Top Ten Worst AFL Footballers Ever

[best on hill]

b.o.h. how about scott hodges does he fit YOUR criteria? both crow players you mention would be walk ups for port...really get real mate.

yep great sanfl player, i think the coach at the time didnt get the best out of him though

[tigerpie]

and the fact a bloke called modra was an infinetly better player.

[best on hill]

i thought a player at port was a dud his name is brad symes then the crows picked him up

[Ron Burgundy]

Ty Zantuck

[OnSong]

Ty Zantuck

Now we're talking. Top 5 at least.

[OnSong]

A few years ago I would have said Leigh Brown but what a mistake that would have been.

[Media Park]

Aaron Shattock

[Brodlach]

A few years ago I would have said Leigh Brown but what a mistake that would have been.

Shattered when Collingwood picked him up, had signed at Westies.

[piccachu]

Yep Zantuck is a must have in the top 10.

i dont think Brett Peake is much chop either

[best on hill]

Ty Zantuck

Now we're talking. Top 5 at least.

he would be in the votes

[OnSong]

Aaron Shattock

His last name is a candidate on its own. Haha. Sounds like he shat a hammock.

[best on hill]

Ty Zantuck

Now we're talking. Top 5 at least.

he would be in the votes

just on that if i had to give votes it would be

best on aaron keating
second ty zantuck
third ronny de lulio

[Dirko]

third ronny de lulio

Ron De Iulio has his name on a locker at Carlton. He held his own, by far away there's 100 shittier Blues I'd have above him.

[helicopterking]

Fergus Watts, Nick Smith(Melb), David King (Coll) Chad Rintoul

[Media Park]

third ronny de lulio

Ron De Iulio has his name on a locker at Carlton. He held his own, by far away there's 100 shittier Blues I'd have above him.

100 games and shortlisted for the Italian team of the century.

I never saw the guy play, so I can't have a say really.

[Dog_ger]

Don't know if you guys are old enough..?

There was a guy called Jacko, many years ago.

My memory sees him in red and white but that could be way off.

Was it Mark Jackson...?

[hottie]

Mark Jackson did play for about 4 or 5 teams,was a good player but better known for his entertainment,hilarious to watch.Like Akermanis didnt make friends at his clubs and was quickly moved on.Previous page someone stated Adam Saliba remember Mick Nunan saying the Jarman brothers and Saliba had the most talent in his time of coaching at North Adelaide.

[Punk Rooster]

while im on it adam saliba

this thread is not about "underachieving talented footballers"...

[FlyingHigh]

Don't know if you guys are old enough..?

There was a guy called Jacko, many years ago.

My memory sees him in red and white but that could be way off.

Was it Mark Jackson...?

Didn't Jacko also play at South Fremantle at one stage?

[FlyingHigh]

Aaron Fiora! This bum went number 3 in 1999 and played 140 matches!!
Career Highs
Disposals:29 v Adelaide, 20th May, 2005
Kicks:16 v Melbourne,30th March, 2007
Handballs: 15 v Adelaide 20th May, 2005
Marks:13 v Melbourne,30th March,2007
Goals:2 v Pt Adelaide, 3rd August,2008
Tackles:5 v Richmond, 1st September,2007
Hit-Outs:2 v Adelaide, 13th July,2007

Career Ave G:140 K:7.3 H:4.1 Dis:11.4 Mk:4.0 G:0.4 B:0.4 T:1.4 H/O:0.3 F/F:0.6 F/A 0.6

Again, took some great marks. Wasn't a great player but not worth mentioning here.

If Media Park's original qualification of a semi-decent run is used, Fiora probably doesn't belong on this thread as this fairy got a far-more-than-decent run. Thank christ Woodville-West Torrens didn't rescuit him when he was delisted. Luke Jarrad is not my favourite Eagles player compared to Powell, Lewis, etc, but he is at least 5 times as tough as this bloke.

See, I understand he's not tough etc but there is no doubting he had ability.

Highlights such as:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DzECYay-jKc

and

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qMXdfzsg ... re=related

Yeah, wasn't a number three draft pick but was far from the top 10 worst AFL footballers ever, surely.

Sure, maybe not in the worst ten ever, but still has me staggered how two clubs saw enough there for him to play 140 games. But I suppose that is 140 more than me