SA Footy

marbles wrote:Who in the crows finals 22 would u drop to fit in hartlett

mackay

helicopterking wrote:

marbles wrote:Who in the crows finals 22 would u drop to fit in hartlett

Cheney and McKay to name a couple.

Aside from the fact that Cheney plays a totally different role to Hartlett, he had a far better year than most give him credit for. Spent an awful amount of time prior to joining Adelaide playing as an undersized tall defender and predictably got exposed. Now he's settled into a far more suitable role and his game is improving as a result. More than happy to keep him in the starting side.

Mackay and Douglas would be high on the list IMHO. Plus there could well be one or two mids at the moment whose form or fitness might not demand selection.

If we got Hartlett (wont happen IMO), you would think Thommo will not go around again

MW wrote:If we got Hartlett (wont happen IMO), you would think Thommo will not go around again

I think it all depends on what happens with CEY/Lyons and if/who we bring in during trade period. We lose both "depth" mids and fail to bring in another mid then he is certain to go around again. We keep Lyons and bring in Gibbs for example then he retires.

Is Cheney uncontracted?

Pretty sure Cheney is contracted (and should be, thought he had a good season)

Thompson Henderson Lyons are the main ones that arent contracted yet

I'm miffed that Thompson is going around again, miffed I say.

Booney wrote:I'm miffed that Thompson is going around again, miffed I say.

Is he though?
Not signed yet...

MW wrote:

Booney wrote:I'm miffed that Thompson is going around again, miffed I say.

Is he though?
Not signed yet...

I had heard that, which surprised me. Surely he can't be assured a game at the top level in '17?

If Adel are going to get serious about this so called premiership window, he can't be.

MW wrote:If Adel are going to get serious about this so called premiership window, he can't be.

I agree. Thompson, Mackay, Brown and Douglas go to move forward.

Agree on all four but I am in the minority on Brown apparently. Maybe just don't notice the shut down work he does but he gets exposed on the quicker smalls, esp. Hawks.

MW wrote:Agree on all four but I am in the minority on Brown apparently. Maybe just don't notice the shut down work he does but he gets exposed on the quicker smalls, esp. Hawks.

Agreed, Brown is lock on our best 22.

Booney wrote:

Rik E Boy wrote:

Booney wrote:Hartlett more likely to end up in a Melbourne club than on the Gold Coast, more likely again to not go anywhere.

Bad luck. He's a skirt.

regards,

REB

By the look of it, you blokes will be wearing one soon.

Still wouldn't want him.

regards,

REB

listening to trade radio

Jack Frost has asked to be traded to Brisbane on a 3 year deal

bennymacca wrote:listening to trade radio

Jack Frost has asked to be traded to Brisbane on a 3 year deal

Yeah heard that.
Was interesting listening to Kane Cornes earlier who reckons Port have 9 players on $500k plus and need to find cap room.

Jim05 wrote:

bennymacca wrote:listening to trade radio

Jack Frost has asked to be traded to Brisbane on a 3 year deal

Yeah heard that.
Was interesting listening to Kane Cornes earlier who reckons Port have 9 players on $500k plus and need to find cap room.

Let's speculate then;

Ryder, Wines, Trengove, Boak, Wingard, Gray, Dixon, Ebert, Hombsch?

Hartlett took ( reportedly ) $200k less p.a. to stay at Port, so I'd think he'd be under $500k. Lobbe, with his 4 year deal, I doubt would be over $500k.

Hombsch would be massive overs for 500k

bennymacca wrote:Hombsch would be massive overs for 500k

Disagree, but that's fine, he is our #1 backman.

I can't think of anyone else I'd see that high, unless a bloke like Polec is front loaded or Westhoff back loaded.

Booney wrote:

bennymacca wrote:Hombsch would be massive overs for 500k

Disagree, but that's fine, he is our #1 backman.

I can't think of anyone else I'd see that high, unless a bloke like Polec is front loaded or Westhoff back loaded.

Hartlett $550k has been the talk.
North reportedly offered him $700k plus last time

Jim05 wrote:

Booney wrote:

bennymacca wrote:Hombsch would be massive overs for 500k

Disagree, but that's fine, he is our #1 backman.

I can't think of anyone else I'd see that high, unless a bloke like Polec is front loaded or Westhoff back loaded.

Hartlett $550k has been the talk.
North reportedly offered him $700k plus last time

North and Richmond were closer to offering $800k.