AFL - Round 4 discussion - (and lives scores)

[The Sleeping Giant]

MRP FINDINGS

Neville Jetta - 2 weeks
Pearce Hanley - 1 week
Steve Morris - 1 week
Stephen Milne - 1 week

D. Petrie E. McKenzie, S. Thompson, A. Saad and J. Redden have been cleared.

Nathan Wright, Tom Simpkin, Ahmed Saad, Jarryn Geary can all accept $1200 for a 1st offence for engaging in a melee.

Tom Bellchambers, Michael Hibberd, Jake Carlisle can all accept $2100 sanction for a 2nd offence for engaging in a melee.

Stephen Milne can accept $3000 sanction for a 3rd offence for engaging in a melee.

How did Steve Johnson get away with clouting Mattner? Van Berlo was found guilty the other week for something that could be deemed accidental.

[howzat]

MRP FINDINGS

Neville Jetta - 2 weeks
Pearce Hanley - 1 week
Steve Morris - 1 week
Stephen Milne - 1 week

D. Petrie E. McKenzie, S. Thompson, A. Saad and J. Redden have been cleared.

Nathan Wright, Tom Simpkin, Ahmed Saad, Jarryn Geary can all accept $1200 for a 1st offence for engaging in a melee.

Tom Bellchambers, Michael Hibberd, Jake Carlisle can all accept $2100 sanction for a 2nd offence for engaging in a melee.

Stephen Milne can accept $3000 sanction for a 3rd offence for engaging in a melee.

How did Steve Johnson get away with clouting Mattner? Van Berlo was found guilty the other week for something that could be deemed accidental.

TSG dont know what game you were watching stevie j did nothing lol

[lincolnsdirtysecrets]

Time for Milne to hang up the boots. Keeping a kid out of the game while he does nothing

[Rik E Boy]

MRP FINDINGS

Neville Jetta - 2 weeks
Pearce Hanley - 1 week
Steve Morris - 1 week
Stephen Milne - 1 week

D. Petrie E. McKenzie, S. Thompson, A. Saad and J. Redden have been cleared.

Nathan Wright, Tom Simpkin, Ahmed Saad, Jarryn Geary can all accept $1200 for a 1st offence for engaging in a melee.

Tom Bellchambers, Michael Hibberd, Jake Carlisle can all accept $2100 sanction for a 2nd offence for engaging in a melee.

Stephen Milne can accept $3000 sanction for a 3rd offence for engaging in a melee.

How did Steve Johnson get away with clouting Mattner? Van Berlo was found guilty the other week for something that could be deemed accidental.

BWAHAHAHA. You're ******* kidding right? Even Lindsay Thomas wouldn't have hit the deck from that love tap. You couldn't blame him though, even though we were getting every free kick under the sun the umpires thought it was permissible for a Swans defender to sit on his chest when the friggin ball was miles away. Stevie boy if you stop playing for the frees you might actually win some more ball and the odd whistle!

Oh, did I forget to say BWAAHAHAHAHA. Even the Rugby fans up there knew there was nothing in that.

regards,

REB

[Johno6]

Wasn't Johnson holding him down at the start?
Can someone post the footage?

[The Sleeping Giant]

MRP FINDINGS

Neville Jetta - 2 weeks
Pearce Hanley - 1 week
Steve Morris - 1 week
Stephen Milne - 1 week

D. Petrie E. McKenzie, S. Thompson, A. Saad and J. Redden have been cleared.

Nathan Wright, Tom Simpkin, Ahmed Saad, Jarryn Geary can all accept $1200 for a 1st offence for engaging in a melee.

Tom Bellchambers, Michael Hibberd, Jake Carlisle can all accept $2100 sanction for a 2nd offence for engaging in a melee.

Stephen Milne can accept $3000 sanction for a 3rd offence for engaging in a melee.

How did Steve Johnson get away with clouting Mattner? Van Berlo was found guilty the other week for something that could be deemed accidental.

BWAHAHAHA. You're ******* kidding right? Even Lindsay Thomas wouldn't have hit the deck from that love tap. You couldn't blame him though, even though we were getting every free kick under the sun the umpires thought it was permissible for a Swans defender to sit on his chest when the friggin ball was miles away. Stevie boy if you stop playing for the frees you might actually win some more ball and the odd whistle!

