SA Footy

cracka wrote:Are the Simon Goodwin critics/haters still out there.

Yep.

cracka wrote:Are the Simon Goodwin critics/haters still out there.

Now, where were we...

Melbourne snatch defeat from the jaws of victory.

RB wrote:Melbourne snatch defeat from the jaws of victory.

Adelaides premiership to loose now.

RB wrote:Melbourne snatch defeat from the jaws of victory.

I think a couple of the maggots had money on the Crows

Well done Crows but Melbourne are still Melbourne.

Jim05 wrote:

RB wrote:Melbourne snatch defeat from the jaws of victory.

I think a couple of the maggots had money on the Crows

2 of the worst umpiring decisions ever in the last minute or 2 gifted Adelaide the win.

Matters little to me as i have little interest anymore in AFL as it's the inconsistent rule interpretations and non decisions like that , that have driven me away from the game.

Just farcical and Laughable

Spargo wrote:

cracka wrote:Are the Simon Goodwin critics/haters still out there.

Now, where were we...

I thought Williams was doing the coaching.

cracka wrote:

Spargo wrote:

cracka wrote:Are the Simon Goodwin critics/haters still out there.

Now, where were we...

I thought Williams was doing the coaching.

Nope, never said that.

Spargo wrote:

cracka wrote:

Spargo wrote:

cracka wrote:Are the Simon Goodwin critics/haters still out there.

Now, where were we...

I thought Williams was doing the coaching.

Nope, never said that.

Plenty others did

I did and still believe it

jackpot jim wrote:

Jim05 wrote:

RB wrote:Melbourne snatch defeat from the jaws of victory.

I think a couple of the maggots had money on the Crows

2 of the worst umpiring decisions ever in the last minute or 2 gifted Adelaide the win.

Matters little to me as i have little interest anymore in AFL as it's the inconsistent rule interpretations and non decisions like that , that have driven me away from the game.

Just farcical and Laughable

Why comment then?

jackpot jim wrote:

Jim05 wrote:

RB wrote:Melbourne snatch defeat from the jaws of victory.

I think a couple of the maggots had money on the Crows

2 of the worst umpiring decisions ever in the last minute or 2 gifted Adelaide the win.

Matters little to me as i have little interest anymore in AFL as it's the inconsistent rule interpretations and non decisions like that , that have driven me away from the game.

Just farcical and Laughable

im glad 2 umpiring decisions in over 100 minutes of football decided the result of the game

I think we can all agree the umpiring has been rubbish.
The standard is at an all time low.
I thought the crows got crucified for most of the game.
The deliberate decision was a case in point.
He tried to handball it more infield but it took a deflection off the defender and went out.
I'm happy with the decision made.
But trying to marry that up with the Zurhar one where he was actually shooting for goal?
Ya just can't!

The 2 game Nick Holman ban is one of the harsher ones i've seen. Can't really call it a sling and not sure how you can possible tackle someone from behind without bring them forward.

whufc wrote:The 2 game Nick Holman ban is one of the harsher ones i've seen. Can't really call it a sling and not sure how you can possible tackle someone from behind without bring them forward.

The umpire even paid HTB! They will appeal this and get off. Agree, not much else he could have done.

Michael Christian needs to go ASAP

Sent from my SM-G781B using Tapatalk

Eagles2014 wrote:

whufc wrote:The 2 game Nick Holman ban is one of the harsher ones i've seen. Can't really call it a sling and not sure how you can possible tackle someone from behind without bring them forward.

The umpire even paid HTB! They will appeal this and get off. Agree, not much else he could have done.

They have appealed as predicted (as have Plowman and Pickett - big night at Tribunal!)

mighty_tiger_79 wrote:Michael Christian needs to go ASAP

Sent from my SM-G781B using Tapatalk

Three players have appealed today (Holman, Pickett and Plowman).

Think that backs up your comment, clubs no longer accept the garbage Christian is serving up, they just appeal and they all end up getting off!!

Years since last negative free kick differential (incl. 2021*):

0 BRI, COL, FRE, GCS, HAW, PTA, RIC, STK
1 CAR, ESS, GEE, GWS
2 MEL, SYD
3
4 ADE
5
6
7
8 WBD
9 NTH
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20 WCE