SA Footy

I stopped reading after seeing Ryswyk at 19.

Maybe if they were rating downhill skiers he'd be up there.

Good effort. Good to see the time and effort taken as it continues to promote the SANFL.

topsywaldron wrote:I stopped reading after seeing Ryswyk at 19.

Maybe if they were rating downhill skiers he'd be up there.

You obviously don't watch alot of North games do you?

Slattery yet to pull a guernsey on in anger and makes the list.....

Booney wrote:Slattery yet to pull a guernsey on in anger and makes the list.....

Yeah, how does that work?

The Dark Knight wrote:

Booney wrote:Slattery yet to pull a guernsey on in anger and makes the list.....

Yeah, how does that work?

Read the article with the list and the boys explain that.

Big Phil wrote:

The Dark Knight wrote:

Booney wrote:Slattery yet to pull a guernsey on in anger and makes the list.....

Yeah, how does that work?

Read the article with the list and the boys explain that.

BP I dont think Slattery played a league SANFL games so he has not earned any stripes either.

Returning AFL players were eligible but only Michael Coad, who has a proven record in the SANFL, and proven AFL performer Henry Slattery made it. The rest have to earn their stripes in the local league

Kieran McGuinness who has not played for a year ?
James Aish is not in the top 10 ?????

Not a bad effort on something that will always create discussion.
Couple of changes I reckon, Scott Lewis lucky to be there before Gallman and Joe Anderson.
Luke Harder I'd have a bit higher.

Big Phil wrote:

The Dark Knight wrote:

Booney wrote:Slattery yet to pull a guernsey on in anger and makes the list.....

Yeah, how does that work?

Read the article with the list and the boys explain that.

Well Matt Campbell has more claim than Slattery if they are using past SANFL plus AFL???

From Central Jarrod Schiller a tad lucky, he had that magnificent season in 2011 but last year really didnt reach any great heights apart from the cameo quarter here and there.

The unlucky ones from Central were Corey Reichart and Matty Westhoff

WALOC! Should read POTENTIALLY Messenger's Top 50 SANFL Players.
Boyd was by far the best player in 2012.

A (surprisingly?) good attempt.

topsywaldron wrote:I stopped reading after seeing Ryswyk at 19.

Maybe if they were rating downhill skiers he'd be up there.

Made it further than I. Got to K Mac.

on the rails wrote:

topsywaldron wrote:I stopped reading after seeing Ryswyk at 19.

Maybe if they were rating downhill skiers he'd be up there.

You obviously don't watch alot of North games do you?

He's a gun when you're ten goals up.

The irony here is that if he'd signed for the club that flew him down to South Australia he'd be a premiership player by now.

topsywaldron wrote:

on the rails wrote:

topsywaldron wrote:I stopped reading after seeing Ryswyk at 19.

Maybe if they were rating downhill skiers he'd be up there.

You obviously don't watch alot of North games do you?

He's a gun when you're ten goals up.

The irony here is that if he'd signed for the club that flew him down to South Australia he'd be a premiership player by now.

We may donate the cost of the airfares you paid (at the 2005 price!) to help you pay the big fine your about to get for cheating again re the Salary Cap. That $200 shoudl help no end!

So with your lot and West outed as crooks then North claim the "Moral" Premiership for 2012 for being an upstanding club that abides by the rules! Don't froget to tell Bass to bring the flag and cup with him when you visit us in Round 6!

This is obviously all very subjective, but Ty Allen not in the top 20?

on the rails wrote: Don't froget to tell Bass to bring the flag and cup with him when you visit us in Round 6!

Happy to wave them at you Drebin.

topsywaldron wrote:

on the rails wrote: Don't froget to tell Bass to bring the flag and cup with him when you visit us in Round 6!

Happy to wave them at you Drebin.

I look fwd to that!