SA Footy

Actual rumor.

Is that different from a rumor rumor?

MW wrote:

Brodlach wrote:Really MW?

Brad needs to get in the park but how much blame goes to our medical staff?

Yeah true.
I think either way if we keep him or do that trade we will not lose.
Brad's history of injuries have been horrific. Zero games in 2015 and 2018 plus interrupted seasons in the others. Will he ever be up for 22+ rounds of footy in a year?

O’Meara didn’t play 15/16 and went to the hawks for 2 first rounders. The level Brad can play at is absolute A grade, I’d be disappointed if it wasn’t a straight swap for a pick 4 and definitely wouldn’t agree with giving up brad and a first rounder for 4. Essentially what you’re saying is you’re happy for Brad to be traded for pick 23.

hawks21 wrote:

Bonney wrote:

MW wrote:

Bonney wrote:Brad Crouch won't play for Adelaide again. Mark my words.

D-

St Kilda give pick 4

Adelaide give Crouch and 13.

Actual rumour or what you'd do Bonney?

There's a new one, it's gonna stick

MW wrote:

Brodlach wrote:Really MW?

Brad needs to get in the park but how much blame goes to our medical staff?

Yeah true.
I think either way if we keep him or do that trade we will not lose.
Brad's history of injuries have been horrific. Zero games in 2015 and 2018 plus interrupted seasons in the others. Will he ever be up for 22+ rounds of footy in a year?

That's a risk you take. If he does get on the park and then he might wbe in the same ball park as O'Meara in terms of ouput (only speculating based on the draft he was from etc etc).

So I guess do you want pick 4 that bad or do hope that Crouch gets his body right.

Absolutely a massive boost to your midfield with him on the park. Crouches x 2, Gibbs and Sloane. Looks solid. But it's an if and a risk of course.

stan wrote:

MW wrote:

Brodlach wrote:Really MW?

Brad needs to get in the park but how much blame goes to our medical staff?

Yeah true.
I think either way if we keep him or do that trade we will not lose.
Brad's history of injuries have been horrific. Zero games in 2015 and 2018 plus interrupted seasons in the others. Will he ever be up for 22+ rounds of footy in a year?

That's a risk you take. If he does get on the park and then he might wbe in the same ball park as O'Meara in terms of ouput (only speculating based on the draft he was from etc etc).

So I guess do you want pick 4 that bad or do hope that Crouch gets his body right.

Absolutely a massive boost to your midfield with him on the park. Crouches x 2, Gibbs and Sloane. Looks solid. But it's an if and a risk of course.

Not sure about solid, but it looks slow.

Booney wrote:

stan wrote:

MW wrote:

Brodlach wrote:Really MW?

Brad needs to get in the park but how much blame goes to our medical staff?

Yeah true.
I think either way if we keep him or do that trade we will not lose.
Brad's history of injuries have been horrific. Zero games in 2015 and 2018 plus interrupted seasons in the others. Will he ever be up for 22+ rounds of footy in a year?

That's a risk you take. If he does get on the park and then he might wbe in the same ball park as O'Meara in terms of ouput (only speculating based on the draft he was from etc etc).

So I guess do you want pick 4 that bad or do hope that Crouch gets his body right.

Absolutely a massive boost to your midfield with him on the park. Crouches x 2, Gibbs and Sloane. Looks solid. But it's an if and a risk of course.

Not sure about solid, but it looks slow.

A lot of good ball wining ability in there. And they'll land Rankine and Rozee for some additional pace.

Not at pick 8 they won't.

Carlton - Walsh
GC - Lukosius
GC - Rankine/Rozee
St Kilda - ??
Brisbane - ??
Port - Rozee or Rankine if he's there.

King x 2 will go top 8 and throw in Bailey Smith

Brodlach wrote:King x 2 will go top 8 and throw in Bailey Smith

I think St Kilda will take a Vic lad, they know they're going to be shit for a while yet so they won't take any go home risks. Perhaps one of the King brothers, they need KPP.

Brisbane will back themselves in to make the place one worth staying at over the next 3-5 years. Midfield is good, they are going to (?) add Neale, do they go the other King?

Booney wrote:

MW wrote:

Booney wrote:Brad Crouch won't play for Adelaide again. Mark my words.

D-

St Kilda give pick 4

Adelaide give Crouch and 13.

IMHO if such a deal were on offer, Adelaide would be nuts not to take that.

Crouch is a good, but not great player. You do notice how much better he looks when he can string a decent number of games together, but whilst he's good at finding the ball, tackles well and has good size, he's not quick and he's far from elite by foot. Then there's the injury concerns ...

The Bedge wrote:Dangerfield leaves - we are better side without him, Sloane is better.
Lever leaves - Kelly is better
McGovern leaves - Over rated, injury prone, don’t need him, got the Fog
Kelly leaves - Doedee is better

You forgot Cameron left. He’s shit can’t kick- we have Milera

So much salt!

MW wrote:So much salt!

Haha not salty, these are legit comments that come from the masses of apricot slicers.

hollywood7477 wrote:

The Bedge wrote:Dangerfield leaves - we are better side without him, Sloane is better.
Lever leaves - Kelly is better
McGovern leaves - Over rated, injury prone, don’t need him, got the Fog
Kelly leaves - Doedee is better

You forgot Cameron left. He’s shit can’t kick- we have Milera

The Tippet one must of cut deep though, booed at the Airport

Booney wrote:Brad Crouch won't play for Adelaide again. Mark my words.

Is this still going ahead Booney? Running out of time.

hawks21 wrote:

Booney wrote:Brad Crouch won't play for Adelaide again. Mark my words.

Is this still going ahead Booney? Running out of time.

St Kilda were the ones....

Booney wrote:

hawks21 wrote:

Booney wrote:Brad Crouch won't play for Adelaide again. Mark my words.

Is this still going ahead Booney? Running out of time.

St Kilda were the ones....

And St Kilda have pick 4...

PatowalongaPirate wrote:

Booney wrote:

hawks21 wrote:

Booney wrote:Brad Crouch won't play for Adelaide again. Mark my words.

Is this still going ahead Booney? Running out of time.

St Kilda were the ones....

And St Kilda have pick 4...

No way we giving up pick 4 for Crouch

Crouch + Pick 8 to St Kilda for pick 4.

Crows then take whichever SA lad is left after GC take 2 of them with pick's 2 & 3 (Lukocious, Rankine Rozee).

Then Port use pick 5 on....ummmm....hmmmmmm......

PatowalongaPirate wrote:Crouch + Pick 8 to St Kilda for pick 4.

Crows then take whichever SA lad is left after GC take 2 of them with pick's 2 & 3 (Lukocious, Rankine Rozee).

Then Port use pick 5 on....ummmm....hmmmmmm......

Bailey Smith, Tarryn Thomas, Ian Hill...it's hard to believe, I know, but there's some talent outside of SA too!