Has Mick Malthouse lost the plot?

[bennymacca]

Quiz time
Who was the 2010 AFL Premiership coach ?

The same coach whose thinking seems to be stuck in 2010?

[woodublieve12]

Nathan buckley or razor ray

or steven milne

[gadj1976]

I would expect the journalists "union" would have had plenty of discussion behind closed doors, Mick shows us some respect and we'll show him some.

Mick must remember just after he got arseholed from Collingwood he spent a year analysing games, coaches game plans, player development at other clubs, the manner in which clubs prepare, every facet of the game and on every club he passed comment on and it would have made him a tidy little living for that time.

Time for someone to tell Mick to pull his head in.

Pick me, pick me!

[gadj1976]

If I were Carlton fan, I'd be more concerned about Yarran's little friendly smile and chat with Buddy just after the latter had kicked another goal.

Really? Than our senior coach having spats with reporters? FFS, if Yarran's smile is more important than your coach going off the rails - and not focussing on what IS important, then I'm Thorpy's love interest.

[stan]

Yeah I think he is starting to lose it.

[Jimmy_041]

I said this a few weeks ago after watching him in a post match talk

All journalists should stop asking him questions.
Just let him sit there.
He is a $hit coach and always has been
It is always about him
I still haven't forgotten how he treated Jason Cloke in the 2003 Grand Final (which Malthouse lost due to his arrogance)
I hope he stays at Carlton forever - they deserve each other

[Jim05]

Mick isnt that bad of a coach.
Carlton's list is full of d graders id defy any coach to get that lot into finals. They have paid the price for ordinary recruiting over the years and the worst thing is I dont think they have bottomed out just yet. Some lean years coming up

[JK]

If I were Carlton fan, I'd be more concerned about Yarran's little friendly smile and chat with Buddy just after the latter had kicked another goal.

Really? Than our senior coach having spats with reporters? FFS, if Yarran's smile is more important than your coach going off the rails - and not focussing on what IS important, then I'm Thorpy's love interest.

No, I just wrote it for fun. It's an appalling look for a club, but it is Carlton I guess and you've accepted it since Fevola put himself above the place, why start worrying now. Don't forget your lube.

[Booney]

I said this a few weeks ago after watching him in a post match talk

All journalists should stop asking him questions.
Just let him sit there.
He is a $hit coach and always has been
It is always about him
I still haven't forgotten how he treated Jason Cloke in the 2003 Grand Final (which Malthouse lost due to his arrogance)
I hope he stays at Carlton forever - they deserve each other

I'm sure you cried this from the terraces after the GF of 2010 too.

[Dogwatcher]

You love him when he's with you, hate him when he's against.

[Jim05]

You love him when he's with you, hate him when he's against.

Yep. Reckon the Pies would have him back.
Old Figjam hasnt quite been the messiah Eddie hoped for

[Spargo]

Quiz time
Who was the 2010 AFL Premiership coach ?

And look how the team who lost that day are travelling now...

[Dogwatcher]

You love him when he's with you, hate him when he's against.

Yep. Reckon the Pies would have him back.
Old Figjam hasnt quite been the messiah Eddie hoped for

I wouldn't have him back, he's gone bonkers.
I'm not writing Bucks off yet, either. I always said this would be a rebuilding year for us, younger side. Although, defensive injuries have hurt us a bit.
Must admit though, I was seduced by the run of form we had after that first loss.

[RustyCage]

Is Micks current antics a sign of the changing/poor administration above him? While I'm definitely not a collingwood fan they are a well run club, an environment where these antics are less likely to happen, or stamped out quickly when they do.

[bennymacca]

Bucks has the charisma of a block of wood

[Jimmy_041]

I said this a few weeks ago after watching him in a post match talk

All journalists should stop asking him questions.
Just let him sit there.
He is a $hit coach and always has been
It is always about him
I still haven't forgotten how he treated Jason Cloke in the 2003 Grand Final (which Malthouse lost due to his arrogance)
I hope he stays at Carlton forever - they deserve each other

I'm sure you cried this from the terraces after the GF of 2010 too.

Sure did. Didn't change the fact that he's a $hit coach

[Dogwatcher]

Bucks has the charisma of a block of wood

And...

[bennymacca]

Bucks has the charisma of a block of wood

And...

Much easier to get the players, supporters and others to buy into what you are trying to do if you are a good public speaker.

Also helps for motivational purposes game day too.

[Dogwatcher]

He is a good public speaker. Do you think he'd be captain of an AFL club, let alone a coach, if he wasn't?
Business-like, granted. But he is not a bad public speaker and has a very dry sense of humour.

[bennymacca]

He is a good public speaker. Do you think he'd be captain of an AFL club, let alone a coach, if he wasn't?
Business-like, granted. But he is not a bad public speaker and has a very dry sense of humour.

Captains can be different imo because you can be the type that leads by their actions.