Trades/Drafts (Nov & PSD/Rookie) - 2015

[valleys07]

CARLTON has traded Troy Menzel to Adelaide in return for Sam Kerridge and pick No.28 in this year's NAB AFL Draft.

Genuine LOL, Carlton.

[Rik E Boy]

CARLTON has traded Troy Menzel to Adelaide in return for Sam Kerridge and pick No.28 in this year's NAB AFL Draft.

Pick 28 and Kerridge?? The clean out is on. I reckon Menzel goes OK.

regards,

REB

[HH3]

Word on the street that Brisbane are trying to cut Collingwood out of the Aish/Bastinac deal and just deal exclusively with North.

Bastinac, 38 & 40 for Aish & 17.

[Spargo]

Word on the street that Brisbane are trying to cut Collingwood out of the Aish/Bastinac deal and just deal exclusively with North.

Bastinac, 38 & 40 for Aish & 17.

Bring it.

[Rik E Boy]

Word on the street that Brisbane are trying to cut Collingwood out of the Aish/Bastinac deal and just deal exclusively with North.

Bastinac, 38 & 40 for Aish & 17.

Can't happen if Aish isn't happy with the trade.

regards,

REB

[GWW]

If time is running out, he may just be glad to get out of Brisbane.

[carey]

CARLTON has traded Troy Menzel to Adelaide in return for Sam Kerridge and pick No.28 in this year's NAB AFL Draft.

Pick 28 and Kerridge?? The clean out is on. I reckon Menzel goes OK.

regards,

REB

Wow. Carlton are f##ed.

[GWW]

Be interesting to see how the players go, who Carlton have recruited from GWS.

[Jim05]

Be interesting to see how the players go, who Carlton have recruited from GWS.

Classic lol by SOS. He had a million picks at GWS and **** a heap up now he moves to Carlton and re-drafts the duds he drafted in the first place

[bennymacca]

CARLTON has traded Troy Menzel to Adelaide in return for Sam Kerridge and pick No.28 in this year's NAB AFL Draft.

Pick 28 and Kerridge?? The clean out is on. I reckon Menzel goes OK.

regards,

REB

If his lars holds he should be really good.

Atkins and especially grigg would be a bit worried though as their opportunities seem more limited

[Booney]

DONE DEAL: Carlton's picks 28, 77 & 95 & Geelong's 2016 1st-Rd pick go to GWS for pick No.8, Plowman, Lamb, Phillips & Sumner.

[bennymacca]

Seems like a great deal for the blues

[Turbo]

Seems like a great deal for the blues

Menzel has heaps of potential but is unfortunately injury prone. His knee is suspect and he just had hip surgery. Hope he can string a few games together at the crows

[bennymacca]

Seems like a great deal for the blues

Menzel has heaps of potential but is unfortunately injury prone. His knee is suspect and he just had hip surgery. Hope he can string a few games together at the crows

Was talking about the other one involving the GWS lads.

But yeah I hope Menzel can stay on park

[Turbo]

Be interesting to see how the players go, who Carlton have recruited from GWS.

Classic lol by SOS. He had a million picks at GWS and **** a heap up now he moves to Carlton and re-drafts the duds he drafted in the first place

Think your hatred of Carlton clouds your judgment to an extent. Injuries, lack of opportunities and a larger list always meant that certain players would inevitably leave. Time will tell about the GWS4 and who we pick with no8. Weitering at 1 will be star.

We are building from the bottom. Something we've never done before as we've always gone for the quick fix.

Unfortunately there are no real absolutes..except maybe that we'll have number 1 pick in the super draft next year. Be prepared for Gibbs and/or Murphy to be trade bait next year for more picks.

[Turbo]

Seems like a great deal for the blues

Menzel has heaps of potential but is unfortunately injury prone. His knee is suspect and he just had hip surgery. Hope he can string a few games together at the crows

Was talking about the other one involving the GWS lads.

But yeah I hope Menzel can stay on park

Think there's a bit of potential with a couple of them

[Dutchy]

Collingwood should be hauled over the coals by the AFL for videoing Treloar in COllingwood colours before he was signed, disgrace.

The deal was done last week. There's a reason it won't be 'official' until tomorrow.

So he was a contracted Collingwood player when they taped the video then?

[Jim05]

Be interesting to see how the players go, who Carlton have recruited from GWS.

Classic lol by SOS. He had a million picks at GWS and **** a heap up now he moves to Carlton and re-drafts the duds he drafted in the first place

Think your hatred of Carlton clouds your judgment to an extent. Injuries, lack of opportunities and a larger list always meant that certain players would inevitably leave. Time will tell about the GWS4 and who we pick with no8. Weitering at 1 will be star.

We are building from the bottom. Something we've never done before as we've always gone for the quick fix.

Unfortunately there are no real absolutes..except maybe that we'll have number 1 pick in the super draft next year. Be prepared for Gibbs and/or Murphy to be trade bait next year for more picks.

Pick 8 is a good get and a couple of the GWS lads may turn it ok maybe. Lamb is very ordinary and its not Carlton im having a go at its SOS. He was the guy who took Plowman at pick 3 and injuries or otherwise he cant get into the GWS side. SOS aint the guru you Carlton believe he is, was hard to mess up a draft with a million top 10 picks gifted to him

[Q.]

Collingwood should be hauled over the coals by the AFL for videoing Treloar in COllingwood colours before he was signed, disgrace.

The deal was done last week. There's a reason it won't be 'official' until tomorrow.

So he was a contracted Collingwood player when they taped the video then?

Obviously not.

My point is nothing will come from it because the AFL have a finger in that Pie.

[Turbo]

Be interesting to see how the players go, who Carlton have recruited from GWS.

Classic lol by SOS. He had a million picks at GWS and **** a heap up now he moves to Carlton and re-drafts the duds he drafted in the first place

Think your hatred of Carlton clouds your judgment to an extent. Injuries, lack of opportunities and a larger list always meant that certain players would inevitably leave. Time will tell about the GWS4 and who we pick with no8. Weitering at 1 will be star.

We are building from the bottom. Something we've never done before as we've always gone for the quick fix.

Unfortunately there are no real absolutes..except maybe that we'll have number 1 pick in the super draft next year. Be prepared for Gibbs and/or Murphy to be trade bait next year for more picks.

Pick 8 is a good get and a couple of the GWS lads may turn it ok maybe. Lamb is very ordinary and its not Carlton im having a go at its SOS. He was the guy who took Plowman at pick 3 and injuries or otherwise he cant get into the GWS side. SOS aint the guru you Carlton believe he is, was hard to mess up a draft with a million top 10 picks gifted to him

Yeah fair enough.