SA Footy

Hilarious listening to Bickley give his player ratings on 5aa. Jenkins 3 or 4 out of 10. Walker 5.

Grenville wrote:Hilarious listening to Bickley give his player ratings on 5aa. Jenkins 3 or 4 out of 10. Walker 5.

No forward should be above a 4 after today's effort

mighty hounds wrote:i'm so gutted, this is going to hurt for a while

Another 20 years?

Brodlach wrote:
Well they are the pride of South Australia after all ..... and all that crap.

Not to mention the admiration of the nation...[/quote]
Will be if they win next Saturday[/quote]
Nup.. try again.

bennymacca wrote:I think they are playing close to their best and we are average.

No!

My player ratings (been crook so cannot drown my sorrows)


Laird 8
Sloane 7
Jacobs 6
Hartigan 6


Knight 4
Walker 3
Jenkins 1
Cameron 4
Betts 3
Brown 5
Lever 4
Kelly 4
Otten 2
B Couch 4
M Crouch 5
McKay 3
Douglas 4
Talia 5
Seedsman 2
Atkins 3
Lynch 3

Corona Man wrote:

Brodlach wrote:
Well they are the pride of South Australia after all ..... and all that crap.

Not to mention the admiration of the nation...

Will be if they win next Saturday[/quote]
Nup.. try again.[/quote]

Nice if you quoted that correctly in context

Suffered like many other minor premiers in 2017
SANFL Woodville West Torrens
SANFL Reserves Port
SANFL U18 South Adelaide
VFL Williamstown
NEAFL Sydney 2
WAFL Subiaco
AFL Adelaide Crows
Just seems that it was the 2017 trend and however good you were it wasn't going to happen
Not a good plan to bring your worst game for the year to the Grand Final

Brodlach wrote:

Corona Man wrote:

Brodlach wrote:
Well they are the pride of South Australia after all ..... and all that crap.

Not to mention the admiration of the nation...

Will be if they win next Saturday

Nup.. try again.[/quote]

Nice if you quoted that correctly in context[/quote]
Makes no difference.

bennymacca wrote:I thought castagna played alright too

none of those small forwards get many touches, but if they stop the opposition rebounding easily then they have done their job.

If we kick the ball out of the back half as well as we did against geelong i cant see us losing. Our skills were exceptional. But thats obviously where the pressure from Richmond plays a part

Run that by me again B Mac?

Reddeer wrote:Suffered like many other minor premiers in 2017
SANFL Woodville West Torrens
SANFL Reserves Port
SANFL U18 South Adelaide
VFL Williamstown
NEAFL Sydney 2
WAFL Subiaco
AFL Adelaide Crows
Just seems that it was the 2017 trend and however good you were it wasn't going to happen
Not a good plan to bring your worst game for the year to the Grand Final

Thought that was in Tassie v the Kangas but whatever...

Brodlach wrote:My player ratings (been crook so cannot drown my sorrows)


Laird 8
Sloane 7
Jacobs 6
Hartigan 6


Knight 4
Walker 3
Jenkins 1
Cameron 4
Betts 3
Brown 5
Lever 4
Kelly 4
Otten 2
B Couch 4
M Crouch 5
McKay 3
Douglas 4
Talia 5
Seedsman 2
Atkins 3
Lynch 3

Pretty bloody close mate. Certainly agree with your top 4 although I would've made it a 5 and added M.Crouch hence raising him to a 6. I'd drop at least 1 off of Douglas thought he was terrible and the touches he did have he turned over. Lever was terrible I really don't think you'll miss him that much he'd go to a 2 but the rest very close.

Just wasn't your day mate. It happens.

FWIW, I thought Richmond made them look slow. Cows played their worst game for the year. Walker did his usual 'go missing' when its there to be won. Can't say I'm disappointed with the result - suggest that the 'Karma Bus' just smashed into the Bandwagon. Shout out to Rob Chapman...

Corona Man wrote:

Reddeer wrote:Suffered like many other minor premiers in 2017
SANFL Woodville West Torrens
SANFL Reserves Port
SANFL U18 South Adelaide
VFL Williamstown
NEAFL Sydney 2
WAFL Subiaco
AFL Adelaide Crows
Just seems that it was the 2017 trend and however good you were it wasn't going to happen
Not a good plan to bring your worst game for the year to the Grand Final

Thought that was in Tassie v the Kangas but whatever...

They did kick 9 goals in Tasie

Reddeer wrote:

Corona Man wrote:

Reddeer wrote:Suffered like many other minor premiers in 2017
SANFL Woodville West Torrens
SANFL Reserves Port
SANFL U18 South Adelaide
VFL Williamstown
NEAFL Sydney 2
WAFL Subiaco
AFL Adelaide Crows
Just seems that it was the 2017 trend and however good you were it wasn't going to happen
Not a good plan to bring your worst game for the year to the Grand Final

Thought that was in Tassie v the Kangas but whatever...

They did kick 9 goals in Tasie

Against North.... Nuf said

Richmond were awesome in the second half, cows looked slow and deflated.
Cows were totally screwed by the umps in the first half.
Momentum means so much these days.
Well played AFL you dipsticks.
Remind me again why Geelong didn't get a home game.
Totally agree with an earlier poster, the worse display of the men in blue in a GF I've ever seen.
Totally unbiased opinion.
I'm a Roo supporter.
Said to my mate the other week they would never win a flag with Douglas and McKay in the side, been there long enough and have failed big time when it matters.

Wow, what a result. Tigers were magnificent, Crows so very poor. This Simpsons skit springs to mind at times like these:

LPH wrote:FWIW, I thought Richmond made them look slow. Cows played their worst game for the year. Walker did his usual 'go missing' when its there to be won. Can't say I'm disappointed with the result - suggest that the 'Karma Bus' just smashed into the Bandwagon. Shout out to Rob Chapman...

Lol

I wish David Burtenshaw would jump back on safooty........knob head

The next 12 months are going to be amazing

And to think. Jenkins is the highest payed player at the Crows.

LPH wrote:FWIW, I thought Richmond made them look slow. Cows played their worst game for the year. Walker did his usual 'go missing' when its there to be won. Can't say I'm disappointed with the result - suggest that the 'Karma Bus' just smashed into the Bandwagon. Shout out to Rob Chapman...

Shout out to Chappy... he can't hear you, he's a deaf as a post.