Most over-rated player in the AFL

[Rik E Boy]

What's it got to do with the Lions?

Well I bet you wouldn't be posting what you did about any of these blokes if they happened to wear the Maroon, Navy and Yellow mate.

regards,

REB

[Ron Burgundy]

Hodge when fully fit is a weapon.

At present while carrying an injury, I can understand how he is viewed as overrated, as he isnt achieving his potential.

He probably shouldnt be playing at the moment, but he soldiers on. I rate that.

[Rik E Boy]

Nick Natanui. Very inconsistent.

Surprise surprise. He is a very raw ruckman. Look how long it took for Jamar to stand up. It takes time with these blokes but you can tell Nicknat has real potential. The type of player who can drag blokes through the gates just to watch him. His rating is based on potential that is true but his best is brilliant. People who rate him are rating him as the player the Eagles hope that he can become.

Hasn't got the runs on the board just yet but we all get excited sometimes about the young players who show a bit early.

regards,

REB

[Rik E Boy]

Hodge when fully fit is a weapon.

At present while carrying an injury, I can understand how he is viewed as overrated, as he isnt achieving his potential.

He probably shouldnt be playing at the moment, but he soldiers on. I rate that.

Yep he's a lame duck at the moment. Not a great time to be given the captaincy.

regards,

REB

[OnSong]

Aaron Davey seems to have dropped off lately or am I just imagining things?

[Rik E Boy]

Aaron Davey seems to have dropped off lately or am I just imagining things?

Can't shake a tag. Doesn't work hard enough. He has plenty of mates at Melbourne.

regards,

REB

[Baron Greenback]

What's it got to do with the Lions?

Well I bet you wouldn't be posting what you did about any of these blokes if they happened to wear the Maroon, Navy and Yellow mate.

regards,

REB

I can't post any of the Lions because no one rates them!

[Rik E Boy]

What's it got to do with the Lions?

Well I bet you wouldn't be posting what you did about any of these blokes if they happened to wear the Maroon, Navy and Yellow mate.

regards,

REB

I can't post any of the Lions because no one rates them!

LOL. Good call I suppose.

regards,

REB

[cripple]

Aaron Davey seems to have dropped off lately or am I just imagining things?

Does have trouble against a super heavy tag but would be close to the best in the comp for hitting a target when coming out of the definsive 50. Considering he started his career as a lowly ranked rookie and then spent the first few years of his career as a crumbing forward i think he has done remarkably well in an often poor team.

[OnSong]

Aaron Davey seems to have dropped off lately or am I just imagining things?

Does have trouble against a super heavy tag but would be close to the best in the comp for hitting a target when coming out of the definsive 50. Considering he started his career as a lowly ranked rookie and then spent the first few years of his career as a crumbing forward i think he has done remarkably well in an often poor team.

No doubt, but last year he was one of their premier midfielders, this year, Moloney, Sylvia, Jones, Trengove has been outperforming him.

[no_remorse28]

Aaron Davey seems to have dropped off lately or am I just imagining things?

Can't shake a tag. Doesn't work hard enough. He has plenty of mates at Melbourne.

regards,

REB

Seems him and Daniel Wells have taken similar pathways. there so much the same as in they could be so much more damaging

[The Sleeping Giant]

Carlton v Swans. 30 players around a stoppage. Bruce makes the call "WHERE'S JUDD". Over rated much.

[Jim05]

Carlton v Swans. 30 players around a stoppage. Bruce makes the call "WHERE'S JUDD". Over rated much.

He has played well tonight but bruces man love is annoying

[Dirko]

Carlton v Swans. 30 players around a stoppage. Bruce makes the call "WHERE'S JUDD". Over rated much.

25 contested IIRC, career high. He was probably wondering how Judd missed a contested in the second half.....

[Turbo]

Carlton v Swans. 30 players around a stoppage. Bruce makes the call "WHERE'S JUDD". Over rated much.

25 contested IIRC, career high. He was probably wondering how Judd missed a contested in the second half.....

The best player going around

[carey]

well after all the judd hating on here after last's night game surely the focus must be switched from judd to goodes? ok maybe goodes isn't over rated but gee last night he was shocking and judd was simply fantastic.

[7-Dog]

I am of the opinion that if Judd played for Collingwood, Geelong, Hawthorn, Gold Coast in particular or every other team, he would be that clubs best player.

[Rik E Boy]

well after all the judd hating on here after last's night game surely the focus must be switched from judd to goodes? ok maybe goodes isn't over rated but gee last night he was shocking and judd was simply fantastic.

Judd's game was good last night but that still doesn't make him the best of all time so yeah he's still overrated. Goodes not great last night that's for sure. This isn't about 'Judd hating' you precious lot, it's just that some people don't happen to believe that he is 'the best of all time' or even the best current player. I reckon he might have been that a few years ago but not now. Gaz has him covered.

regards,

REB

[cripple]

people get sucked into rating players or dismissing them on the back of one performance to easily. Every player has a stinker now and again and the truly talented will stand out often. Juddy had a fantastic game last and has to be in the top 5 in the comp at the moment (with ablett, buddy, pendles and pav IMO, not that that means anything) and Goodes has 2 brownlows, premiership, best and fairests, all australians, indigenous team of the century etc.... to prove that last nights game was the exception rather then the norm.

[The Sleeping Giant]

I'm a Swans supporter and I think Goodes is over rated. Plays too many games where he has little impact, like last night.