Jacob Surjan

[Pup]

Surjan may go. Will it be in a trade for someone like Byron Schammer. Yes he may have just signed a new contract earlier this year but it isnt out of the question. Or even a Shannon Hurn.

Carlton will not be after Sandilands. Cloke, Hampson, Kruzer, Warnock, Jacobs. They have a good ruck squad to work with for the next 5-10 years.

Hawthorn however could definitely give it a real shake if the right offer went freo's way.

IMO tho, PP shouldnt trade Surjan unless he wants out, he has had a pretty solid year. One of only 4 or 5 that can say that.

No chance.

Good chance to win the Eagles Best and Fairest this year and is contracted until the end of 2011. Wont be going anywhere.

[Pup]

Since we're all talking hypotheticals, IF Surjan were able to return home via trade, you'd think Beau Waters could be like-for-like.

Some Port fans would argue Surjan is worth more than Waters given his injury problems over the last 2 years and i tend to agree.

[JK]

Since we're all talking hypotheticals, IF Surjan were able to return home via trade, you'd think Beau Waters could be like-for-like.

Some Port fans would argue Surjan is worth more than Waters given his injury problems over the last 2 years and i tend to agree.

On recent value yep, but at the best either of them has displayed, I'd give the vote to Waters (just IMHO) .. Either way, the difference between the 2 is negligible.

[Swooper16]

Waters wouldnt be going anywhere whilst Woosha is still coaching the Weagles..!!

Surjan for Seaby would be the most likely but i think Port would be getting the rough end of the stick on this deal.

[GWW]

Surjan for Seaby would be the most likely but i think Port would be getting the rough end of the stick on this deal.

I think there would need to be more to that deal for Port to accept it.

[wycbloods]

Surjan for Seaby would be the most likely but i think Port would be getting the rough end of the stick on this deal.

I think there would need to be more to that deal for Port to accept it.

I doubt it that seems a pretty fair deal to me. Seaby is what port really need.

[dotmar]

Surjan for Seaby would be the most likely but i think Port would be getting the rough end of the stick on this deal.

I think there would need to be more to that deal for Port to accept it.

I doubt it that seems a pretty fair deal to me. Seaby is what port really need.

Have to agree there Port are getting a good deal. Surjan is an average player that tries his guts out but port are in need of a ruckman. Seaby would be more than handy in the power squad. Now that Lade has finally gone i think is the right trade!!!