Who will get sacked first?

[blues2002]

So, who's getting sacked - a power recruiter? Confused why this is sanfl thread?

[Squawk]

GWW - do you know if Stewart's (or the club's) draft philosophy was
a) to pick the best available player when it's your turn, or
b) to pick the best available player required for a role that is needed now or in the future?

Also, I don't know that James Fantasia has done much better at the Crows (or probably the Bulldogs since).

Has anyone ever actually done a study of all the drafts to see who has really shone and who has really just got it all wrong?

[GWW]

Good question Squawk, I'm not sure of the answer to that one.

[Squawk]

Good question Squawk, I'm not sure of the answer to that one.

Which one?

The draft philosophy question, or the empirical study question? I'm not aware of the empirical study having ever been done; but I think the other question has genuine relevance to the discussion about performance evaluation.

[on the rails]

Back on topic please.

Someone sensible has invaded his brain!

[The Sleeping Giant]

So, who's getting sacked - a power recruiter? Confused why this is sanfl thread?

One club.

[gossipgirl]

never rule out the bays .... we have a history of sacking coaches early

[MagareyLegend]

Laird 100/1
Francou 50/1
Fuller 50/1
Bamford 5/1
Collins 8/1
Maloney 25/1
Bassett 100/1
Massie 10/1
Godden 100/1

[Booney]

Laird 100/1
Francou 50/1
Fuller 50/1
Bamford 5/1
Collins 8/1
Maloney 25/1
Bassett 100/1
Massie 10/1
Godden 100/1

You're giving 5's on Bamford and 8's on Collins?

I'll have some of both, thanks...

[MagareyLegend]

It was meant to reflect the relative chances of all to be the first sacked.
In reality both Bamford and Collins are probably Black Caviar odds or less

[Grahaml]

It was meant to reflect the relative chances of all to be the first sacked.
In reality both Bamford and Collins are probably Black Caviar odds or less

Your odds equate to 53.5% of occurences by my reckoning.

[Jim05]

What odds on Bassett replacing Primus?

[dedja]

I doubt it would make any difference even if they enlisted Jesus Christ.

[The Sleeping Giant]

What odds on Bassett replacing Primus?

A gazillion to 1.

[Dutchy]

What odds on Bassett replacing Primus?

A gazillion to 1.

Centurion?

[RustyCage]

What odds on Bassett replacing Primus?

If Primus was replaced at the end of the year I'd say Bassett is a big chance

[Slots It Through]

What odds on Bassett replacing Primus?

If Primus was replaced at the end of the year I'd say Bassett is a big chance

I think that would be a gamble, bringing in a new coach, who hasnt coached in the AFL.

[am Bays]

Laird 100/1
Francou 50/1
Fuller 50/1
Bamford 5/1
Collins 8/1
Maloney 25/1
Bassett 100/1
Massie 10/1
Godden 100/1

Given that our current board has sacked one coach whilst North has sacked two, I reckon Francou should be more worried than Mass, especially when you consider how our board gave Mickan the opportunity to "change the plan, not the man" at the end of 2010.

[The Sleeping Giant]

Correction. North have only sacked Healy. Jars was not sacked.

[robranisgod]

Laird 100/1
Francou 50/1
Fuller 50/1
Bamford 5/1
Collins 8/1
Maloney 25/1
Bassett 100/1
Massie 10/1
Godden 100/1

Given that our current board has sacked one coach whilst North has sacked two, I reckon Francou should be more worried than Mass, especially when you consider how our board gave Mickan the opportunity to "change the plan, not the man" at the end of 2010.

There have been major changes to the North Board since Healy was sacked, so it could be argued that the current North board have sacked no coaches, certainly over the past 15 years, Glenelg have sacked a lot more coaches than any other club.