Page 21 of 43
Re: Preliminary Final teams.
Posted:
Mon Sep 17, 2018 3:43 pmby locky801
The determination wont mean much
Norwood will win by plenty, only difference is if the Eagles play there will be about 10,000 less in the crowd
Re: Preliminary Final teams.
Posted:
Mon Sep 17, 2018 3:44 pmby Bombers4EVA
another grub wrote:Bombers4EVA wrote:Nothing will happen. The only thing North did wrong is play an extra man. The rules state that the captain of the opposing team needs to make the umpire aware of the extra man and call for a head count. He didn't so unfortunately North get away with it. I
If it didnt change the outcome of the game then I am fine with that PUTRID old rule .....but it clearly has.
Rules or common sense???? I guess thats what they have to decide today.
I agree with ya but I reckon the rules will win this debacle.
Re: Preliminary Final teams.
Posted:
Mon Sep 17, 2018 3:46 pmby Groucho
Don't the S.A.N.F.L. have to be told what the decision will be by their AFL Overlords? They need to consider what is in the best interests of the AFL the same as every other decision.
They'll probably do nothing.
Re: Preliminary Final teams.
Posted:
Mon Sep 17, 2018 3:46 pmby another grub
I think so to Bomber.
Re: Preliminary Final teams.
Posted:
Mon Sep 17, 2018 3:50 pmby locky801
Re: Preliminary Final teams.
Posted:
Mon Sep 17, 2018 3:51 pmby Punk Rooster
Jim05 wrote:Eagles training this arvo and their CEO has said the club is exploring legal avenues
Bit early for pre-season- even AFL teams have 6 weeks off...
Re: Preliminary Final teams.
Posted:
Mon Sep 17, 2018 3:53 pmby dogbreath
Solution. :
Amalgamate the Hybrids once more with the Cocks & joint team can play Norwood in the GF.
Call them the Soft Cocks.
Norwood still win by 20+
Re: Preliminary Final teams.
Posted:
Mon Sep 17, 2018 3:54 pmby bulldogproud
Punk Rooster wrote:Jim05 wrote:Eagles training this arvo and their CEO has said the club is exploring legal avenues
Bit early for pre-season- even AFL teams have 6 weeks off...
I think they are actually just exploring Oval Avenue: part of mad Monday.
Re: Preliminary Final teams.
Posted:
Mon Sep 17, 2018 4:16 pmby GMcG
Interesting that North have actually fessed up about them cheating, this should be taken into consideration.
Re: Preliminary Final teams.
Posted:
Mon Sep 17, 2018 4:20 pmby Magellan
GMcG wrote:Interesting that North have actually fessed up about them cheating, this should be taken into consideration.
Didn't hear anything about admitting to cheating. Heard that there was an interchange error, which the club readily admits.
Re: Preliminary Final teams.
Posted:
Mon Sep 17, 2018 4:24 pmby woodublieve12
Bad luck eagles. Enjoy mad Monday. Nothing should come of this
Re: Preliminary Final teams.
Posted:
Mon Sep 17, 2018 4:27 pmby The Jack
Seems pretty cut and dried to me. Eagles through is the only solution. Scored 8 points with a man extra, take those points away. Simples. If it was a horse race... Margin on the line insufficient to cover interference caused to the 2nd placed horse at the top of the straight, protest upheld. Amended placings are...
Re: Preliminary Final teams.
Posted:
Mon Sep 17, 2018 4:43 pmby Jim05
North win but Carr and the player in question suspended from the GF
Re: Preliminary Final teams.
Posted:
Mon Sep 17, 2018 4:52 pmby another grub
Any other ideas how we could decide a winner?.......
Free Kick shoot out?
Which team got the most magarey votes?
Highest finishing position at end of minor round?
Let the 4,000 ravens fans have a vote?
Grog Squad v the Eagles supporters on who sings the club song better/ louder?
Re: Preliminary Final teams.
Posted:
Mon Sep 17, 2018 4:54 pmby another grub
The Jack wrote:Seems pretty cut and dried to me. Eagles through is the only solution. Scored 8 points with a man extra, take those points away. Simples. If it was a horse race... Margin on the line insufficient to cover interference caused to the 2nd placed horse at the top of the straight, protest upheld. Amended placings are...
Thats the logical thing to do but it gets messy with that stupid rule they still have.
Re: Preliminary Final teams.
Posted:
Mon Sep 17, 2018 4:55 pmby Pseudo
another grub wrote:Any other ideas how we could decide a winner?.......
Free Kick shoot out?
Which team got the most magarey votes?
Highest finishing position at end of minor round?
Let the 4,000 ravens fans have a vote?
Ro-sham-bo!
Re: Preliminary Final teams.
Posted:
Mon Sep 17, 2018 4:57 pmby another grub
Let Roo and Dits decide ?
Re: Preliminary Final teams.
Posted:
Mon Sep 17, 2018 4:58 pmby Dogs64
Should replay one quarter, with starting scores from end of the third.
The rule re the captain having to notify the umpires isn't necessarily very workable or fair.
Re: Preliminary Final teams.
Posted:
Mon Sep 17, 2018 5:00 pmby mots02
another grub wrote:Any other ideas how we could decide a winner?.......
Free Kick shoot out?
Which team got the most magarey votes?
Highest finishing position at end of minor round?
Let the 4,000 ravens fans have a vote?
Grog Squad v the Eagles supporters on who sings the club song better/ louder?
Retro Round boxing match - The Weed v Kym Klomp?
Re: Preliminary Final teams.
Posted:
Mon Sep 17, 2018 5:02 pmby JK
another grub wrote:Any other ideas how we could decide a winner?.......
Free Kick shoot out?
Which team got the most magarey votes?
Highest finishing position at end of minor round?
Let the 4,000 ravens fans have a vote?
Grog Squad v the Eagles supporters on who sings the club song better/ louder?
Soggy Sao