Oh, did I forget to say BWAAHAHAHAHA. Even the Rugby fans up there knew there was nothing in that.

regards,

REB

You have missed the point reb. Van Berlo was found guilty of trying to punch the ball. I guess it's just another case of inconsistency from the mrp.

And Lindsay Thomas would have played a coma on that one for a free kick.

[lincolnsdirtysecrets]

Lindsay Thomas really annoys me the way he plays for frees. Why does he do it?

Is there anyone worse in the league than him do you think at it?

[Jim05]

Lindsay Thomas really annoys me the way he plays for frees. Why does he do it?

Is there anyone worse in the league than him do you think at it?

Buddy is good at milking frees but atleast he goes hard at it
Thomas is by far the worst, dishes out cheap punches and flops when someone brushes him with a fingernail. Would love to see someone do a Barry Hall on him and just whack him

[daysofourlives]

Lindsay Thomas really annoys me the way he plays for frees. Why does he do it?

Is there anyone worse in the league than him do you think at it?

Buddy is good at milking frees but atleast he goes hard at it
Thomas is by far the worst, dishes out cheap punches and flops when someone brushes him with a fingernail. Would love to see someone do a Barry Hall on him and just whack him

He's no different to a former Bomber Brownlow meadallist but that was ok, he was in an Essendon jumper

[Jim05]

Lindsay Thomas really annoys me the way he plays for frees. Why does he do it?

Is there anyone worse in the league than him do you think at it?

Buddy is good at milking frees but atleast he goes hard at it
Thomas is by far the worst, dishes out cheap punches and flops when someone brushes him with a fingernail. Would love to see someone do a Barry Hall on him and just whack him

He's no different to a former Bomber Brownlow meadallist but that was ok, he was in an Essendon jumper

Not true, I was always having a crack at Lloydy for diving but no way Hirdy was

[Squids]

Wanganeen

[Spargo]

Wanganeen

10x the actor after he went to port.

[FOURTH ESTATE]

He carried on like he was Bambi who had been shot!!!!

[Ruben Carter]

All true - he certainly benefitted from umpiring decisions at times, that was a skill in itself when Gav played - wouldn't work these days. Perhaps he got some of the frees that Tredrea never got; but should have. Anyway nobody should question Wanganeen's courage or football ability. He was one of the all time great AFL stars - for both Essendon & Port. (Despite some diving)

[Killa]

Lindsay Thomas really annoys me the way he plays for frees. Why does he do it?

Is there anyone worse in the league than him do you think at it?

He has not changed over the years. Was doing the same stuff back in primary school for augusta park primary on Friday afternoons.

[Spargo]

Lindsay Thomas really annoys me the way he plays for frees. Why does he do it?

Is there anyone worse in the league than him do you think at it?

He has not changed over the years. Was doing the same stuff back in primary school for augusta park primary on Friday afternoons.

His teachers always said he'd amount to nothing

[Rik E Boy]

You have missed the point reb. Van Berlo was found guilty of trying to punch the ball. I guess it's just another case of inconsistency from the mrp.

And Lindsay Thomas would have played a coma on that one for a free kick.

So you don't believe that Johnson should have been suspended or do you want the MRP to make two shit decisions instead of one?

regards,

REB

[Rik E Boy]

Lindsay Thomas really annoys me the way he plays for frees. Why does he do it?

Is there anyone worse in the league than him do you think at it?

Steve Johnson is up there and it is bloody annoying. Win the ball Dog! Ashton Hams is pretty bad too was poleaxed by, um....no one during the Carlton game.

regards,

REB

[The Sleeping Giant]

You have missed the point reb. Van Berlo was found guilty of trying to punch the ball. I guess it's just another case of inconsistency from the mrp.

And Lindsay Thomas would have played a coma on that one for a free kick.

So you don't believe that Johnson should have been suspended or do you want the MRP to make two shit decisions instead of one?

regards,

REB

I guess it depends on any injury sustained. Johnson is a pretty strong lad. I'm sure he could of pushed mattner off.

[Rik E Boy]

No injury sustained by Mattner. No Suspension. Play on.

regards,

REB