2017 AFL Season

[morell]

Didn't he get what would have been 2 down to 1, but stays at 2 cause of his previous bad record?

You, and just about everyone else, have previously agreed Wines was lucky.
Yet you then use the Wines case as a way of saying Jonas was unlucky, even though you've previously admitted the Wines one is not an accurate base case.

Jonas hit a bloke above the shoulders 50m off the ball. I've got no issue with him getting 2 weeks for it.

5aa were reporting that it was 3 down to 2. Could be wrong.

No, I am using Wines a precedent in an attempt to highlight that the MRP is so inconsistent it's laughable.

Jonas checked him and his shoulder connected with his neck. If he smashed him in the head then Dollhouse wouldn't have gotten up as quickly as he did - which is the entire point of using impact and a critical metric when determining these things!!

They can't one week say Greene was fine for literally kicking someone in the ******* face because "the player was fine, it didn't hurt him", give Ollie nothing because the player got up even though both incidents were unbelievably dangerous and then the next week ban someone even though he didn't hurt for what was a simple body check.

[amber_fluid]

It wasn't a body check Morrell!
If it was it went seriously wrong.

[morell]

He deserves 2 Morrell as others have stated on here.

Rubbish.

Can't believe you are defending his action Morrel, he had no reason to do it. Extremely dumb on his part

I'm not defending him per se - although i do think there was next to nothing in it - I'm pointing out the inconsistency with the MRP.

There have been many incidents brought before them this year that were dangerous but the player was let off or had their sentence reduced because the player being affected was physically fine. Jonas didn't get the same treatment.

Again, I am ok-ish with Jonas getting 2 weeks, if the other players doing actual dangerous shit get more.

It's that inconsistency that is stupefying.

[morell]

It wasn't a body check Morrell!
If it was it went seriously wrong.

Bloody oath it was. Dollhouse just got rocked and tried to milk a free. His shoulder got him on the neck.

Stop drinking beer and open your damn eyes.

[Booney]

Stop drinking beer and open your damn eyes.

Now hear this, I will not stand by and have someone suggest to anyone that they should stop drinking beer. We're all mates here, but you've crossed a line and I won't have it.

Drink as much as you want Amber.

[MW]

2nd time. Definition of repeat offender.

Yep and similar offence.
Keep your elbows to yourself.

He didn't elbow Dahlhaus.

And water is not wet...

[Jim05]

Didn't he get what would have been 2 down to 1, but stays at 2 cause of his previous bad record?

You, and just about everyone else, have previously agreed Wines was lucky.
Yet you then use the Wines case as a way of saying Jonas was unlucky, even though you've previously admitted the Wines one is not an accurate base case.

Jonas hit a bloke above the shoulders 50m off the ball. I've got no issue with him getting 2 weeks for it.

5aa were reporting that it was 3 down to 2. Could be wrong.

No, I am using Wines a precedent in an attempt to highlight that the MRP is so inconsistent it's laughable.

Jonas checked him and his shoulder connected with his neck. If he smashed him in the head then Dollhouse wouldn't have gotten up as quickly as he did - which is the entire point of using impact and a critical metric when determining these things!!

They can't one week say Greene was fine for literally kicking someone in the ******* face because "the player was fine, it didn't hurt him", give Ollie nothing because the player got up even though both incidents were unbelievably dangerous and then the next week ban someone even though he didn't hurt for what was a simple body check.

Technically 5aa were correct. Was a 2 week ban and then given 1 week extra for his bad record. With the early plea it comes back down to 2

[morell]

Stop drinking beer and open your damn eyes.

Now hear this, I will not stand by and have someone suggest to anyone that they should stop drinking beer. We're all mates here, but you've crossed a line and I won't have it.

Drink as much as you want Amber.

Yeast drink is vile and clouds ones judgement

[Booney]

Stop drinking beer and open your damn eyes.

Now hear this, I will not stand by and have someone suggest to anyone that they should stop drinking beer. We're all mates here, but you've crossed a line and I won't have it.
Drink as much as you want Amber.

Yeast drink is vile and clouds ones judgement

No Xmas card from me, heathen.

[amber_fluid]

Stop drinking beer and open your damn eyes.

Now hear this, I will not stand by and have someone suggest to anyone that they should stop drinking beer. We're all mates here, but you've crossed a line and I won't have it.

Drink as much as you want Amber.

Not that I need anyone's permission but cheers Booney!

[MW]

Beeker (Sam McClure) going with the following offers for Dusty:

Richmond: $1.2m/yr 7 years
North: $1.5m/yr 7 years

Going to be hard to turn down North's ridiculous offer but I think he will

[Brodlach]

Brisbanes Sam Skinner who can seriously play will undergo his third ACL op after doing it again on the weekend. Poor bloke only 20 years old

[amber_fluid]

Stop drinking beer and open your damn eyes.

Now hear this, I will not stand by and have someone suggest to anyone that they should stop drinking beer. We're all mates here, but you've crossed a line and I won't have it.

Drink as much as you want Amber.

Yeast drink is vile and clouds ones judgement

You should try it sometime as your judgement needs clouding by the sounds of it.

[JK]

Stop drinking beer and open your damn eyes.

Now hear this, I will not stand by and have someone suggest to anyone that they should stop drinking beer. We're all mates here, but you've crossed a line and I won't have it.

Drink as much as you want Amber.

Yeast drink is vile and clouds ones judgement

Ok NOW you've lost all credibility

[Dutchy]

Beeker (Sam McClure) going with the following offers for Dusty:

Richmond: $1.2m/yr 7 years
North: $1.5m/yr 7 years

Going to be hard to turn down North's ridiculous offer but I think he will

Cause Richmond are such a stable successful club

[Booney]

Beeker (Sam McClure) going with the following offers for Dusty:

Richmond: $1.2m/yr 7 years
North: $1.5m/yr 7 years

Going to be hard to turn down North's ridiculous offer but I think he will

Cause Richmond are such a stable successful club

North about to finish bottom, Richmond about to play at least 2 finals.

[Dutchy]

Want to compare Richmond's finals record?

[morell]

You should try it sometime as your judgement needs clouding by the sounds of it.

Yes beigey I've never tried beer before.

Nah it is honestly a vile substance, can't stand it. Don't know how people drink it.

I like the girly sugary drinks. And Captain Morgan.

[Jim05]

Yeast drink is vile and clouds ones judgement

Is this you?

[Booney]

Want to compare Richmond's finals record?

Irrelevant, really, isn't it?