SA Footy

Reserves Elimination Final 2010
Central District v West Adelaide
Woodville Oval
Saturday, September 11, 11.25am

WEST ADELAIDE

B: M Barber K Thomson W Champion
HB: R Blesing C Chubb J Rowe
C: N Homburg S Birss M Krakouer
HF: T Langford Br Fisher L Hill
F: M Jose D Webb M Ward

R: M Borholm M Shearer S Harding
Int: P Nelson S Callahan A Anderson

Centrals Squad

From: L. Barmby, Cochrane, Duncan, Dunne, Edmead, Foldesdy, Frail, Fry, Hannath, Haydon, Hynes, Marschall, Musolino, J. Schiller, Switala, Vater, Waldhuter, L. Westhoff, M. Westhoff, M. White, N. White.

scott wrote:WEST ADELAIDE

B: M Barber K Thomson W Champion
HB: R Blesing C Chubb J Rowe
C: N Homburg S Birss M Krakouer
HF: T Langford Br Fisher L Hill
F: M Jose D Webb M Ward

R: M Borholm M Shearer S Harding
Int: P Nelson S Callahan A Anderson

Did Logan play league for the Bloods last week?

Thought that meant he isn't allowed to play in the reserves finals, same with Musolino from Central...

Big Phil wrote:

scott wrote:WEST ADELAIDE

B: M Barber K Thomson W Champion
HB: R Blesing C Chubb J Rowe
C: N Homburg S Birss M Krakouer
HF: T Langford Br Fisher L Hill
F: M Jose D Webb M Ward

R: M Borholm M Shearer S Harding
Int: P Nelson S Callahan A Anderson

Did Logan play league for the Bloods last week?

Thought that meant he isn't allowed to play in the reserves finals, same with Musolino from Central...

would be good if we could get clarification what the reserves qualification rules are.

would i be right in saying musolino has played the last 3 games in the league side or did he not play against sturt

I'm hoping Shearer, Webb, and Jose dominate, and Westies get the win.

(They're all from Flagstaff Hill, so I'm a bit one eyed)

And not sure why with the Dogs reserves side there is no Habel or Hardy who both played reserves last week?

I can only think they played more league than reserves. No doubt there's more to it since I'm sure Switala played more league than reserves. Maybe it's something along the lines of having to play 3 reserves in a row or be qualified as a reserves player.

Big Phil wrote:And not sure why with the Dogs reserves side there is no Habel or Hardy who both played reserves last week?

resting them for next weekend?

Grahaml wrote:I can only think they played more league than reserves. No doubt there's more to it since I'm sure Switala played more league than reserves. Maybe it's something along the lines of having to play 3 reserves in a row or be qualified as a reserves player.

I have heard the SANFL is trying to stop Switlala from fronting up on some technicality.

Big Phil wrote:

scott wrote:WEST ADELAIDE

B: M Barber K Thomson W Champion
HB: R Blesing C Chubb J Rowe
C: N Homburg S Birss M Krakouer
HF: T Langford Br Fisher L Hill
F: M Jose D Webb M Ward

R: M Borholm M Shearer S Harding
Int: P Nelson S Callahan A Anderson

Did Logan play league for the Bloods last week?

Thought that meant he isn't allowed to play in the reserves finals, same with Musolino from Central...

Was named on their interchange bench (as you probably know BP), did he play? Why no Hardy, Habel...anyone?

Will be at Woodville tomorrow and will probably have the laptop with me so will try and post some score updates if possible...

Big Phil wrote:

scott wrote:WEST ADELAIDE

B: M Barber K Thomson W Champion
HB: R Blesing C Chubb J Rowe
C: N Homburg S Birss M Krakouer
HF: T Langford Br Fisher L Hill
F: M Jose D Webb M Ward

R: M Borholm M Shearer S Harding
Int: P Nelson S Callahan A Anderson

Did Logan play league for the Bloods last week?

Thought that meant he isn't allowed to play in the reserves finals, same with Musolino from Central...

Logan did play league for the bloods last week

i wont be there saturday absoloutly spewing i have to work but luckily im working the div 6 grandfinal so i get to watch lockleys win 2 premierships in one day , think west will get this 1 so that i can go watch next week

sjt wrote:

Big Phil wrote:

scott wrote:WEST ADELAIDE

B: M Barber K Thomson W Champion
HB: R Blesing C Chubb J Rowe
C: N Homburg S Birss M Krakouer
HF: T Langford Br Fisher L Hill
F: M Jose D Webb M Ward

R: M Borholm M Shearer S Harding
Int: P Nelson S Callahan A Anderson

Did Logan play league for the Bloods last week?

Thought that meant he isn't allowed to play in the reserves finals, same with Musolino from Central...

Was named on their interchange bench (as you probably know BP), did he play? Why no Hardy, Habel...anyone?

Dogs have lodged a complaint about this to the SANFL.

How Habel/Hardy cant play but Musolino can(who played league round 23) is a joke.

Big Phil wrote:And not sure why with the Dogs reserves side there is no Habel or Hardy who both played reserves last week?

They've played too many League games, so they are ineligable

So how come Switala can play when he hasnt played the 5 reserve games. Hardy must be injured cause im sure he has played at least 5. Habel not sure if injured, but wouldnt he be in the same position as Switala. Seems a bit weird to me.

I would have thought anyone with League and Reserves still in finals could please themselves who played where until the League side was out of finals. SANFL clearly dosen't = common sense.

Pidge wrote:

Big Phil wrote:And not sure why with the Dogs reserves side there is no Habel or Hardy who both played reserves last week?

They've played too many League games, so they are ineligable

Sorry, but incorrect Pidge...

If that were the case, Cochrane and Switala would not have been given permission to play...

http://www.adelaidenow.com.au/sport/afl ... 5917399842

Has to be either injury or Roy Laird not wanting them to play and risk injury as they may be in calculations for league selection next week...

PUNTER wrote:I would have thought anyone with League and Reserves still in finals could please themselves who played where until the League side was out of finals. SANFL clearly dosen't = common sense.

When both or all sides are in the finals qualification games don't apply for interchange between league/ressies and U18s.