Page 1 of 5
Norwood vs Claremont
Posted:
Sun Oct 07, 2012 4:58 pmby FOURTH ESTATE
Would Norwood & Bassett be prepared to take on Claremont in a Premiers challenge????
Re: Norwood vs Claremont
Posted:
Sun Oct 07, 2012 4:59 pmby Pseudo
FOURTH ESTATE wrote:Would Norwood & Bassett be prepared to take on Claremont in a Premiers challenge????
Wouldn't be fair; Claremont players would have been on the turps for the last fortnight.
OTOH, that might even things up a little...
Re: Norwood vs Claremont
Posted:
Sun Oct 07, 2012 5:03 pmby locky801
Bassett wont be there so not his decision
Re: Norwood vs Claremont
Posted:
Sun Oct 07, 2012 5:08 pmby am Bays
Pseudo wrote:FOURTH ESTATE wrote:Would Norwood & Bassett be prepared to take on Claremont in a Premiers challenge????
Wouldn't be fair; Claremont players would have been on the turps for the last fortnight.
OTOH, that might even things up a little...
Plus Claremont players might still be fatigued from playing three extra games in the Roxtel Cup compared to the Nwd blokes!
Re: Norwood vs Claremont
Posted:
Sun Oct 07, 2012 7:48 pmby Jimmy_041
Good idea though
Re: Norwood vs Claremont
Posted:
Mon Oct 08, 2012 12:07 pmby Bluedemon
Play it as a pre-season game before the season starts.
Re: Norwood vs Claremont
Posted:
Mon Oct 08, 2012 12:22 pmby mighty_tiger_79
Have the Premiers Challenge part of the Foxtel Cup??
Re: Norwood vs Claremont
Posted:
Mon Oct 08, 2012 3:40 pmby MATT IN WA
People on a WA forum I read reckon on yesterdays performance, Claremont would smash 'em.
Tend to agree.
Re: Norwood vs Claremont
Posted:
Mon Oct 08, 2012 3:56 pmby MagareyLegend
Bluedemon wrote:Play it as a pre-season game before the season starts.
That's when most pre-season games are
Re: Norwood vs Claremont
Posted:
Mon Oct 08, 2012 4:09 pmby SDK
Who cares about that League. You want us to play the Ammo premiers too ?
Norwood would crush Claremont though
Re: Norwood vs Claremont
Posted:
Mon Oct 15, 2012 9:56 amby JamesH
considering SANFL clubs have double the salary cap and take the best of the VFL such a match would never be an even contest.... unless restricted to local players only - then Claremont would blow Norwood away
Re: Norwood vs Claremont
Posted:
Mon Oct 15, 2012 10:09 amby topsywaldron
JamesH wrote:unless restricted to local players only - then Claremont would blow Norwood away
Yes, Norwood's dominance of a competition with double the salary cap of the WAFL's was based almost exclusively on the involvement of their AFL listed players.
Re: Norwood vs Claremont
Posted:
Mon Oct 15, 2012 10:12 amby scoob
Norwood would give the Sydney Swans a run for their money, woul dbe Claremont by 10-15 goals
Re: Norwood vs Claremont
Posted:
Mon Oct 15, 2012 10:20 amby JamesH
topsywaldron wrote:JamesH wrote:unless restricted to local players only - then Claremont would blow Norwood away
Yes, Norwood's dominance of a competition with double the salary cap of the WAFL's was based almost exclusively on the involvement of their AFL listed players.
It is not a criticism of Norwood. They are just a better resourced club in terms of recruiting. WAFL relies a lot more on local players than the SANFL.
Re: Norwood vs Claremont
Posted:
Mon Oct 15, 2012 12:20 pmby gossipgirl
scoob wrote:Norwood would give the Sydney Swans a run for their money, woul dbe Claremont by 10-15 goals
not sure claremont would win by that much but you would expect them to win comfortable
Re: Norwood vs Claremont
Posted:
Mon Oct 15, 2012 12:26 pmby scoob
gossipgirl wrote:scoob wrote:Norwood would give the Sydney Swans a run for their money, woul dbe Claremont by 10-15 goals
not sure claremont would win by that much but you would expect them to win comfortable
Supposed to say Norwood would beat... Norwood would have won more games than 4 AFL side if they were in that comp this year...
Re: Norwood vs Claremont
Posted:
Mon Oct 15, 2012 12:32 pmby Jim05
scoob wrote:gossipgirl wrote:scoob wrote:Norwood would give the Sydney Swans a run for their money, woul dbe Claremont by 10-15 goals
not sure claremont would win by that much but you would expect them to win comfortable
Supposed to say Norwood would beat... Norwood would have won more games than 4 AFL side if they were in that comp this year...
As much as I love Norwood I couldnt see us getting within 5 goals of the GWS
Re: Norwood vs Claremont
Posted:
Mon Oct 15, 2012 12:37 pmby on the rails
scoob wrote:Norwood would give the Sydney Swans a run for their money, woul dbe Claremont by 10-15 goals
What a ridiculous post - the only time Norwood would give the Swans a run and be close would be if they entered the playing arena at the same time!
Re: Norwood vs Claremont
Posted:
Mon Oct 15, 2012 1:21 pmby GWW
Norwood would beat the All Australian side.
Re: Norwood vs Claremont
Posted:
Mon Oct 15, 2012 2:11 pmby JK
GWW wrote:Norwood would beat the All Australian side.
And the All Blacks, LA Lakers and New York Giants .. Reckon we were good things to take out Bathurst too