Worst players to play AFL..

[Rik E Boy]

R. Clarke hands down wins this award!!!

No way. One of our best players in the 2009 Grand Final. Absolute gun.

regards,

REB

[Media Park]

F:
HF: I. Perrie
C:
HB: R. Clarke R. Schoenmakers T. Zantuck
B: Z. Dawson
1R: C. Ackland
Int: J. Sellar

[CoverKing]

How the hell is Schoenmakers is in this thread? he has come on really well this year. Did a pretty good job on the weekend. A young key defender is bloody hard. Coming along pretty nice i think

[GWW]

This thread probably need a qualifier such as, "worst to have played 25 AFL games", that would disqualify some of the absolute duds who fluked a game or 2.

Austin McCrabb I thought was a very average full back for Geelong and then Hawthorn.

Then there's David Gallagher who's been mentioned.

I also remember a bloke by the name of Michael Laffy who played for Richmond in the 80's, a real scrubber.

Scott Harding would probably qualify, as would another recycled Port player Aaron Shattock.

[Squids]

How the hell is Schoenmakers is in this thread? he has come on really well this year. Did a pretty good job on the weekend. A young key defender is bloody hard. Coming along pretty nice i think

Agreed, he was terrible last year but this year he has been very good.

[Squids]

Cain Hackland

[Killa]

Jason harland

[overloaded]

Ackland

Stephen Tiller

[Booney]

How the hell is Schoenmakers is in this thread?

Some people are simply clueless, thats why.

[CoverKing]

This thread probably need a qualifier such as, "worst to have played 25 AFL games", that would disqualify some of the absolute duds who fluked a game or 2.

Austin McCrabb I thought was a very average full back for Geelong and then Hawthorn.

Then there's David Gallagher who's been mentioned.

I also remember a bloke by the name of Michael Laffy who played for Richmond in the 80's, a real scrubber.

Scott Harding would probably qualify, as would another recycled Port player Aaron Shattock.

Shattock a premiership player, not too shabby!

[The Dark Knight]

Cripes Melbourne are hella carp.

I picked them on Saturday night to beat the Power, mainly due to the Power poor record in Darwin. Watching it with my mates who picked the Power in our tipping comp, it was horrible, Melbourne made so many stupid mistakes, I was almost tearing my hair out. I feel sorry for Mark Neeld, some of the mistakes and some of the poor decisions made by his team an amateur footballer wouldn't make!

[GWW]

So was Aaron Keating a premiership player. Both he abd Shattock very ordinary footballers.

[FlyingHigh]

This thread probably need a qualifier such as, "worst to have played 25 AFL games", that would disqualify some of the absolute duds who fluked a game or 2.

Austin McCrabb I thought was a very average full back for Geelong and then Hawthorn.

Then there's David Gallagher who's been mentioned.

I also remember a bloke by the name of Michael Laffy who played for Richmond in the 80's, a real scrubber.

Scott Harding would probably qualify, as would another recycled Port player Aaron Shattock.

Shattock a premiership player, not too shabby!

And 21 WWT Eagles are too because Fuller had the guts to drop him. (Of course we may have won otherwise, but he had been poor in deed and attitude in our 2006 finals)

[dedja]

So was Aaron Keating a premiership player. Both he abd Shattock very ordinary footballers.

Aaron Keating ... 3 AFL games, 1 premiership

Not a bad strike rate

[overloaded]

Shane Tongerie

[Interceptor]

So was Aaron Keating a premiership player. Both he abd Shattock very ordinary footballers.

Aaron Keating ... 3 AFL games, 1 premiership

Not a bad strike rate

Doubled up a week later for Norwood

[dedja]

LOL, he did too ...

[GWW]

On a serious note - I think his career (with South Adelaide) was cut short after being assaulted in Queensland..

[Media Park]

F:
HF: D.Gallagher I. Perrie
C:
HB: R. Clarke R. Schoenmakers T. Zantuck
B: A. McCrabb Z. Dawson
1R: C. Ackland A. Shattock
Int: J. Sellar

added gallagher shattock and mccrabb

[Jim05]

Michael Quinn, Jay Neagle, Jay Nash, Paul Thomas.
Cameron Cloke must also get a mention