RD 22 West v North Match Review

[magpie in the 80's]

West 5.6.36
North 5.11.41

West
Goal Kickers: Bennett 2, Rowe, Lobbe, Caruso ea 1
Best Players: Bailey, Thompson, fisher, Ferguson, bricknell, Davies

North
Goal Kickers: Tapscott 2, Delvins, Thring, O'Brien ea 1.
Best Players: Stribling, Younie, Allan, Sloane, Davis, Ryswyk


QxQ
West...1.3...2.5...4.6...5.6.36
North...2.3...4.6...5.7...5.11.41


Reserves
West 6.8.44
North 7.13.55

U/18's
West 14.13.97
North 3.7.25

Crowd
1392

[Dirko]

No finals for Westies....

[Pseudo]

No finals for Westies....

so now it's final?

[geppscrossrams]

Congrats to norfffff but when you've got 21 on the field in white it's pretty hard to win

[Thiele]

Congrats to norfffff but when you've got 21 on the field in white it's pretty hard to win

agree

[Leaping Lindner]

Winners are grinners - losers can please themselves.

[am Bays]

Congrats to norfffff but when you've got 21 on the field in white it's pretty hard to win

agree

You're kiddinga ren't you??? Watching it on the box, not saying they were perfect but gee the decisions went both ways.

[Mic]

Congrats to norfffff but when you've got 21 on the field in white it's pretty hard to win

Hard to win when your team doesn't play well.

[Cambridge Clarrie]

Didn't see the game today but regardless of the fact Westies lost their supporters must be very happy with the year as a whole...

Will certainly be pushing for a finals spot again next year. Hats off to Collins for the job he's done.

[geppscrossrams]

The kfc mob did get some extremely soft free kicks at crucial periods throughout the game. For example just before 3/4 time which basically was the difference in the final result

[bloods08]

Congrats to norfffff but when you've got 21 on the field in white it's pretty hard to win

Hard to win when your team doesn't play well.

Well how did u win. Oh hang on, u had 3 extra guys to help you.

[bloods08]

Goalkickers West: Bennett 2, Caruso, Rowe, Lobbe. North: Younie 2, Delvins, Thring, Obrien. Best players (from the club): Bailey, Thompson, Ferguson.

[Thiele]

Good effort by the boys today.

Wonder if Andy will get fine after what happen at 3/4.time.

Sorry if the bad singing got on the effects in the after second half when West kicked a goal

[whatever]

I did not notice that the umpiring was one sided. shocking at times yes.

That reversal just before 3/4 time was a joke.

Mind you so was the free kick missed early in the last quarter to North, so that evened that one up.

I would like to hear the umpires reasoning why he allow two North players to shepherd block, knock over Bennett 40m away from the ball right in front of him and not pay the free kick.

[Wedgie]

Whilst bad umpiring decisions went both ways today, considering the small winning margin I honestly think West can count themselves extremely unlucky.

Hopefully North win next week to mean the umpiring made no difference in the grand scheme of things but should the weird happen....

Eveyrone was a winner today with the BBQ at Richmond.
Marks lost however for no bundy and cola cans at the bar.

[The Sleeping Giant]

Westies was robbed.

Although North did miss some easy shots at goal, and made a mess of a few other opportunities.

Anyone know if Alleway was definitely reported? If so, would be one of the softest reports I have seen.

[bayman]

Westies was robbed.

Although North did miss some easy shots at goal, and made a mess of a few other opportunities.

Anyone know if Alleway was definitely reported? If so, would be one of the softest reports I have seen.

alleway was definately reported for striking & this was the 'incident' in the goalsquare......i think a reprimand will be the verdict


westies main problem over the concluding stages was it flooded so only one team could score, the umpiring had no bearing on the result

[mal]

Saw the first 3qtrs , then
Was listening to the game on the radio
The last 5-10 minutes
The 5rph commentators were calling for WA to stop flooding and to get players forward of the ball
They called WA having every player in the NA forward line for what sounded like most of that last 5-10 minutes
I asked a person who works at Richmond
I asked him about the WA tactics when they needed to score
He said supporters were calling for players to go forward


WA have improved in 2009
Supporters can be satisfied with that improvement
But another similar season next year would be deemed unacceptable
To much talent to be playing too defensive too often or often enough
need to be a bit more offensive, play man to man, and stop the overflooding


Please Note
My comments are only based on the games I have seen WA play this year

[Strawb]

I didn't listen to the game and I couldn't watch it. I am happy with the improvement and it is a great stepping stone for next season. Looking at the scoreboard we did well and could have won it. Looks like a wet and scrappy game.

[Thiele]

WA have improved in 2009
Supporters can be satisfied with that improvement
But another similar season next year would be deemed unacceptable
To much talent to be playing too defensive too often or often enough
need to be a bit more offensive, play man to man, and stop the overflooding

Totally agree