Judd or Chapman

[lebron]

Judd - end of thread!

[Rik E Boy]

Chapman. Stronger, a better kick, better contested mark, better shot for goal. Judd has him covered for pace and acceleration and is perhaps slightly ahead in endurance but overall Chapman is the more complete package.

regards,

REB

[Mr Beefy]

One point of difference is we have seen how Judd performs in a struggling team, very very well still. Fortunatly for Chapman since he become established as an AFL regular Geelong have been an extremly good side, would he be the same player if Geelong slid and become an average side?

Chapman won a B&F in 2006 when, if I remember correctly, we had a crap year

[White Line Fever]

Both great players, hard to put side by side and say one is better.

I voted Judd as I like his acceleration in traffic away from packs, ability to win the unwinnable ball & the way he keeps his feet.

Chappy is a better finisher than Judd because he spends more time there.
Wouldn't have the same tank as Judd but would certainly outmark him.

Good poll.

[beef]

I really don't like watching Judd play, I find him to be a dirty player who gets away with it but if you touch him he gets a free kick. Tribunal love him as he gets away with eye gauging (never liked him since that dirty act). Can't kick a set shot at goal either.

Chapman any day.

Got three weeks for that incident, so wouldnt say tribunal love him.

Judd clearly better, the poll is asking who is better not who does the commentators love the most, i even hate the way the media say he is god-like. Surely people can judge who is better by watching and not listening to the tv/radio, Chapman still a very good player but not in judds league, Chapman prob not even best player in his team.