Brisbane Season 2009

[catchit]

One was a brain fade, the other was an ill-timed contest. Chaplin arrived a mere split second after the ball and was already in the air when Rich marked it.

pretty sure you no when you are going to arrive a bit late... he didnt do what he intended to do cause rich played on..
stupid sort of somes it up!!!

[Booney]

Perhaps if he was Superman, he could have stopped in mid-air?

[Pac-Man]

I honestly believe that if Josh Carr wasnt a bleeder , Brenan would of got off with a reprimand with his clean sheet.

Because he bled it looked far worse then what it really was. Was nothing more then a love tap.

[Baron Greenback]

Na Brennan deserved to get suspended.
Was a stupid thing to do, particularly with the Lions in that position on the scoreboard.

[catchit]

Perhaps if he was Superman, he could have stopped in mid-air?

if he was superman he would of picked a better club to play for!!!

before he decided to leave the ground he knew what he was going to do... but like i said it didnt work..
there could only be 2 outcomes of his decision.. 1st is rich gets stretchered off... 2nd is rich is lucky!!

[Booney]

Perhaps if he was Superman, he could have stopped in mid-air?

if he was superman he would of picked a better club to play for!!!

before he decided to leave the ground he knew what he was going to do... but like i said it didnt work..
there could only be 2 outcomes of his decision.. 1st is rich gets stretchered off... 2nd is rich is lucky!!

Players dont pick the club mate, clubs pick the players!

Before he decided to leave the ground? Yeah, stay out of a contest altogether so your coach and team mates think you're going half hearted.

What are you blokes watching? FFS...

[dedja]

Must be this Booney ... http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ml3ybCxxMRk

They live in that world.

[catchit]

Perhaps if he was Superman, he could have stopped in mid-air?

if he was superman he would of picked a better club to play for!!!

before he decided to leave the ground he knew what he was going to do... but like i said it didnt work..
there could only be 2 outcomes of his decision.. 1st is rich gets stretchered off... 2nd is rich is lucky!!

Players dont pick the club mate, clubs pick the players!

Before he decided to leave the ground? Yeah, stay out of a contest altogether so your coach and team mates think you're going half hearted.

What are you blokes watching? FFS...

did carlton pick judd?? now thats superman for you..

you are right go in like that and get 2 games coaches love that.. there is a diff from going in hard and being silly...

[Dirko]

did carlton pick judd?? now thats superman for you..

[Booney]

Perhaps if he was Superman, he could have stopped in mid-air?

if he was superman he would of picked a better club to play for!!!

before he decided to leave the ground he knew what he was going to do... but like i said it didnt work..
there could only be 2 outcomes of his decision.. 1st is rich gets stretchered off... 2nd is rich is lucky!!

Players dont pick the club mate, clubs pick the players!

Before he decided to leave the ground? Yeah, stay out of a contest altogether so your coach and team mates think you're going half hearted.

What are you blokes watching? FFS...

did carlton pick judd?? now thats superman for you..
you are right go in like that and get 2 games coaches love that.. there is a diff from going in hard and being silly...

You knwo what I meant when I said players dont choose clubs ( when they get drafted ,like Chaplin was to Port ).

I find it hard to believe you actually think that staying out of a contest when your 90kg+ running flat out is easy to do?

[catchit]

i am hearing you with the point you are making but i would also add that when you take your eyes off the ball to go in like he did is just stupid.. if he kept his eyes on the ball i am sure the coach would be patting him on the back, instead of sitting in the coachs box for the next 2 weeks with him IMO.. there was only one courageous player and that was a 19 year old kid..

[catchit]

did carlton pick judd?? now thats superman for you..

and yes i still feel the pain is was like one of the days where you remember where you were when hearing of the news

[Booney]

IMO he was off the ground when he realised he was not going to be the first to the ball and then protected himself while doing what he could to avoid any more damage than was unavoidable to Rich.

I think the way the Brisbane players reacted shows they too knew it was a "football collision".

[saveyourlegs]

i am hearing you with the point you are making but i would also add that when you take your eyes off the ball to go in like he did is just stupid.. if he kept his eyes on the ball i am sure the coach would be patting him on the back, instead of sitting in the coachs box for the next 2 weeks with him IMO.. there was only one courageous player and that was a 19 year old kid..

Spot on catchit, he should get 1 or 2 games. imo

[catchit]

IMO he was off the ground when he realised he was not going to be the first to the ball and then protected himself while doing what he could to avoid any more damage than was unavoidable to Rich.

I think the way the Brisbane players reacted shows they too knew it was a "football collision".

seriously have a look on utube under chaplin bump.. look at the replay at 34 seconds and come back and tell me if chaplin is looking at the ball before he leaves the ground??

[dedja]

Just wondering, how many of you guys have actually played footy?

[catchit]

Just wondering, how many of you guys have actually played footy?

my grandma hasnt and she reckons chaplin is a silly boy
are you telling me someone has to play the game to be able to tell when to look at the ball??
to be fair if it was a west coast player i would be saying the same as booney

[catchit]

Just wondering, how many of you guys have actually played footy?

your not graham cornes are you??

[dedja]

to be fair if it was a west coast player i would be saying the same as booney

Case closed then

[catchit]

to be fair if it was a west coast player i would be saying the same as booney

Case closed then

to true... but my point was it is easy to be one eyed in a situation like this