Round 23 : Live scores & discussion.

[Spargo]

How can anyone say nick dived. Buddy is 100 kgs and his shoulder made contact with head.

It's more the reaction after it. Laying on the ground like seriously injured. Faking it to get franklin Matches. Actually drops a little and leans into the hit. Not in the Spirit of the game. Therefore cheating.

You been to lunch today helicopterking?

[carey]

Buddy will beat that for sure. Slap on the wrist

IMO so it should be.

[Jimmy_041]

Finals time means a whole different set of rules. Barry hall punches a bloke 200m away from ball and gets off.

Who'd he punch outsidethe ground?

touche

[Q.]

It's more the reaction after it. Laying on the ground like seriously injured. Faking it to get franklin Matches. Actually drops a little and leans into the hit. Not in the Spirit of the game. Therefore cheating.

[Vulcan]

It's pretty simple really,
1- he has the choice whether to
a) attempt to tackle
b) smother the kick
c) bump
He "chooses" to bump, his shoulder makes contact with opponents head, no serious damage
But.....
1 week it will be and should be under today's rules.

[woodublieve12]

Buddy has to get games on MRP record, anything less the 2 will be a disgrace! Saying that though, I don't think it's reportable. But like I said on MRP record he has to get games. And for the people who think nick dived obviously have no idea

Positive thing for buddy is that he'll have some free time to find a house in western Sydney

[The Sleeping Giant]

Like Maclure said, why didn't he smother? Lazy.

[Jim05]

Would hate to see anyone get rubbed out for that. Should be more of it but going on the weak as piss MRP he will get 2-3

[daysofourlives]

Like Maclure said, why didn't he smother? Lazy.

5hit like smothering , tackling etc is for players with no talent i.e Sydney

[daysofourlives]

Would hate to see anyone get rubbed out for that. Should be more of it but going on the weak as piss MRP he will get 2-3

Not enough impact to constitute a report will be Mark Evan's oops Mark Fraser's statement on Monday

[The Sleeping Giant]

Like Maclure said, why didn't he smother? Lazy.

5hit like smothering , tackling etc is for players with no talent i.e Sydney

They will go no where doing that.

[carey]

Terrible discussion

[bd u15 09]

Buddy should get two at a minimum.
Hartlett got two for an accidental head clash
Buddy has hit Malceski high with his shoulder deliberately when he had other choices.

There is no reason why that Buddy shouldn't get two if the MRP are consistent.
Only thing going in his favour is he is the love child of the AFL and Malceski didn't get injured

[woodublieve12]

Like Maclure said, why didn't he smother? Lazy.

5hit like smothering , tackling etc is for players with no talent i.e Sydney

you literally have no idea...

We have heaps out and for a half we have outplayed you... We both had 7 days between games so you can't use your usual excuse if you lose

[Johno6]

Umps all over swans dick

[The Sleeping Giant]

Buddy should get two at a minimum.
Hartlett got two for an accidental head clash
Buddy has hit Malceski high with his shoulder deliberately when he had other choices.

There is no reason why that Buddy shouldn't get two if the MRP are consistent.
Only thing going in his favour is he is the love child of the AFL and Malceski didn't get injured

Which will result in 1 game.

[carey]

Spanger is a total spud

[Johno6]

Spanger is a total spud

Wash your mouth out!!!

[carey]

I swear these umpires hate Hawthorn and Sam Mitchell isn't interesting in playing tonight.

[The Sleeping Giant]

Why didn't Jack go the hip and shoulder instead of the smother. Thats not how you win flags.