SA Footy

wth he didn't even touch it

This goal umpire is having a blinder tonight. And by blinder I mean he can't see a thing out there.

Powell Pepper next captain

Arc needs to go. Time wasting at best. Get the technology right. That second one was a clear goal. Goal umpires are doubting them selves and are coming as usual as umpires in cricket

woodublieve12 wrote:Arc needs to go. Time wasting at best. Get the technology right. That second one was a clear goal. Goal umpires are doubting them selves and are coming as usual as umpires in cricket

Absolutely, took for ages on 2 decision and one of them was wrong anyway.

And thst 50m just then was fricken horrendous.

This entire round has been shit umpire round.

its a Power surge at the moment

They have 4 umpires and they all have a different interpretation of deliberate.

Game over

Sydney with an absolute run on from the umpires int he last 5 mins.

Spargo wrote:

woodublieve12 wrote:Didn't even look bad. Absolutely guttered for him

Shouldn’t be playing - period. If the AFL are serious about protecting blokes he should’ve been tapped on the shoulder long ago. How many more concussions for him, 3? 5? Maybe 10 more?
Forget the “feel good comeback story” spun by Sydney, this is ridiculous.

100% agree. If we’re talking about one more head knock being potentially the end of his career then why the **** is he even out there? That was a terrible look on something that wasn’t even that bad let’s be honest. Sydney and the AFL should be shot! On top of that there are a few more from other clubs in the same boat.

LaughingKookaburra wrote:

Spargo wrote:

woodublieve12 wrote:Didn't even look bad. Absolutely guttered for him

Shouldn’t be playing - period. If the AFL are serious about protecting blokes he should’ve been tapped on the shoulder long ago. How many more concussions for him, 3? 5? Maybe 10 more?
Forget the “feel good comeback story” spun by Sydney, this is ridiculous.

100% agree. If we’re talking about one more head knock being potentially the end of his career then why the **** is he even out there? That was a terrible look on something that wasn’t even that bad let’s be honest. Sydney and the AFL should be shot! On top of that there are a few more from other clubs in the same boat.

What a shock. People take cheap shots at the Swans for something that wasn't an issue for the past 18 months. He played in the reserves the year before last...

woodublieve12 wrote:

LaughingKookaburra wrote:

Spargo wrote:

woodublieve12 wrote:Didn't even look bad. Absolutely guttered for him

Shouldn’t be playing - period. If the AFL are serious about protecting blokes he should’ve been tapped on the shoulder long ago. How many more concussions for him, 3? 5? Maybe 10 more?
Forget the “feel good comeback story” spun by Sydney, this is ridiculous.

100% agree. If we’re talking about one more head knock being potentially the end of his career then why the **** is he even out there? That was a terrible look on something that wasn’t even that bad let’s be honest. Sydney and the AFL should be shot! On top of that there are a few more from other clubs in the same boat.

What a shock. People take cheap shots at the Swans for something that wasn't an issue for the past 18 months. He played in the reserves the year before last...

Cmon man, take your rose coloured glasses off. That was shithouse and Will Hamill at Adelaide in my opinion is in the same boat.

woodublieve12 wrote:

LaughingKookaburra wrote:

Spargo wrote:

woodublieve12 wrote:Didn't even look bad. Absolutely guttered for him

Shouldn’t be playing - period. If the AFL are serious about protecting blokes he should’ve been tapped on the shoulder long ago. How many more concussions for him, 3? 5? Maybe 10 more?
Forget the “feel good comeback story” spun by Sydney, this is ridiculous.

100% agree. If we’re talking about one more head knock being potentially the end of his career then why the **** is he even out there? That was a terrible look on something that wasn’t even that bad let’s be honest. Sydney and the AFL should be shot! On top of that there are a few more from other clubs in the same boat.

What a shock. People take cheap shots at the Swans for something that wasn't an issue for the past 18 months. He played in the reserves the year before last...

We’re all a bit wiser & educated now. If you really think this is taking cheap shots at the Swans…

Rather than looking at it as people having a shot Wubbzy, look at it that people are looking out for Patty.

How the hell is that play on?

Paddy obviously knows the risks and has made his decision to play.

2 McCartin boys down for the Swines, Lingy?

Lycett.

Yet again, most overrated player in the AFL by the length of the straight. Absolutely rubbish

Armchair expert wrote:Paddy obviously knows the risks and has made his decision to play.

How the hell does that make it right?

Spargo wrote:

woodublieve12 wrote:

LaughingKookaburra wrote:

Spargo wrote:[quote="woodublieve12"]Didn't even look bad. Absolutely guttered for him

Shouldn’t be playing - period. If the AFL are serious about protecting blokes he should’ve been tapped on the shoulder long ago. How many more concussions for him, 3? 5? Maybe 10 more?
Forget the “feel good comeback story” spun by Sydney, this is ridiculous.

100% agree. If we’re talking about one more head knock being potentially the end of his career then why the **** is he even out there? That was a terrible look on something that wasn’t even that bad let’s be honest. Sydney and the AFL should be shot! On top of that there are a few more from other clubs in the same boat.

What a shock. People take cheap shots at the Swans for something that wasn't an issue for the past 18 months. He played in the reserves the year before last...

We’re all a bit wiser & educated now. If you really think this is taking cheap shots at the Swans…[/quote]Just look at how much more we know in the last 10 years versus the 40 hears before.

End of the day he was cleared to play by doctors and the AFL. The question is should he have been? No idea and we aren't in a position to make that call but based on the recent events around concussion, you would think the they would be taking a more conservative approach.