How many games will Judd get??

[RustyCage]

should get 5. great footballer but is a moron

[Jimmy_041]

should get 5. great wife but is a moron

<Edited for accuracy>

[footballmad]

Should get 4-6 as it was truly a spineless act in which as usual he received a free kick because the NMFC Captain who plays the ball all the time took considerable umbridge with the fact he was pulling his team mates arm and causing him pain. Judd has been outstanding as a player but has tainted his image with these incidents against players who are in defenceless positions therefore the only solution I can think of is that he is a physicall coward. That fits as the club he represents are a joke!! Anything to win,cheat if you can get away with it,suffer Carlton and book holidays for September cause youre season is over AGAIN!!!!!

[Johno6]

anyone see the footage they showed last night of rioli doing a "chicken wing" tackle on robbie warnock,
if anyone has the video can they show it please
it didnt even get looked at, but this was worse obviously.

also last time a player went straight to MRP was heath shaw for pushing an ump... he got 1 week.



judd to get off and play this week and win the brownlow.

[Booney]

I think he'll get 4.

[HH3]

Dislocating an opponents shoulder, bringing game into disrepute. 4-6.

Did hear a few experts on Melbourne radio this arvo saying he will get 6.
Yet turn it over to 5aa and both those numbnuts thought it was worth nothing, Cornes even thought he did nothing wrong

Yeah I listen to them every evening on the drive home, and I had to turn it off. Cornes is a total idiot, telling callers its a mans game so deal with it...that was one of the most piss weak unmanly things Ive ever seen on a footy field. He also kept saying it didnt hurt Adams and he played on. In actual fact it dislocated his shoulder, and Adams, being the manly man he is (unlike Juddy) patched it up and played on.

[Media Park]

Official warning. And 3 votes.

[valleys07]

Official warning. And 3 votes.

Watch come brownlow night MP, you will be the most accurate of the lot

[HH3]

Can you get the 3 votes in a game you got reported in?

I wouldve thought you'd have to play fair to get the votes?

[Lightning McQueen]

Can you get the 3 votes in a game you got reported in?

I wouldve thought you'd have to play fair to get the votes?

Highly unlikely, the umpire would have to be a dill, it is for best and fairest, not just best.

[daysofourlives]

Does anyone know if Judd has a martial arts background?
If he does he should get 10+

[Dols]

Can you get the 3 votes in a game you got reported in?

I wouldve thought you'd have to play fair to get the votes?

Highly unlikely, the umpire would have to be a dill, it is for best and fairest, not just best.

it is not an umpires job to choose who was the fairest, those issues are for an independent group of people such as the tribunal. Do you think they think to themselves that person was suspended the other week so waste of time giving him votes? They just need to concern themselves who was the best player on the field. If they thought about reports and not gave a player votes, then the matter was withdrawn, how would that go?

[valleys07]

Did he actually get reported? or was he sighted by the MRP who handed it straight to the tribunal?

[HH3]

I think the boundry umpire reported him.

[Lightning McQueen]

Can you get the 3 votes in a game you got reported in?

I wouldve thought you'd have to play fair to get the votes?

Highly unlikely, the umpire would have to be a dill, it is for best and fairest, not just best.

it is not an umpires job to choose who was the fairest, those issues are for an independent group of people such as the tribunal. Do you think they think to themselves that person was suspended the other week so waste of time giving him votes? They just need to concern themselves who was the best player on the field. If they thought about reports and not gave a player votes, then the matter was withdrawn, how would that go?

Pigs arse, the Brownlow Medal is awarded to the most brilliant and fairest player, the votes are awarded each week based on the the 3 most brilliant and fairest players for that individual game, if you didn't get a kick but played fairly you wouldn't get a vote, if you got 40 kicks put played unfairly, you wouldn't get a vote.
Each game is a new chapter and votes can only be based on that game's performance. whether the matter is withdrawn or not, if the umpires deemed that he played unfairly, he would not be awarded votes.
There are media awards and MVP awards based purely on performances.

[the joker]

Cyril's tackle last week was very similar.
I think judds is made worst when swallow and McMillan push Chris. The arm is pulled the same way as Judd is pushed.

[Footy Smart]

Cyril's tackle last week was very similar.
I think judds is made worst when swallow and McMillan push Chris. The arm is pulled the same way as Judd is pushed.

not similar in the slightest. Cyril was tackling a standing warnock who was able to get rid of the ball. Judd picked up the arm of an completely tackled player and pulled it behind his back only to inflict pain..... IM a judd fan but he deserves a break for this brain fart.

[D14]

Cyril's tackle last week was very similar.
I think judds is made worst when swallow and McMillan push Chris. The arm is pulled the same way as Judd is pushed.

Maybe he should have let go...

[Footy Smart]

Cyril's tackle last week was very similar.
I think judds is made worst when swallow and McMillan push Chris. The arm is pulled the same way as Judd is pushed.

Maybe he should have let go...

Maybe he shouldnt have picked it up at all????

[saintal]

Deserves a couple.