The Riddler/UK Fans Ken Mcgregor Top 10 AFL duds

[Jim05]

Rhys goes alright I reckon.

Bootsma from Carlton certain to receive a nomination at years end

I'm assuming we can take majaks nomination away

Nup, 1 good game against a pack of duds doesnt get him off the list especially seeing his game tonight.
Very average

[Pag]

Matt White from Richmond needs to be seriously considered.

[Squids]

Michael Hurley deserves a spot...constantly lets his team down getting injured during games.

[The Sleeping Giant]

Michael Hurley deserves a spot...constantly lets his team down getting injured during games.

He got his head slammed into the Etihad turf. Using your definition of a dud, Waite should be captain/coach.

[Squids]

Michael Hurley deserves a spot...constantly lets his team down getting injured during games.

He got his head slammed into the Etihad turf. Using your definition of a dud, Waite should be captain/coach.

lol why u mad tho?

[The Sleeping Giant]

Ha.

[The Riddler]

Yet again our list causes great debate and controversy just the way we like it! It's time Rucci took some notice and started publishing it alongside his Top 50.

[carey]

Nick Maxwell making a charge to be skipper tonight.

[Jim05]

Jordan Russell needs another nomination

[Spargo]

Nick Maxwell making a charge to be skipper tonight.

Only reinforcing many people's thoughts.

[The Sleeping Giant]

Nick Maxwell making a charge to be skipper tonight.

Only reinforcing many people's thoughts.

Maxwell is terribly one dimensional.

[Spargo]

Rhys goes alright I reckon.

Bootsma from Carlton certain to receive a nomination at years end

I'm assuming we can take majaks nomination away

Nup, 1 good game against a pack of duds doesnt get him off the list especially seeing his game tonight.
Very average

I find it amusing that after ONLY 4 GAMES he is even mentioned in this thread.

[UK Fan]

Nick Maxwell making a charge to be skipper tonight.

Only reinforcing many people's thoughts.

Maxwell is terribly one dimensional.

You said that about the second dimension discovery!!

[Jim05]

John Butcher is making a good fist of a Kenny nomination.
How can an AFL footballer have 2 set shots from 25m out straight infront and kick both out on the full.
Absolute dud!!

[Jim05]

Is the pushup King a Kenny candidate?
Should stick to the pushups because he a garbage footballer.
Thought Brian Taylor was going to blow his bolt everytime King got one of his almighty 6 possies tonight, it was sickening listening to him carry on about that spud

[NO-MERCY]

John Butcher is making a good fist of a Kenny nomination.
How can an AFL footballer have 2 set shots from 25m out straight infront and kick both out on the full.
Absolute dud!!

TRADE

[whufc]

John Butcher is making a good fist of a Kenny nomination.
How can an AFL footballer have 2 set shots from 25m out straight infront and kick both out on the full.
Absolute dud!!

TRADE

Agree, while he has a tad of value left, by the end of next year he will be playing state league reserves somewhere.

[The Sleeping Giant]

Look forward to him playing in Darwin in 18 months.

[UK Fan]

John Butcher is making a good fist of a Kenny nomination.
How can an AFL footballer have 2 set shots from 25m out straight infront and kick both out on the full.
Absolute dud!!

TRADE

The future is a Modern day nick gill. Certainly down in confidence ATM big time.

Nomination noted for Butcher.


What about Dean Brogan ?? Was a great ruckmen but he is simply ordinary now.

[The Sleeping Giant]

But Nick Gill could perform at SANFL level.