SA Footy

Eagles2014 wrote:

valleys07 wrote:That call on Franklin is absolutely awful.

Agree, that was one of the softest frees for the year, no wonder Phil Davis could not believe it!

Blatant push. Doing it all day

Jim05 wrote:

woodublieve12 wrote:Would grundy be in all Australian consideration?

Has been good but don't think he would be anywhere near it.

I'll probably get shot down for this, but if Grundy is in AA consideration, then Tom Jonas absolutely must be.

Both won't be though. Talia the exception of "non fashionable" defenders making AA, Jonas and Grundy wouldn't make AA for that reason.

Another big question, is Buddy better now than ever?

Lever on ice in the last. possible hammy and corky

woodublieve12 wrote:Another big question, is Buddy better now than ever?

didnt he kick 100 in a year? that would be hard to beat...

valleys07 wrote:

Jim05 wrote:

woodublieve12 wrote:Would grundy be in all Australian consideration?

Has been good but don't think he would be anywhere near it.

I'll probably get shot down for this, but if Grundy is in AA consideration, then Tom Jonas absolutely must be.

Both won't be though. Talia the exception of "non fashionable" defenders making AA, Jonas and Grundy wouldn't make AA for that reason.

I doubt Talia would be in currently.

Not currently, referring to previous years, Jim.

0-6 to start the season. Now a game out of the 4. Unbelievable.

valleys07 wrote:Not currently, referring to previous years, Jim.

Fair enough. Who knows how they will vote but my back 6 would be:
Howe, Rance, Laird
Docherty, Hurley, Yeo

woodublieve12 wrote:0-6 to start the season. Now a game out of the 4. Unbelievable.

fair to say with the team you have you shouldnt have been 0-6 in the first place...
phenomenal recovery though and will be hard to beat in September

Jim05 wrote:

valleys07 wrote:Not currently, referring to previous years, Jim.

Fair enough. Who knows how they will vote but my back 6 would be:
Howe, Rance, Laird
Docherty, Hurley, Yeo

hard to argue with that back six except Howe but I havent watched enough pies to know

Jim05 wrote:

valleys07 wrote:Not currently, referring to previous years, Jim.

Fair enough. Who knows how they will vote but my back 6 would be:
Howe, Rance, Laird
Docherty, Hurley, Yeo

Yep- that would be my back 6 also.

woodublieve12 wrote:0-6 to start the season. Now a game out of the 4. Unbelievable.

Port have not only beaten a top 8 side, we rolled the premiership favourites

Kane Cornes :

Dangerfield won't miss many, he tends to exaggerate his injuries.

DOC wrote:Kane Cornes :

Dangerfield won't miss many, he tends to exaggerate his injuries.

He was the first player to be investigated for staging, so I guess he knows a lot about exaggerating.

He'll play this week. Lever and Sloane won't though.

Depends on what his scans show up tomorrow. Issues around the ankle area.

DOC wrote:Kane Cornes :

Dangerfield won't miss many, he tends to exaggerate his injuries.

Cornes is an absolute flog.

Wedgie wrote:Depends on what his scans show up tomorrow. Issues around the ankle area.

You can't play like he did with anything decent damaged.

MW wrote:

Wedgie wrote:Depends on what his scans show up tomorrow. Issues around the ankle area.

You can't play like he did with anything decent damaged.

When he cooled down and the jab wore off.

Sloane will play.