The Bye????
Posted: Mon Feb 01, 2010 7:33 amWith the talk of both Ports merging or Magpies folding the Bye is being brought up again as an issue, I'm wondering once and for all what everyone thinks about it.
Page 1 of 2
Posted: Mon Feb 01, 2010 7:33 amRe: The Bye????
Posted: Mon Feb 01, 2010 7:35 amI've voted for it, I think it gives supporters and players time during the season to catch up with family and friends and a bit of time for injuries to heal.
Re: The Bye????
Posted: Mon Feb 01, 2010 11:55 amCUTTERMAN wrote:I've voted for it, I think it gives supporters and players time during the season to catch up with family and friends and a bit of time for injuries to heal.
I'm with you C-MAN!
Re: The Bye????
Posted: Mon Feb 01, 2010 12:01 pmCUTTERMAN wrote:I've voted for it, I think it gives supporters and players time during the season to catch up with family and friends and a bit of time for injuries to heal.
Same reasons I like the bye.
If we did go to an 8 team comp I wonder if a split round would be a permanent fixture to allow some sort of mid-season break?
Re: The Bye????
Posted: Mon Feb 01, 2010 12:02 pmCUTTERMAN wrote:I've voted for it, I think it gives supporters and players time during the season to catch up with family and friends and a bit of time for injuries to heal.
Agreed ... Or head back to your local Ammo's club or catch some AFL footy etc.
Re: The Bye????
Posted: Mon Feb 01, 2010 12:09 pmConstance_Perm wrote:CUTTERMAN wrote:I've voted for it, I think it gives supporters and players time during the season to catch up with family and friends and a bit of time for injuries to heal.
Agreed ... Or head back to your local Ammo's club or catch some AFL footy etc.
Mentioning AFL in the SANFL room. Balls as big as onions have you CP?
Re: The Bye????
Posted: Mon Feb 01, 2010 12:11 pmBooney wrote:Constance_Perm wrote:CUTTERMAN wrote:I've voted for it, I think it gives supporters and players time during the season to catch up with family and friends and a bit of time for injuries to heal.
Agreed ... Or head back to your local Ammo's club or catch some AFL footy etc.
Mentioning AFL in the SANFL room. Balls as big as onions have you CP?
I knew I'd risk the ire of Pseudo .. Hopefully he doesn't find this thread
Re: The Bye????
Posted: Mon Feb 01, 2010 12:14 pmOnly a matter of time before he Googles "bye"....
Re: The Bye????
Posted: Mon Feb 01, 2010 1:18 pmI like having that week off but I've gone with crap because of the uneven way the draw is structured.
Re: The Bye????
Posted: Mon Feb 01, 2010 1:32 pmConstance_Perm wrote:Booney wrote:Constance_Perm wrote:CUTTERMAN wrote:I've voted for it, I think it gives supporters and players time during the season to catch up with family and friends and a bit of time for injuries to heal.
Agreed ... Or head back to your local Ammo's club or catch some AFL footy etc.
Mentioning AFL in the SANFL room. Balls as big as onions have you CP?
I knew I'd risk the ire of Pseudo .. Hopefully he doesn't find this thread
Go for a double header and get someone from the Eagles to tweet it on their new twitter site.
Re: The Bye????
Posted: Mon Feb 01, 2010 1:37 pmdedja wrote:Go for a double header and get someone from the Eagles to tweet it on their new twitter site.
I'll get Don Henley onto it right away
Re: The Bye????
Posted: Mon Feb 01, 2010 2:16 pmI wanna see my team every week, so I voted against it.
Admittedly, you can use that week to go and spy on the opposition.
With any luck it will be 'the game of the round' between teams on top of the ladder.
If not.....
*boring*
Admittedly, you can use that week to go and spy on the opposition.
With any luck it will be 'the game of the round' between teams on top of the ladder.
If not.....
*boring*Re: The Bye????
Posted: Mon Feb 01, 2010 2:45 pmIm with sabre, I want to see my team every week, forget the bye it is crap and also very uneven to the game structure over the season.
The week off in the middle of the season can go back to the Interstate game/s
Cheers
The week off in the middle of the season can go back to the Interstate game/s
Cheers
Re: The Bye????
