2013 Magarey Medal

[Dutchy]

Not far away now and well into the season, who are the standouts from your clubs so far?

[The Sleeping Giant]

Fairly even spread at North. Gordon to poll well early, with the Thring brothers and Thiele also polling well.

Winner won't come from North this year.

[Ian]

I think you're right TSG, no one has been a stand out for the whole year, Nipper started in a blaze of glory but doesn't appear to like the cold and wet, others have stepped up as he's dropped off, I think you'll see quite a few from North in the top 20 but none in the top 5

[Jim05]

Eagleton is a shoe in

[saintal]

Liddle is the obvious stand out at South, although he did start the season slowly by his standards. Scott's stats will show that he and Cross receive the most frees in the comp which doesn't hurt their chances. Cross will poll a few but hasn't had the year he had last year.

Others that will do well in the Knuckey cup but wont necessarily poll many votes are defenders Hartigan and Redigolo, and on baller Gotch.

[Pseudo]

Fairly even spread at North. Gordon to poll well early, with the Thring brothers and Thiele also polling well.

Winner won't come from North this year.

Fairly even spread at Glenelg too. Winner won't come from the Bays either.

[The Sleeping Giant]

Good point.

[DOC]

Liddle is the obvious stand out at South, although he did start the season slowly by his standards. Scott's stats will show that he and Cross receive the most frees in the comp which doesn't hurt their chances. Cross will poll a few but hasn't had the year he had last year.

Others that will do well in the Knuckey cup but wont necessarily poll many votes are defenders Hartigan and Redigolo, and on baller Gotch.

Scott who?

[Dogwatcher]

Boyd or O'Hara will poll best for us. Glenn will get a few sneaky ones.
Don't think we'll have the winner.

[Big Phil]

I think the winner will come from one of:

Matt Suckling (very consistent year but may have blokes share votes)

Nathan Gordon (he'll come home strong with the warmer weather in Spring)

Nick Liddle (seems to be Mr Consistent again, Joel Cross may take some votes)

Joel Cross (hasn't seemed as dominant as 2012, Liddle may take some votes)

Sam Gray (has been very good all year, Kirkwood and Beard may take votes)

Brayden O'Hara (has had his best year, so far, but Dogs have struggled a bit)

James Boyd (Dogs have had an average year, O'Hara may take some votes)

Ben MacReadie (had a great start to the year, dropped off of late, may share votes with Schmidt)

Chris Schmidt (had another good year but may have to share a few votes with others)

Ryan Ferguson (would love to see a non-midfielder win it, but just don't think it will happen)

[leggies]

Matt Suckling or Matt Thomas from Norwood would be a chance for us.



Sent from my GT-I9505 using Tapatalk 2

[Jim05]

Matt Suckling at this stage would be going well.
Would think Grigg might collect a few votes aswell

[saintal]

Liddle is the obvious stand out at South, although he did start the season slowly by his standards. Scott's stats will show that he and Cross receive the most frees in the comp which doesn't hurt their chances. Cross will poll a few but hasn't had the year he had last year.

Others that will do well in the Knuckey cup but wont necessarily poll many votes are defenders Hartigan and Redigolo, and on baller Gotch.

Scott who?

The resident stats guru. See the sticky thread at the top of the page DOC.

[Mark_Beswick]

Cant see it being a west player this year

Suckling, Gordon, Liddle, B. Martin,..... Hard to pick as many players have had god months and then dipped in and out.

[Jim05]

Tambling would be worth a punt.
Lack of wins at Sturt might hurt but think he has been BOG in a few of their wins and is a flashy type player

[DOC]

Liddle is the obvious stand out at South, although he did start the season slowly by his standards. Scott's stats will show that he and Cross receive the most frees in the comp which doesn't hurt their chances. Cross will poll a few but hasn't had the year he had last year.

Others that will do well in the Knuckey cup but wont necessarily poll many votes are defenders Hartigan and Redigolo, and on baller Gotch.

Scott who?

The resident stats guru. See the sticky thread at the top of the page DOC.

Sorry. I thought you meant a player.

For us, I think Nick Liddle comfortably.

[Aerie]

Goldsworthy would be Eagles best chance IMO.

[dedja]

I predict the whole Bays team will get less than 10 votes for the season ...

[rod_rooster]

George Thring would be the most likely from North but too many blokes stealing votes off each other for it to come from Prospect this year.

[prowling panther]

Nick Liddle and Joel Cross from South look like being our clubs best chance. Tarak Redigolo has had a consistent year but does not flash around to catch the umpires eye. He did win the Seconds Magarey Medal a couple of years back, so he has what it takes.

George Thring is my tip at this part of the season.