Top Ten Worst AFL Footballers Ever

[overloaded]

Stuart Wigney

[stan]

Brent Reilly

Ease up fellas, this guy can actually play football, hes just not good at being a robot.

[David Brent]

Carlile from port, reckon he is one of the most over rated players in the comp. Very very lazy too

[hearts on fire]

Carlile from port, reckon he is one of the most over rated players in the comp. Very very lazy too

yes!! looks fat, slow and useless.

[best on hill]

Carlile from port, reckon he is one of the most over rated players in the comp. Very very lazy too

yes!! looks fat, slow and useless.

yep should have got rid of him and got something for him while people actually rate him

[GWW]

Carlile from port, reckon he is one of the most over rated players in the comp. Very very lazy too

He's not really rated at all these days.

[Rik E Boy]

Pity anyone playing Fullback for the Power that's all I can say.

My nom goes to some past champions of the Geelong Football Club.

Brent Grgic - the only time this dud ever played any good was AGAINST Geelong. So what do we do? We draft the bozo BUZZZ
Justin Murphy - More jumpers than Glenelg Jetty. This jellyfish never left Carlton mentally. Look at the way he looked at Milburn after he cleaned up SOS. Wouldn't want to be in the same foxhole as him!
Derek Hall - The late nineties were not a good time to be a Cat. He was supposed to kick goals!
Brett Spinks - The classic 'looks like Tarzan, plays like Jane' player. Huge hulk of a list clogger.
Kane Tenace - A rare Wells failure. How's he going at Glenelg anyway?
Peter Street - Tall, lanky and totally useless. A Mark Blake prototype.
Nathan Djerkerra - I thought indigenous boys were supposed to have pace and innate ball sense. Nope. Off to the Bullies you go.
Marcus Baldwin - Failed forward number 147
Matthew McCarthy - Failed forward number 96
Henry Playfair - Failed forward number 42

...took us a while to replace Gazza which was amazing since he was 42 when he left the club!

GO CATS

regards,

REB

[Dutchy]

Eddie Sansbury

[The Dark Knight]

Pity anyone playing Fullback for the Power that's all I can say.

My nom goes to some past champions of the Geelong Football Club.

Brent Grgic - the only time this dud ever played any good was AGAINST Geelong. So what do we do? We draft the bozo BUZZZ
Justin Murphy - More jumpers than Glenelg Jetty. This jellyfish never left Carlton mentally. Look at the way he looked at Milburn after he cleaned up SOS. Wouldn't want to be in the same foxhole as him!
Derek Hall - The late nineties were not a good time to be a Cat. He was supposed to kick goals!
Brett Spinks - The classic 'looks like Tarzan, plays like Jane' player. Huge hulk of a list clogger.
Kane Tenace - A rare Wells failure. How's he going at Glenelg anyway?
Peter Street - Tall, lanky and totally useless. A Mark Blake prototype.
Nathan Djerkerra - I thought indigenous boys were supposed to have pace and innate ball sense. Nope. Off to the Bullies you go.
Marcus Baldwin - Failed forward number 147
Matthew McCarthy - Failed forward number 96
Henry Playfair - Failed forward number 42

...took us a while to replace Gazza which was amazing since he was 42 when he left the club!

GO CATS

regards,

REB

I'm sure I saw his name in the reserves at one point.

[Jimmy]

Eddie Sansbury

Haha, subtle shot at the dogs

My nom is Geary from the Saints, just useless

[daysofourlives]

Ryan Shoenmakers
Its 24 hours after the event and im still angry
Has played his last game for Hawthorn, maybe we can swap him for Gunston
End of Thread

[David Brent]

Dean Polo & Rap Clarke

Classic game by Raph Clarke last night. Genuine A Grade Spud

[gadj1976]

Raph Clarke is still top of my list, and yet he still gets a game???? He'd struggle in an Div 3 half back line IMO. No offence to a Div 3 half back line!

And one today that reminded me of when I went to Melbourne last time. Alwyn Davey. He's just plain terrible.

[Media Park]

Most current Melbourne midfielders should be on this thread.

[Rik E Boy]

Most current Melbourne midfielders should be on this thread.

Maloney
Jones
Scully
McKenzie


...turn it up.

regards,

REB

[the milky bar kid]

Most current Melbourne midfielders should be on this thread.

Maloney
Jones
Scully
McKenzie


...turn it up.

regards,

REB

He said Melbourne midfielders

[RustyCage]

Carlile from port, reckon he is one of the most over rated players in the comp. Very very lazy too

yes!! looks fat, slow and useless.

when is the last time he had a bag kicked on him? Carlisle is the least of our worries

[best on hill]

Raph Clarke is still top of my list, and yet he still gets a game????.

clacke is not in my top three but is very close to the votes

[best on hill]

Carlile from port, reckon he is one of the most over rated players in the comp. Very very lazy too

yes!! looks fat, slow and useless.

when is the last time he had a bag kicked on him? Carlisle is the least of our worries

not too many big bags get kicked in this day and age of footy, he just doesnt look like he is trying or interested

[GWW]

His fitness and body language has been poor the last year or so.

He needs to get a decent pre season under his belt, and make some improvement. He's too easily pushed aside in marking contests.