Match Review Panel

[Squids]

There was no real malice in it. Was smart actually, since he could not get release the ball, IIRC Judd got a free for holding the ball. Not Judds problem the Adams has weak shoulders.

[NO-MERCY]

The media play things up big time, they love hanging blokes.

[Turbo]

Adams should have tapped.

Judd will get a fine.

Which is all it should be but those that love slaying champions and will make some ridiculous statements. That's ok, their opinion.
Have seen Rhys-Jones around the club recently. Maybe he's been passing on some tips

Doubt it, David was a thug and laid a lot of cheap hits but he was man enough to go toe to toe with most blokes aswell, if he had tried what Judd did I can guarantee he would have been belted by North players
Common theme amongst Judd's incidents is that his opponent is lying on the ground, reckon he would run the other way if he was confronted toe to toe

I was only joking anyway. Completely different characters. Toe to toe I reckon there are heaps that would be soft

[The Sleeping Giant]

There was no real malice in it. Was smart actually, since he could not get release the ball, IIRC Judd got a free for holding the ball. Not Judds problem the Adams has weak shoulders.

You recall incorrectly. Judd got a free when the North players reacted to the low act.

[cokadonkeytoo]

If Judd doesn't get any games for what he did then the afl needs to have a good hard look at themselves. I'm sick of seeing guys like judd, Franklin and swan getting free rides from the match review panel. What Judd did was not needed and totally unacceptable.

[The Sleeping Giant]

The media play things up big time, they love hanging blokes.

Could of sworn all I heard was a love fest towards Judd in the media last night. The only thing I have read today is the media reporting what happened. How is that hanging a bloke?

[Psyber]

There was no real malice in it. Was smart actually, since he could not get release the ball, IIRC Judd got a free for holding the ball. Not Judds problem the Adams has weak shoulders.

It doesn't take a lot of force to dislocate a shoulder, even a strong one, if you know how - it is just angle and leverage.
On the TV close up Judd looked like he knew how, and had two goes at getting the result.
He should go big time for it!

[mighty_tiger_79]

There was no real malice in it. Was smart actually, since he could not get release the ball, IIRC Judd got a free for holding the ball. Not Judds problem the Adams has weak shoulders.

It doesn't take a lot of force to dislocate a shoulder, even a strong one, if you know how - it is just angle and leverage.
On the TV close up Judd looked like he knew how, and had two goes at getting the result.
He should go big time for it!

as Fevola has pointed out Steven Seagal went for a pressure point approach with the arm twisting

[Brad]

If someone did the same to Judd all you Carlton supporters would be screaming blue murder! If he gets off then I am convinced the system is rigged, Judd should have been sighted and suspended for his elbow to Matthew Pavlich's head in 2010 which was never sighted...

[Spargo]

Just a coincidence that the elbow to Brown, the pressure point, the eye gauging and now last night's gutless act all occured whilst being at carlton?
Was he ever reported/sighted/suspended at west coast?

[Sorry Dude]

Just a coincidence that the elbow to Brown, the pressure point, the eye gauging and now last night's gutless act all occured whilst being at carlton?
Was he ever reported/sighted/suspended at west coast?

he was at the eagles for the eye gouge!

[Jim05]

Just a coincidence that the elbow to Brown, the pressure point, the eye gauging and now last night's gutless act all occured whilst being at carlton?
Was he ever reported/sighted/suspended at west coast?

he was at the eagles for the eye gouge!

Only the first one

[daysofourlives]

Just a coincidence that the elbow to Brown, the pressure point, the eye gauging and now last night's gutless act all occured whilst being at carlton?
Was he ever reported/sighted/suspended at west coast?

he was at the eagles for the eye gouge!

Only the first one

OMG How many times has he eye gouged someone

[PatowalongaPirate]

There was no real malice in it. Was smart actually, since he could not get release the ball, IIRC Judd got a free for holding the ball. Not Judds problem the Adams has weak shoulders.

A contender for most ridiculous post of the year.

[Spargo]

There was no real malice in it. Was smart actually, since he could not get release the ball, IIRC Judd got a free for holding the ball. Not Judds problem the Adams has weak shoulders.

A contender for most ridiculous post of the year.

post or postER ?

[Punk Rooster]

There was no real malice in it. Was smart actually, since he could not get release the ball, IIRC Judd got a free for holding the ball. Not Judds problem the Adams has weak shoulders.

No real malice in it. Wellingham was just protecting himself prior to the collision. Not Wellinghams problem that Simpson has a glass jaw...

[am Bays]

There was no real malice in it. Was smart actually, since he could not get release the ball, IIRC Judd got a free for holding the ball. Not Judds problem the Adams has weak shoulders.

No real malice in it. Wellingham was just protecting himself prior to the collision. Not Wellinghams problem that Simpson has a glass jaw...

What are you doing on here, aren't you supposed to be watching a replay of the 1989 GF at Prospect?

[Punk Rooster]

There was no real malice in it. Was smart actually, since he could not get release the ball, IIRC Judd got a free for holding the ball. Not Judds problem the Adams has weak shoulders.

No real malice in it. Wellingham was just protecting himself prior to the collision. Not Wellinghams problem that Simpson has a glass jaw...

What are you doing on here, aren't you supposed to be watching a replay of the 1989 GF at Prospect?

busy arming myself at the moment, as this is what I have in mind-

[Booney]

There was no real malice in it. Was smart actually, since he could not get release the ball, IIRC Judd got a free for holding the ball. Not Judds problem the Adams has weak shoulders.

A contender for most ridiculous post of the year.

I'm with you mate.

"Not Judds problem Adams has weak shoulders"....news for you mate, it is Judds problem because he did what he did and it might be his problem for the next 3 or 4 weeks.

Very low act on a bloke who was defenceless, that is my biggest issue, Adams could offer no resistence and Judd knew it.

[overloaded]

If someone did the same to Judd all you Carlton supporters would be screaming blue murder! If he gets off then I am convinced the system is rigged, Judd should have been sighted and suspended for his elbow to Matthew Pavlich's head in 2010 which was never sighted...

Like last week with Simpson?