Posted: Mon Feb 01, 2010 3:17 pmI don't like the bye.
I just had a great (or very stupid) idea on how to get rid of it.
The team that has the bye plays the WAFL side that has the bye on the same round.
The result of the match gets recorded on our premiership table, but the name of the WAFL side gets recorded only as "WAFL".
So for example, if Central plays Swan Districts in round one and the Dogs win 95-90 then the premiership table would read:
Central 1-0 95-90
WAFL 0-1 90-95
Likewise the result would get recorded on the WAFL premiership ladder
SANFL 1-0 95-90
Swan Districts 0-1 90-95
Then in the following week Norwood gets belted by Claremont 150-50, the result would again be tallied under SANFL and WAFL in the respective leagues. Hence after two rounds, on the SANFL ladder:
WAFL 1-1 240-145
And on the WAFL ladder:
SANFL 1-1 145-240
And so the seaon continues with the teams playing the bye acting as representatives for their respective leagues until we enter the finals. Which would become a "final 5" for both leagues.
If the SANFL or WAFL bye team makes the finals in the others' opposing league then the 6th ranked side from the represented league would play in the other's finals series. So let's say Westies finish 6th in the SANFL, but the SANFL makes the 5 on the WAFL ladder, then Westies would play the WAFL finals from 5th place. And same for the WAFL if they have the same situation in the SANFL.
Brilliant or stupid
I just had a great (or very stupid) idea on how to get rid of it.
The team that has the bye plays the WAFL side that has the bye on the same round.
The result of the match gets recorded on our premiership table, but the name of the WAFL side gets recorded only as "WAFL".
So for example, if Central plays Swan Districts in round one and the Dogs win 95-90 then the premiership table would read:
Central 1-0 95-90
WAFL 0-1 90-95
Likewise the result would get recorded on the WAFL premiership ladder
SANFL 1-0 95-90
Swan Districts 0-1 90-95
Then in the following week Norwood gets belted by Claremont 150-50, the result would again be tallied under SANFL and WAFL in the respective leagues. Hence after two rounds, on the SANFL ladder:
WAFL 1-1 240-145
And on the WAFL ladder:
SANFL 1-1 145-240
And so the seaon continues with the teams playing the bye acting as representatives for their respective leagues until we enter the finals. Which would become a "final 5" for both leagues.
If the SANFL or WAFL bye team makes the finals in the others' opposing league then the 6th ranked side from the represented league would play in the other's finals series. So let's say Westies finish 6th in the SANFL, but the SANFL makes the 5 on the WAFL ladder, then Westies would play the WAFL finals from 5th place. And same for the WAFL if they have the same situation in the SANFL.
Brilliant or stupid
Re: The Bye????
Posted: Mon Feb 01, 2010 3:25 pmdifferent
Re: The Bye????
Posted: Mon Feb 01, 2010 3:42 pmtherisingblues wrote:.
Brilliant ?:
Nup, sorry, the other one.
Re: The Bye????
Posted: Mon Feb 01, 2010 3:48 pmBooney wrote:therisingblues wrote:.
Brilliant ?:
Nup, sorry, the other one.
Re: The Bye????
Posted: Mon Feb 01, 2010 3:51 pmAlways hated it -can kill any momentum a team might have and is too disruptive to team performance.
Sure players and fans can have a break, but everyone did just fine for decades in the eras of even team numbers.
Sure players and fans can have a break, but everyone did just fine for decades in the eras of even team numbers.
Re: The Bye????
Posted: Mon Feb 01, 2010 4:36 pmVoice wrote:CUTTERMAN wrote:I've voted for it, I think it gives supporters and players time during the season to catch up with family and friends and a bit of time for injuries to heal.
I'm with you C-MAN!
What, so you can take the Princess Voice down to Sellicks on a windy Sunday arvo?
Re: The Bye????
Posted: Mon Feb 01, 2010 6:11 pmHate it and IMHO it can shape an entire season of some clubs and even worse when a state game break or split round is thrown into the mix.
Footy every week like the good old days, allows the season to gain more momentum.
Footy every week like the good old days, allows the season to gain more momentum.