morell wrote:Neade - reject
Howard - ill give you that one, still a kid though
Bonner - kid
Marshall - toddler
So really, Summerton and Eddy are the only 'senior' footballers on that list of any consistent quality aren't kids, rejects or has beens. You're trying to argue that this side is good right?
I recall SANFL supporters arguing that these kids getting games when they shouldn't ruins the SANFL because they're getting gifts.
These blokes were good enough to play in the AFL Elimination final, but no good for SANFL?
Robbie Young - he's 22yrs old, not sure you can call him a reject.
Ah Chee was runner up in the Magarey Medal.
White, Lobbe might be has been's but they're still very handy at SANFL level.
The "reject" claim is a really stupid one - they may be "rejects" from AFL level, does not make them an lesser of a footballer, and does not mean they aren't still very good at SANFL level.
It's like having a junior at your club who plays underage SANFL - they may not play each week, but bet you wouldn't turn them away at Mitchell Park because they're "rejects".. nope, they'd probably still be in your top group of players.