SA Footy

Brodlach wrote:Simple, don’t nominate for the draft. No one is forcing you to play AFL

The current system doesn't let them nominate a club as a 18yo, but as a 20yo after 2 years service you can go your hardest and nominate and more often than not get there.

The system is stuffed, time to bring in a 4 year min contract for the top 30 draftee's?

Bandit wrote:I dont think any cat fans will begrudge kelly for seeking a trade to be closer to family, he gave his all during his time at geelong especially this year when he could have sooked it up. If however he is only willing to deal with WCE despite Freo (potentially) having a much better deal then thats poor form from kelly and geelong should remind him that gold coast have pre season draft pick #1.

Freo should be having a bit of fun with this scenario, you would think they would have more cap space than WCE so could offer him a better deal,, they have better picks to trade with the Cats and they have the better draft pick to leverage if he slipped thru to the draft.

Gold Coast couldnt fit him in their cap, if he goes to the draft he nominates his salary.

Jim05 wrote:

woodublieve12 wrote:People saying that Daniher is worth two first round picks are drunk!! 15 games in 3 seasons... Pick 5 and 9 being thrown around.. Stay away from this one Sydney

Swans have just said Papley won’t be allowed to leave so I doubt Daniher can get done

Didn't see that.. Good news

woodublieve12 wrote:

Jim05 wrote:

woodublieve12 wrote:People saying that Daniher is worth two first round picks are drunk!! 15 games in 3 seasons... Pick 5 and 9 being thrown around.. Stay away from this one Sydney

Swans have just said Papley won’t be allowed to leave so I doubt Daniher can get done

Didn't see that.. Good news

Sad news for JJ

JK wrote:

Booney wrote:Anyone care to guess what carey got up to on Wednesday night?

3am Thursday posts....

Just a casual midweek sip

Gotta quench that thirst

Posturing. Both deals will get done

Sure I heard something this morning about maybe both daniher and Fantasia on the move and Essendon in the hunt to sign a contracted player that is a gun could be wrong.

MW wrote:Posturing. Both deals will get done

I’m not so sure on Papley. Can see the Swans holding him for atleast another year. Daniher still hasn’t requested a move but if he does there is no way he will be let go unless it’s something decent

Robran wrote:Sure I heard something this morning about maybe both daniher and Fantasia on the move and Essendon in the hunt to sign a contracted player that is a gun could be wrong.

Yeah, a good possibility. Neither have formally requested a trade yet but seems like it is coming. I’d suspect we have a contingency plan

Jim05 wrote:

MW wrote:Posturing. Both deals will get done

I’m not so sure on Papley. Can see the Swans holding him for atleast another year. Daniher still hasn’t requested a move but if he does there is no way he will be let go unless it’s something decent

Sydney will pay overs, they know Franklin is cooked and need to have someone ready to go ASAP.

Booney wrote:

Jim05 wrote:

MW wrote:Posturing. Both deals will get done

I’m not so sure on Papley. Can see the Swans holding him for atleast another year. Daniher still hasn’t requested a move but if he does there is no way he will be let go unless it’s something decent

Sydney will pay overs, they know Franklin is cooked and need to have someone ready to go ASAP.

source?

woodublieve12 wrote:

Booney wrote:

Jim05 wrote:

MW wrote:Posturing. Both deals will get done

I’m not so sure on Papley. Can see the Swans holding him for atleast another year. Daniher still hasn’t requested a move but if he does there is no way he will be let go unless it’s something decent

Sydney will pay overs, they know Franklin is cooked and need to have someone ready to go ASAP.

source?

Season 2019.

woodublieve12 wrote:

Booney wrote:
Sydney will pay overs, they know Franklin is cooked and need to have someone ready to go ASAP.

source?

And other reasons.

Dutchy wrote:

Bandit wrote:I dont think any cat fans will begrudge kelly for seeking a trade to be closer to family, he gave his all during his time at geelong especially this year when he could have sooked it up. If however he is only willing to deal with WCE despite Freo (potentially) having a much better deal then thats poor form from kelly and geelong should remind him that gold coast have pre season draft pick #1.

Freo should be having a bit of fun with this scenario, you would think they would have more cap space than WCE so could offer him a better deal,, they have better picks to trade with the Cats and they have the better draft pick to leverage if he slipped thru to the draft.

Gold Coast couldnt fit him in their cap, if he goes to the draft he nominates his salary.

Three club deal with Kelly an Eagle. Not sure how Freo could benefit though....

regards,

REB

Booney wrote:
Season 2019.

ahhh i see....

Ok so in that theory, Rance is cooked cause he got injured. Half of GWS list and especially Patton. Or any other player who missed any chunk of the season...

He was training at full pace by seasons end...

carey wrote:

Booney wrote:Geelongs Harry Taylor to play on in 2020.

Lol where at Torque? Pffft I’d kick 6 on the spud.

#geelong2020myass

Righto. Lynch only kicked 5 for a start. A spud who beat Riewoldt in a Grand Final. Top post mate.

regards,

REB

woodublieve12 wrote:

Booney wrote:
Season 2019.

ahhh i see....

Ok so in that theory, Rance is cooked cause he got injured. Half of GWS list and especially Patton. Or any other player who missed any chunk of the season...

He was training at full pace by seasons end...

Yeah. Exact same scenario those two.

regards,

REB

Rik E Boy wrote:

woodublieve12 wrote:

Booney wrote:
Season 2019.

ahhh i see....

Ok so in that theory, Rance is cooked cause he got injured. Half of GWS list and especially Patton. Or any other player who missed any chunk of the season...

He was training at full pace by seasons end...

Yeah. Exact same scenario those two.

regards,

REB

Well if we are going to throw around nonsensical claims with zero facts, i though i'd get involved

stan wrote:Look at Dangerfield to Geelong, Polec to Port, Judd to Carton. It's all the same, now Kelly to West Coast oohhh that's different it should either WA team.

Not salty at all about the Kelly trade because as you have pointed out plenty have gone the other way and he doesn't want to play for our club. But comparing Dangerfield to Kelly is a logic bomb of the highest order. Dangerfield didn't want to come home after two years after Geelong overlooked him in several drafts. Geelong is entitled to seek the best possible outcome for the trade and would be negligent if they did not do so. It has nothing to do with the great WA conspiracy that's rattling around in your head.

regards,

REB

woodublieve12 wrote:

Rik E Boy wrote:

woodublieve12 wrote:

Booney wrote:
Season 2019.

ahhh i see....

Ok so in that theory, Rance is cooked cause he got injured. Half of GWS list and especially Patton. Or any other player who missed any chunk of the season...

He was training at full pace by seasons end...

Yeah. Exact same scenario those two.

regards,

REB

Well if we are going to throw around nonsensical claims with zero facts, i though i'd get involved

It's opinion. And I agree with him. Buddy looks as cooked as a few of ours.

regards,

REB