SA Footy

Brodlach wrote:

Lightning McQueen wrote:

Brodlach wrote:MItch Hinge officially signs with the Crows as a DFA

The Crows should target Daw, I reckon them two would work well together.

There’s plenty of knobs already there


(Just getting in first)

Trader wrote:

Booney wrote:Tell me if I'm wrong here, please.

Collingwood trade Treloar, picks 26,33 and 42 (1687 points) for pick 14 and future 2nd rounder ( we'll call it pick 30, for points value - 1790 points ). So let's call the points even, for arguments sake.

As such Treloar for pick 14, does that pass the "pub test" when taking into account the AFL Integrity Unit sign off on all trades being fair and "market value"? For mine, it doesn't, again, tell me if you think I'm wrong.

I think your summary is wrong. (I'm working on the assumption that all they are getting is Pick 14 and the future 2nd rounder you mentioned above).

Collingwood give up: Treloar, picks 26, 33 and 42 or (Treloar & 1687 points).
Collingwood get: Pick 14 (1161) and Future Pick 30 (629pts) = 1790points.

In short, collingwood give up treloar and get a NET 103points, or the equivalent of pick 64.

Collingwood haven't given up Treloar for Pick 14, they've given him up for pick 64!!!!!

I agree it doesn't pass the sniff test!!!