SA Footy

Agreed

O'Shea goneski.

Neade signed a 2 year extension mid season, so he wont be going anywhere as I doubt anyone would take his contract on.

Great to see Bonner and Snelling get games.

Snelling has been ripping it up at SANFL level in the contested stakes, and Bonner has put 4-5 weeks together of really consistent footy.

Anyone know what it costs the club to upgrade someone from the Rookie list to the Senior list?

Questioning if it is worth the cost in order to give Snelling a game...

valleys07 wrote:Great to see Bonner and Snelling get games.

Snelling has been ripping it up at SANFL level in the contested stakes, and Bonner has put 4-5 weeks together of really consistent footy.

Anyone know what it costs the club to upgrade someone from the Rookie list to the Senior list?

Questioning if it is worth the cost in order to give Snelling a game...

If your talking about list changes at the end of a season In think its a draft pck but like a 5th or 6th rounder that normally gets used.

Sorry Stan I should have been more specific.

I meant the cost to do it mid season.

Westies need all the money we can get so I hope it's a lot

Wouldn't be payment to Westies, Brod. It would be payment to the AFL.

valleys07 wrote:Sorry Stan I should have been more specific.

I meant the cost to do it mid season.

Dunno. Slab of beer?

No new contract for Schultz. Not a massive surprise to be honest

Poor lad thinks someone else will take him. Sorry Jay, retire with some dignity mate.

You never know. Someone may offer him a year deal, transitioning into a development role.

valleys07 wrote:You never know. Someone may offer him a year deal, transitioning into a development role.

Not an AFL club. I don't see him in anyone's best 22 next year and he'd just cost a team a spot that could go to a kid. He fell of a cliff this year and I just don't see how he could contribute on field.

Grahaml wrote:

valleys07 wrote:You never know. Someone may offer him a year deal, transitioning into a development role.

Not an AFL club. I don't see him in anyone's best 22 next year and he'd just cost a team a spot that could go to a kid. He fell of a cliff this year and I just don't see how he could contribute on field.

Yeah, he's no Nathan Van Berlo after all......

Is it true port are that desperate to retain fans next season they aren't going to ban the banana thrower ???

Ruben Carter wrote:

Grahaml wrote:

valleys07 wrote:You never know. Someone may offer him a year deal, transitioning into a development role.

Not an AFL club. I don't see him in anyone's best 22 next year and he'd just cost a team a spot that could go to a kid. He fell of a cliff this year and I just don't see how he could contribute on field.

Yeah, he's no Nathan Van Berlo after all......

What a strange comment.

Not really, it's the Port supporter way when someone offers a balanced opinion of their player, they attack a player from the club you support.

valleys07 wrote:Wouldn't be payment to Westies, Brod. It would be payment to the AFL.

SANFL clubs get a payment after they play their first AFL game

Ruben Carter wrote:

Grahaml wrote:

valleys07 wrote:You never know. Someone may offer him a year deal, transitioning into a development role.

Not an AFL club. I don't see him in anyone's best 22 next year and he'd just cost a team a spot that could go to a kid. He fell of a cliff this year and I just don't see how he could contribute on field.

Yeah, he's no Nathan Van Berlo after all......

Do you watch your colour TV in black and white? FFS every time, whether positive Or negative, someone comments on Port that doesn't barrack for them you feel the need to fire back. Most normal people would agree with Grahaml

Brodlach wrote:

Ruben Carter wrote:

Grahaml wrote:

valleys07 wrote:You never know. Someone may offer him a year deal, transitioning into a development role.

Not an AFL club. I don't see him in anyone's best 22 next year and he'd just cost a team a spot that could go to a kid. He fell of a cliff this year and I just don't see how he could contribute on field.

Yeah, he's no Nathan Van Berlo after all......

Do you watch your colour TV in black and white? FFS every time, whether positive Or negative, someone comments on Port that doesn't barrack for them you feel the need to fire back. Most normal people would agree with Grahaml

#massivechiponshoulder

MW wrote:Not really, it's the Port supporter way when someone offers a balanced opinion of their player, they attack a player from the club you support.

Sorry ladies, I didn't mean to offend you.
I agree Schultz is past it, after last week's performance he has to be retired.
I compared him to VB because I think the same applies to him - game has past him by. Anyway, just my opinion as a passionate PA fan.
UK fan, get a life !