SA Footy

JK wrote:Geelong
Brisbane
Carlton
Port
Melbourne
Richmond
Sydney
Collingwood

Fremantle
Gold Coast
Bulldogs
Essendon
St Kilda
GWS
North Melbourne
West Coast
Adelaide
Hawthorn

Flag - Carlton
Coleman - H McKay
Brownlow - T. Mitchell

Rik E Boy wrote:

gadj1976 wrote:

Armchair expert wrote:Armchairs Coach Ratings (performance vs my expectations)

Adelaide Matthew Nicks B-
Brisbane Lions Chris Fagan A
Carlton Michael Voss B+
Collingwood Craig McRae A
Essendon Brad Scott C
Fremantle Justin Longmuir D
Geelong Chris Scott F
Gold Coast Steven King --
Greater Western Sydney Adam Kingsley A
Hawthorn Sam Mitchell B
Melbourne Simon Goodwin B+
North Melbourne Alastair Clarkson --
Port Adelaide Ken Hinkley A
Richmond Andrew McQualter --
St Kilda Ross Lyon A
Sydney John Longmire C
West Coast Adam Simpson D-
Western Bulldogs Luke Beveridge D-

I don't think you're far away from my estimations there AE. Scott I'd have higher than an F (E?), Simpson a C-, Bevo a C (expected them to only just scrape into finals anyway, so my expectations weren't that high). Others, spot on.

We could have gone gone back to back and Armchair Farqhuit would still have had a crack at the Cats. Not sure how you are supposed to win matches with half the team in the medicos. One of the strengths of 22 is that we could manage our old list. We couldn't do that this year and we ran out of gas. No pass for Scotty but at least a D. If anyone deserves an F at Catland it's probably those in charge of the physical preparation. The management of Cam Guthrie in particular was very poor. Good AF would be handing out F's to the boot studders and the fellows in the hardhats throwing the ball back. Not too sure what the Catters have done to hurt him but we sure do live rent free in that empty head of his.

regards,

REB

gadj1976 wrote:

Rik E Boy wrote:b]Not sure how you are supposed to win matches with half the team in the medicos.[/b]

regards,

REB

Hahaha, did you see our injury list for most of the season REB? FMD.... what a p*ss excuse.

Rik E Boy wrote:

gadj1976 wrote:

Armchair expert wrote:Armchairs Coach Ratings (performance vs my expectations)

Adelaide Matthew Nicks B-
Brisbane Lions Chris Fagan A
Carlton Michael Voss B+
Collingwood Craig McRae A
Essendon Brad Scott C
Fremantle Justin Longmuir D
Geelong Chris Scott F
Gold Coast Steven King --
Greater Western Sydney Adam Kingsley A
Hawthorn Sam Mitchell B
Melbourne Simon Goodwin B+
North Melbourne Alastair Clarkson --
Port Adelaide Ken Hinkley A
Richmond Andrew McQualter --
St Kilda Ross Lyon A
Sydney John Longmire C
West Coast Adam Simpson D-
Western Bulldogs Luke Beveridge D-

I don't think you're far away from my estimations there AE. Scott I'd have higher than an F (E?), Simpson a C-, Bevo a C (expected them to only just scrape into finals anyway, so my expectations weren't that high). Others, spot on.

We could have gone gone back to back and Armchair Farqhuit would still have had a crack at the Cats. Not sure how you are supposed to win matches with half the team in the medicos. One of the strengths of 22 is that we could manage our old list. We couldn't do that this year and we ran out of gas. No pass for Scotty but at least a D. If anyone deserves an F at Catland it's probably those in charge of the physical preparation. The management of Cam Guthrie in particular was very poor. Good AF would be handing out F's to the boot studders and the fellows in the hardhats throwing the ball back. Not too sure what the Catters have done to hurt him but we sure do live rent free in that empty head of his.

regards,

REB

Booney wrote:

gadj1976 wrote:

Rik E Boy wrote:b]Not sure how you are supposed to win matches with half the team in the medicos.[/b]

regards,

REB

Hahaha, did you see our injury list for most of the season REB? FMD.... what a p*ss excuse.

They weren't injured mate, it was arthitis.