wants out)