Round 15 Live scores and discussion

[The Sleeping Giant]

LOL, McKernan gets 2 weeks for an ugly elbow to the head and Stevie J got 2 weeks for a hip and shoulder.
WTF is seriously going on with the game?

Does McKernan have a record like johnson's?

[Jim05]

Westhoff contesting his ban, doesn't face losing an extra week

[kickinit]

Westhoff contesting his ban, doesn't face losing an extra week

turned down still faces a week.

[The Sleeping Giant]

Silly challenge. Should get an extra week for time wasting.

[Wedgie]

LOL, McKernan gets 2 weeks for an ugly elbow to the head and Stevie J got 2 weeks for a hip and shoulder.
WTF is seriously going on with the game?

Does McKernan have a record like johnson's?

Worse looking at what he did, Stevie J's only bumped and tackled blokes where McKernan has assaulted one!

[Turbo]

Silly challenge. Should get an extra week for time wasting.

..and being a tosser

[The Sleeping Giant]

LOL, McKernan gets 2 weeks for an ugly elbow to the head and Stevie J got 2 weeks for a hip and shoulder.
WTF is seriously going on with the game?

Does McKernan have a record like johnson's?

Worse looking at what he did, Stevie J's only bumped and tackled blokes where McKernan has assaulted one!

Didn't Johnson get games for belting Baker?

[NO-MERCY]

McGinnity 3 weeks should of got reprimand.
McKernan 2 weeks should of got 4-5
S.Johnson 2 weeks should of got off.
Westhoff 1 week another that should of got off.

The panel have NFI, talk about consistent.
Consistently getting it wrong.

[woodublieve12]

McGinnity 3 weeks should of got reprimand.
McKernan 2 weeks :shock: should of got 4-5
S.Johnson 2 weeks should of got off.
Westhoff 1 week another that should of got off.

The panel have NFI, talk about consistent.
Consistently getting it wrong.

still can't work out how mckernan only got two...absolute disgrace!!! It was a dirty old elbow. I've heard commentators say it's out of his character, couldn't give a rats... it was on purpose, dog act imo. the only positive was he hit a west coast player

[Footy Smart]

McGinnity 3 weeks should of got reprimand.
McKernan 2 weeks should of got 4-5
S.Johnson 2 weeks should of got off.
Westhoff 1 week another that should of got off.

The panel have NFI, talk about consistent.
Consistently getting it wrong.

NM agree with all of above but I cant see how people think Westoff should have gotten off? He clearly made intentional contact with the jaw of a essendon player with his elbow after the siren

[Jim05]

McGinnity 3 weeks should of got reprimand.
McKernan 2 weeks should of got 4-5
S.Johnson 2 weeks should of got off.
Westhoff 1 week another that should of got off.

The panel have NFI, talk about consistent.
Consistently getting it wrong.

NM agree with all of above but I cant see how people think Westoff should have gotten off? He clearly made intentional contact with the jaw of a essendon player with his elbow after the siren

Im an Essendon member and I think Westhoff should of got off.
Hooker made of meal of it and went fown like he was shot. He suffered no injury whatsoever.
Was only a glancing blow and no worse than the jumper punch he gave back to Westhoff.

[Zorro]

McGinnity 3 weeks should of got reprimand.
McKernan 2 weeks should of got 4-5
S.Johnson 2 weeks should of got off.
Westhoff 1 week another that should of got off.

The panel have NFI, talk about consistent.
Consistently getting it wrong.

NM agree with all of above but I cant see how people think Westoff should have gotten off? He clearly made intentional contact with the jaw of a essendon player with his elbow after the siren

Agree, you were going well until Westhoff.

[Footy Smart]

Im an Essendon member and I think Westhoff should of got off.
Hooker made of meal of it and went fown like he was shot. He suffered no injury whatsoever.
Was only a glancing blow and no worse than the jumper punch he gave back to Westhoff

Geez wouldnt mind giving you one of them glancing blows Jimbo

I hadnt seen it until last night. Watched it a few times, and the contact wasnt that glancing at all and only by pure luck didnt it break his jaw, seen less cause more damage thats for sure.

Did the Mckernan which was higher impact that westoff's i agree and other mentioned incidents cause injury?

[Jim05]

Im an Essendon member and I think Westhoff should of got off.
Hooker made of meal of it and went fown like he was shot. He suffered no injury whatsoever.
Was only a glancing blow and no worse than the jumper punch he gave back to Westhoff

Geez wouldnt mind giving you one of them glancing blows Jimbo

I hadnt seen it until last night. Watched it a few times, and the contact wasnt that glancing at all and only by pure luck didnt it break his jaw, seen less cause more damage thats for sure.

Did the Mckernan which was higher impact that westoff's i agree and other mentioned incidents cause injury?

Hooker has said he didnt feel anything and it was by instinct he went to ground.
Was dumb by Westhoff but due to his good record I felt a reprimand would of been sufficient.

[Footy Smart]

Im an Essendon member and I think Westhoff should of got off.
Hooker made of meal of it and went fown like he was shot. He suffered no injury whatsoever.
Was only a glancing blow and no worse than the jumper punch he gave back to Westhoff

Geez wouldnt mind giving you one of them glancing blows Jimbo

I hadnt seen it until last night. Watched it a few times, and the contact wasnt that glancing at all and only by pure luck didnt it break his jaw, seen less cause more damage thats for sure.

Did the Mckernan which was higher impact that westoff's i agree and other mentioned incidents cause injury?

Hooker has said he didnt feel anything and it was by instinct he went to ground.
Was dumb by Westhoff but due to his good record I felt a reprimand would of been sufficient.

Every players says there was nothing in it

on another note, on 360 last night Gerard came up with a good example of how the MRP and Tribunal system should be set up and if only the AFL would listen to it. Did anyone else see it? he gave good examples i thought as well. It would mean th Zeibel, Brown, Westoff pentalies are consistant for what they are not what it is interpreted to be.

[The Sleeping Giant]

Bellchambers gave a fantastic jumper punch. Could hear the crack from the standing section.

[JK]

Makes you wonder if the powers that be think they've done enough to stamp out elbows and behind the play incidents in the last 20 years, and have moved onto new "pet" indiscretions??

Like most people I really can't work out how McKernan got off as lightly as he did, and I don't agree with McGinnity suspension.

[woodublieve12]

AFL logic

1 week for this...

[toot toot]

on another note, on 360 last night Gerard came up with a good example of how the MRP and Tribunal system should be set up and if only the AFL would listen to it. Did anyone else see it? he gave good examples i thought as well. It would mean th Zeibel, Brown, Westoff pentalies are consistant for what they are not what it is interpreted to be.

Yep saw this, best solution to the MRP I've heard. Really like Gerard's views on most things, talks a lot of sense.

[whufc]

on another note, on 360 last night Gerard came up with a good example of how the MRP and Tribunal system should be set up and if only the AFL would listen to it. Did anyone else see it? he gave good examples i thought as well. It would mean th Zeibel, Brown, Westoff pentalies are consistant for what they are not what it is interpreted to be.

Yep saw this, best solution to the MRP I've heard. Really like Gerard's views on most things, talks a lot of sense.

X2