Top Ten Worst AFL Footballers Ever

[JK]

Like saying aids is better than cancer.

Which one was which?

[dedja]

depends which one was more of a pain in the arse ...

[Johno6]

maybe one started as a pain in the a$$?

[whufc]

mark bolton from essendon
half of ports list including
hitchcock
broadbent
butcher
davenport
meyer
moore
marlon
pettigrew

Broadbent - Shows you dont watch the game much, this bloke has played 20 odd games and is developing nicely.Will be a sound mid-fielder.

Butcher - Hasn't played an AFL game yet. Good call.

Pettigrew - Has been a servicable backman who just hit 100 games.

Even people like you must realise playing 100 AFL games gives you some sort of credibility.

Would have to be one of the worse players to play 100 AFL games.

Geez he was struggling to hold his spot in the team this year in one of the worse Power teams of all time

[Blue Boy]

I remember the Crows n Power swapping 2 of the worst players ever in a pre season trade.

I. Downsborough - B. Chalmers

Surely both clubs were just having a bit of fun.

Id have Chalmers over Downsborough!

Have had many great debates over these 2 players !!!

Always seemed to get know where though as both had the dreaded potential tag and the rest well hmmmmmmmmmmm

[Blue Boy]

Crows

Had a spell there where they went for blokes who couldnt kick further than 35 metres but they were athletes !!!

hmmmmmmmmm as well.

[whufc]

After watching South vs Port today Lokan has to be up there.

[Grahaml]

Anyone mentionaed David Galagher? Sad thing is I think he played 30 or so games! Old problem of a guy having the size and strength around but not the football ability. Understandable they might draft him, DG v Judd at the same age you might be splitting hairs but when Carlton traded for him it was a great laugh.

Winner of this comp though is Shane Tongerie.

[hotpies]

Jack Watts over rated

[Jim05]

Jack Watts over rated

Harsh on the kid, id like to give him another season or two before making my judgement. Ive seen massive improvement from him this year

[tigerpie]

watts will be a 200 gamer i reckon.kpp's,especially no.1 draft picks take a while to come on...i'd have him at collingwood thats for sure.

[Jim05]

Zac Dawson still for me. How has this inept muppet played so many games?

[Dogwatcher]

Anyone mentionaed David Galagher? Sad thing is I think he played 30 or so games! Old problem of a guy having the size and strength around but not the football ability. Understandable they might draft him, DG v Judd at the same age you might be splitting hairs but when Carlton traded for him it was a great laugh.

Winner of this comp though is Shane Tongerie.

I mentioned Gallagher earlier in the thread. Big dud - even at SANFL level.

As for Dawson, my mate and I were watching the Saints/Roos game today and he made that exact comment.

[Media Park]

**For a number one draft pick...***

Clive Waterhouse.

[the big bang]

**For a number one draft pick...***

Clive Waterhouse.

Richard Lounder

[GWW]

Technically Richard Lounder was a "VFL" footballer, not "AFL".

[lebron]

Jack Watts over rated

Terrible call! He will be the next Adam Goodes for the rest of this decade. Versatile and match winning ability. Unlikely to be as good but he'll be the best at this role!

[Johno6]

How can u say jack watts is over rated when everyone bags him
Or are u going on the number draft pick tag?

[Pag]

I still say Richard Tambling.

[OnSong]

Jack Watts over rated

Terrible call! He will be the next Adam Goodes for the rest of this decade. Versatile and match winning ability. Unlikely to be as good but he'll be the best at this role!

Yep, he'll be a gun next year. Just growing into his role.