Mike Sheahan's Top 50

[CoverKing]

Does anyone know how he picks his top 50. Is it based on potential, or if picking a team or based on everyone at their best. Best 50 for this upcoming season or what?? For me Matthew Boyd is a big surprise not to be in at all.

I think it is based on past performances and potential. Pretty much the order where he thinks they'll be at the end of the year i think

[Turbo]

The ones on the top 50 list you Carlton arse clowns.

Looking forward to another Carlton fail season.

Good.

[Squids]

Enjoy your asterix premiership tsg

[The Sleeping Giant]

I don't follow norwood.

[FroffiesMcVeigh]

Does anyone know how he picks his top 50. Is it based on potential, or if picking a team or based on everyone at their best. Best 50 for this upcoming season or what?? For me Matthew Boyd is a big surprise not to be in at all.

I think it is based on past performances and potential. Pretty much the order where he thinks they'll be at the end of the year i think

So you think it's based on their past, present and future? I think it's based on they how they have their steaks cooked.

[UK Fan]

Its Time for Ken Mcgregors top 10 duds of afl.

[Wedgie]

Who the hell is Trent Cotchin and why do so many people rate him?
He'd be lucky to make the Cats best 18!

[Squids]

Who the hell is Trent Cotchin and why do so many people rate him?
He'd be lucky to make the Cats best 18!

[Hondo]

Wedgie, Cotchin is equal favourite for the 2013 Brownlow medal. I think he goes alright or you were stirring us up?

[CoverKing]

Wedgie, Cotchin is equal favourite for the 2013 Brownlow medal. I think he goes alright or you were stirring us up?

Also runner up in last years brownlow IIRC

[The Sleeping Giant]

Who the hell is Trent Cotchin and why do so many people rate him?
He'd be lucky to make the Cats best 18!

One of Richmond's better players so yeah, he would struggle to make the cats side. ;-)

[scoob]

Would anyone select Dangerfield in their side before Franklin, Swan, Watson or even Cotchin???

I would even pick Scott Thompson before Dangerfield

Terrible call

Scott Thompson rolls up every week and plays 4 quarters every week, you know what you are going to get – hence I would pick him before PD

[nolongerthere]

Would anyone select Dangerfield in their side before Franklin, Swan, Watson or even Cotchin???

I would even pick Scott Thompson before Dangerfield

Terrible call

Scott Thompson rolls up every week and plays 4 quarters every week, you know what you are going to get – hence I would pick him before PD

Thommos a good player but he turns the ball over a bit

[scoob]

Thompson won the B&F last year, PD was runner's up... not too bad of indication of where they are at and how they were assessed by the coaching staff. It is certainly not a terrible call as mentioned by some posters on here.

[Turbo]

Taking the pi$$ I'd suggest

[hottie]

I know alot of people on this site dont like the advertiser but its been hilarious,it now starts with Mikes top 50 but has other x-players or journalist given their top 50 each day in the paper.

[GWW]

The top 50 lists are just a promotion for "Super Coach".

[gutterboy]

tex played like someone thats rated out of the top 50 he should be....god knows why so many people rate him so highly....his no superstar and never been close..i'm not blaming him either its the media that has pumped him up...he hasnt done a thing yet to even consider himself to be in front of the guys like bartell etc...

[The Sleeping Giant]

The mullet is worth 40 ranking points.