A sedulous analysis of Round 16

[Booney]

Umpire tells Westhoff he saw the ball hit the ground except he was standing on the wrong side to see it. So basically guessed.
Why do teams not just get someone to go stand next to Hodge or Gibson when they stand loose in the back half . They carve you up.

3 possibilities here -

1. The Players on the ground are dumb as dog shit
2. The Coaching staff have no clue
3. All of the above

4. Hawthorn roll their zone around and not many clubs know how to counter it, that's why they're top.

[kneedeepinthehoopla]

Saints got out of jail today. Steven and Membrey important in the lacklustre win.

Former Redleg Fantasia looks a good sort for the Dons.

Redleg or Blood?

Norwood Premiership player

Gotcha
Carry on

[Dogwatcher]

The Pies average 81 points, the Giants 109. Where will the Pies find 7 goals? Probably not from the key forwards who while offering a bale out option don’t look like threatening any goal kicking records.

Collingwood have won the last 4 over GWS, time for that to change. GWS by 67 points. ( GWS $1.09 Collingwood $7.50 )

Correct analysis and looked to be heading in this direction - then the Giants fell asleep at quarter-time and those much, fairly, maligned forwards pulled things together. Frustrating to watch, because we should be able to do this more often.

[stan]

Cloke tore a game apart.
Kids are playing pokemon.

Stan had a big weelend, so the question is what year is it?

Honestly didnt see that coming from Collingwood.

[Booney]

How do you pick this one? ****. Geelong at home by 9. ( Geelong $1.45 Sydney $2.75 – Might be some value on the Swannies here )

There was indeed.

[woodublieve12]

How do you pick this one? ****. Geelong at home by 9. ( Geelong $1.45 Sydney $2.75 – Might be some value on the Swannies here )

There was indeed.

Swans actually blew out to over $3.

[Brodlach]

How do you pick this one? ****. Geelong at home by 9. ( Geelong $1.45 Sydney $2.75 – Might be some value on the Swannies here )

There was indeed.

Swans actually blew out to over $3.

I got $3.25

[PatowalongaPirate]

The new stadium in Perth can't come quick enough. The ferals that sit on the fence at Subiaco need to be as far from the players as possible. In case you missed it, go back and look at the tough guy who swung his arm at Petrie after he was pushed into the fence. Drink in one hand and swinging the other. Deadset moron.

[MW]

The new stadium in Perth can't come quick enough. The ferals that sit on the fence at Subiaco need to be as far from the players as possible. In case you missed it, go back and look at the tough guy who swung his arm at Petrie after he was pushed into the fence. Drink in one hand and swinging the other. Deadset moron.

Ah Perth, the city of cashed up bogans

[stan]

The new stadium in Perth can't come quick enough. The ferals that sit on the fence at Subiaco need to be as far from the players as possible. In case you missed it, go back and look at the tough guy who swung his arm at Petrie after he was pushed into the fence. Drink in one hand and swinging the other. Deadset moron.

Ah Perth, the city of cashed up bogans

Crowds in Perth have always been an issue. Im the first to admit that. A disgrace at times.

[Booney]

The new stadium in Perth can't come quick enough. The ferals that sit on the fence at Subiaco need to be as far from the players as possible. In case you missed it, go back and look at the tough guy who swung his arm at Petrie after he was pushed into the fence. Drink in one hand and swinging the other. Deadset moron.

Ah Perth, the city of cashed up bogans

Not anymore, they're now just in debt bogans with no mining to dig themselves out of it with.

If you're in the market for a boys toy, something like an older hot rod, a Harley or a V8 ute Perth is currently the place to shop. All the lads on big bucks brought up the toys and now with the bucks dried up they are getting rid of their flashy toys. I know one bloke who went over a brought a Monaro ( HK ) back as the price was too good to refuse.

[Brodlach]

Yet they showed great respect to the Adelaide FC and players a year ago.

[Booney]

Yet they showed great respect to the Adelaide FC and players a year ago.

They did indeed, one of the more touching things I've ever seen on a sporting field.

[stan]

Yet they showed great respect to the Adelaide FC and players a year ago.

They did indeed, one of the more touching things I've ever seen on a sporting field.

Thats true but that was our guys there slightly better than the wharf bogans from Freo [emoji12]

[Brodlach]

Yet they showed great respect to the Adelaide FC and players a year ago.

They did indeed, one of the more touching things I've ever seen on a sporting field.

Still gives me goosebumps thinking about it

[RustyCage]

On the umps, the theatrics and pausing are controlled by the AFL so they are doing what they're told. Also if they are no longer micced, you'd not know what the free was for and would make it worse

Exactly, you can't rely on the commentators to tell you what's going on, they're too busy with their egocentric drivel or ejaculating to Rioli's deliciousness

Sometimes what you hear from the umps is all the indication you get about what the free was for

[bennymacca]

I dont hate that they are mic'd as it can help to know what the hell they were thinking. lol.

All we want as fans is consistency with interpretations. Not just for 1 game but for a whole season.

[Corona Man]

I dont hate that they are mic'd as it can help to know what the hell they were thinking. lol.

All we want as fans is consistency with interpretations. Not just for 1 game but for a whole season.

Good luck with that.

[MW]

Yet they showed great respect to the Adelaide FC and players a year ago.

respectful (formerly) cashed up bogans

[hollywood7477]

Gee the Bombers have had a rough trot with the umps from what I've seen

Only in the last 10 minutes of the game. They were pretty poor all day both ways though

Ok. I only saw bits and pieces and then watched the last 8 mins. Every time I tuned in there was a horrible decision that went against the Bombers.


Sent from my XT1562 using Tapatalk

Umpiring at the moment is absolutely disgraceful across the board.

did you see the poor deliberate decision in the WCE v Roos game. Sheppherd is about to kick it gets pushed in the back ball rolls out of bounds and gets called deliberate. He wouldn't have kicked it out of bounds if he wasn't pushed in the back. absolute disgrace