Page 2 of 7
Re: 2017 All Australian
Posted:
Mon Aug 28, 2017 4:18 pmby bennymacca
rampe destroyed tex the other week. one of the better defensive games ive seen recently
Re: 2017 All Australian
Posted:
Tue Aug 29, 2017 5:47 pmby amber_fluid
Kruezer surely has to be the ruckman just ahead of Jacobs.
Had a very consistent and injury free year for him.
Re: 2017 All Australian
Posted:
Tue Aug 29, 2017 5:52 pmby carey
You must remember it's voted by the same people that have never had Clarkson coach of the year.
I was absolutely staggered when I heard that.
Re: 2017 All Australian
Posted:
Tue Aug 29, 2017 5:55 pmby Wedgie
Don't forget the swarm
Re: 2017 All Australian
Posted:
Tue Aug 29, 2017 5:55 pmby amber_fluid
carey wrote:You must remember it's voted by the same people that have never had Clarkson coach of the year.
I was absolutely staggered when I heard that.
IIRC didn't Hinkley win it in 2014 even though Hawthorn were premiers?
That's just crazy.
Re: 2017 All Australian
Posted:
Tue Aug 29, 2017 5:57 pmby carey
amber_fluid wrote:carey wrote:You must remember it's voted by the same people that have never had Clarkson coach of the year.
I was absolutely staggered when I heard that.
IIRC didn't Hinkley win it in 2014 even though Hawthorn were premiers?
That's just crazy.
See Port fans know coaches of the year!
#closetportfan
Re: 2017 All Australian
Posted:
Tue Aug 29, 2017 5:59 pmby Brodlach
My crack
Betts. Kennedy. Martin
Sloane. Franklin. Zorko
Kelly. Dangerfield. Merrett
Doherty. Hurley. Roberton
McGovern. Rance. Laird
Kruezer. Kennedy. Selwood
Mitchell, Bontempelli, Ryder, Gray
Re: 2017 All Australian
Posted:
Tue Aug 29, 2017 6:03 pmby amber_fluid
Brodlach wrote:My crack
Betts. Kennedy. Martin
Sloane. Franklin. Zorko
Kelly. Dangerfield. Merrett
Doherty. Hurley. Roberton
McGovern. Rance. Laird
Kruezer. Kennedy. Selwood
Mitchell, Bontempelli, Ryder, Gray
Ryder over Jacobs as 2nd ruckman?
I thought Jacobs convincingly beat him both times they played which should add weight?
Re: 2017 All Australian
Posted:
Tue Aug 29, 2017 6:04 pmby Brodlach
Second ruck/ forward I was thinking
Re: 2017 All Australian
Posted:
Tue Aug 29, 2017 6:41 pmby Jim05
I've gone
Daniher, Kennedy, Betts
Zorko, Franklin, Gray
Kelly, Mitchell, Merrett
Laird, Hurley, Docherty
Hibberd, Rance, Howe
Kreuzer, Dangerfield, Martin
I/C Ryder, Kennedy(Syd), Crouch
Re: 2017 All Australian
Posted:
Tue Aug 29, 2017 8:28 pmby morell
amber_fluid wrote:Kruezer surely has to be the ruckman just ahead of Jacobs.
Had a very consistent and injury free year for him.
No.
Re: 2017 All Australian
Posted:
Tue Aug 29, 2017 8:31 pmby amber_fluid
morell wrote:amber_fluid wrote:Kruezer surely has to be the ruckman just ahead of Jacobs.
Had a very consistent and injury free year for him.
No.
Oh please.
Next you'll say Ryder should be the AA ruckman.
Re: 2017 All Australian
Posted:
Tue Aug 29, 2017 8:31 pmby woodublieve12
Rampe is better than Hibberd and Howe.
Re: 2017 All Australian
Posted:
Tue Aug 29, 2017 8:33 pmby TEX07
Jim05 wrote:I've gone
Daniher, Kennedy, Betts
Zorko, Franklin, Gray
Kelly, Mitchell, Merrett
Laird, Hurley, Docherty
Hibberd, Rance, Howe
Kreuzer, Dangerfield, Martin
I/C Ryder, Kennedy(Syd), Crouch
I would love to see them name 2 ruckmen one season - all three rucks nominated would be worthy this season. They have had seasons where they have named guys on the half forward who never play there because they "had" to get in, why not the same for a ruckman.
Re: 2017 All Australian
Posted:
Tue Aug 29, 2017 8:41 pmby Jim05
woodublieve12 wrote:Rampe is better than Hibberd and Howe.
Yes he is but missing so many games early on has hurt him.
Hibberd has been very good this year, wish he had stayed with us
Re: 2017 All Australian
Posted:
Wed Aug 30, 2017 8:37 amby MatteeG
Reckon the Bont got in purely due to hype. He was largely ordinary this year from what I saw.
Re: 2017 All Australian
Posted:
Wed Aug 30, 2017 8:56 amby Booney
MatteeG wrote:Reckon the Bont got in purely due to hype. He was largely ordinary this year from what I saw.
Certainly wasn't at his explosive best.
Re: 2017 All Australian
Posted:
Wed Aug 30, 2017 9:03 amby Booney
bennymacca wrote:Crows dominate the AA squad
Crows - EBetts, MCrouch, SJacobs, RLaird, JLever, TLynch, RSloane, TWalker.
Lions - DZorko.
Blues - SDocherty, MKreuzer.
Pies – JHowe, ATreloar.
Bombers – JDaniher, MHurley, ZMerrett.
Cats – PDangerfield, JSelwood.
GWS – TGreene, JKelly, TScully, DShiel.
Hawks – TMitchell.
Demons – JGarlett, MHibberd, NJetta.
Kangas – BBrown.
Power – RGray, TJonas, PRyder.
Tigers – DMartin, ARance.
Saints – DRoberton, SRoss.
Swans – LFranklin, JKennedy.
Eagles – JKennedy, JMcGovern, EYeo.
Dogs – MBontempelli.
Betts Kennedy Daniher
Zorko Franklin Gray
Kelly Mitchell Martin
Laird Hurley Hibberd
Yeo Rance McGovern
R : Ryder Dangerfield Selwood
Int - M Crouch, Scully, JP Kennedy, Docherty
Re: 2017 All Australian
Posted:
Wed Aug 30, 2017 9:03 amby MW
EBetts JKennedy JDaniher
DZorko LFranklin RGray
TMitchell PDangerfield (c) JKelly
EYeo MHurley SDocherty
RLaird ARance JHowe
SJacobs JKennedy DMartin
MCrouch SRoss BBrown JSelwood (vc)
Re: 2017 All Australian
Posted:
Wed Aug 30, 2017 1:54 pmby Rik E Boy
MatteeG wrote:Reckon the Bont got in purely due to hype. He was largely ordinary this year from what I saw.
How does Bont, Selwood and Treloar get a nom but Duncan doesn't?
regards,
REB