Worst players to play AFL..

[Lightning McQueen]

Who's the bloke that got knocked out nearly every time he played for the crows? Not Tippett.

[Lightning McQueen]

Henry Playfair's lawyers have been on to us, he deserves a mention.

I might get a capital lettered reply but Fitzy was very poor at AFL level.

[daysofourlives]

Troy Chaplin
Darryl Poole
R and Z Clarke
M.Liptak
S.Tasker
C.Hitchcock
J.Mail
Darren Smith
John Klug (or however you spell it)
Shoenmakers
Nick Mawell
Harry O'Brian
Nathan Krakour
Adrian McAdam

I could go on for Pages and Pages i have about 400 to list if the list was titled 'Most overrated players'

Pretty sure adrian mcadam kicked 91 goals in a season hardly the worst player to have played the game

[Booney]

This might just go down as the worst thread ever on SA Footy and there have been a few shit ones. Certainly gives an insight into how much people actually know about how the game is played.

[Lightning McQueen]

This might just go down as the worst thread ever on SA Footy and there have been a few shit ones. Certainly gives an insight into how much people actually know about how the game is played.

What are some of your gripey ones mate, I think some are tongue in cheek and others are a personal dislike.

[the milky bar kid]

This might just go down as the worst thread ever on SA Footy and there have been a few shit ones. Certainly gives an insight into how much people actually know about how the game is played.

That's giving absolutely way to much credit to OL's gay marraige thread...

[carey]

Troy Chaplin
Darryl Poole
R and Z Clarke
M.Liptak
S.Tasker
C.Hitchcock
J.Mail
Darren Smith
John Klug (or however you spell it)
Shoenmakers
Nick Mawell
Harry O'Brian
Nathan Krakour
Adrian McAdam

I could go on for Pages and Pages i have about 400 to list if the list was titled 'Most overrated players'

Pretty sure adrian mcadam kicked 91 goals in a season hardly the worst player to have played the game

Its more so the list of players i hated

[scoob]

This might just go down as the worst thread ever on SA Footy and there have been a few shit ones. Certainly gives an insight into how much people actually know about how the game is played.

So other people opinion differs from yours... Doesn't make them not valid - or shows a smaller knowledge of the game than you.

[GWW]

Pretty sure adrian mcadam kicked 91 goals in a season hardly the worst player to have played the game

68 in 1993, but agree, he doesn't belong on a "worst players" thread.

http://www.footywire.com/afl/footy/pc-k ... ian-mcadam

[Booney]

This might just go down as the worst thread ever on SA Footy and there have been a few shit ones. Certainly gives an insight into how much people actually know about how the game is played.

What are some of your gripey ones mate, I think some are tongue in cheek and others are a personal dislike.

Well, tongue in cheek makes a joke of the thread, personal dislike adds to it and any player listed who played 50 or more games cant be that bad.

[Booney]

This might just go down as the worst thread ever on SA Footy and there have been a few shit ones. Certainly gives an insight into how much people actually know about how the game is played.

What are some of your gripey ones mate, I think some are tongue in cheek and others are a personal dislike.

Ian Perrie
Brett Ebert
Duigan More the poster
Maxwell - Only a premiership captain, named more than once.
Harry O'Brien
Jackson Trengove
Schoenmakers
Luke O'Sullivan

Some of these blokes the worst to ever play at AFL level are they?

[Media Park]

My opinions:

Perrie was an absolute spud to be kind.

O'Brien, Trengove, Ebert, Duigan all very harsh to be named.

Schoenmakers has strung one or two solid games together this year but is still ordinary.

Luke O'Sullivan I won't comment on, I've never heard of him.

[saintal]

My opinions:

Perrie was an absolute spud to be kind.

O'Brien, Trengove, Ebert, Duigan all very harsh to be named.

Schoenmakers has strung one or two solid games together this year but is still ordinary.

Luke O'Sullivan I won't comment on, I've never heard of him.

Went by the name of Rhino I reckon.

[stan]

My opinions:

Perrie was an absolute spud to be kind.

O'Brien, Trengove, Ebert, Duigan all very harsh to be named.

Schoenmakers has strung one or two solid games together this year but is still ordinary.

Luke O'Sullivan I won't comment on, I've never heard of him.

Went by the name of Rhino I reckon.

Also had 3 knee recons as well i think. Wasnt a bad player just had alot of injuries.

[GWW]

Was going to take legal action against the league and/or his club, too from memory, can't remember if anything ever happened out of that.

Settled out of court perhaps.

[FlyingHigh]

Was that due to the state of Waverley when he did his knee?

[woodublieve12]

the 22 blokes with essendon jumpers on tonight

[dedja]

[stampy]

lucas herbert was a star

[daysofourlives]

Leroy Jetta, maybe when his voice breaks he will improve
Alwyn Davey

As long as Essendon have these 2 spuds we have nothing to fear, the 2 of them put together dont even come close to Cyril