Tribunal discussion/views/debate

[redandblack]

Only half?

We've improved

[Adelaide Hawk]

So who are the thugs in the SANFL? Eagleton of course, Allers, Pumpa, Parry, Grocke, Cicca, Chris Gowans (the evil twin), Clayton, Grima and half of the West team.

Eagleton? He gets beaten up every week. Not great form for a thug. Only got sent off because the umpires have no idea.

[CENTURION]

not a smart thug either, starts fights & gets beaten up! (take it easy, only joking) I would say that James Gowans has a shorter fuse than Chris.

[Hazydog]

not a smart thug either, starts fights & gets beaten up! (take it easy, only joking) I would say that James Gowans has a shorter fuse than Chris.

I can assure you Chris didn't endear himself to the Rooster faithful sitting near the scoreboard early on in the game last Saturday

[dedja]

not a smart thug either, starts fights & gets beaten up! (take it easy, only joking) I would say that James Gowans has a shorter fuse than Chris.

to the unedumacated and untrained eye, how do you tell the difference?

[CENTURION]

ask their girlfriends.

[spell_check]

you draw the line at deliberate, dangerous & totally unnecessary contact. simple really. once again, once you have a player in a tackle, where he can't either dispose of the ball or break free, there is nothing further required to get an umpire's adjudication. It will either be a bounce, play on, or holding the ball. By slinging the player, you have now placed yourself in a position where the ball can break free anyway BUT will possibly injure the opponent &/or place the slinger on report.

The problem there is the umpire takes too long to call for a bounce. At the first sign of the ball being trapped, call for a ball up - do it quickly so you don't get 15 or so players around it and move on.

[StrayDog]

Might be a first offence with Central but he has been opn another SANFL list with Glenelg and your record carries over from the past 7 years.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/AFL_Tribun ... deductions

Reckon the "good record" deduction may apply after five years, unless there's a local variation

Yes, there is a local variation, with 7 years being the carry over period:

http://www.sanfl.com.au/league/reports/ ... e_reports/ (at the bottom of the list)

Ah, righto, thanks for that.

Interesting.

[Big Phil]

Might be a first offence with Central but he has been opn another SANFL list with Glenelg and your record carries over from the past 7 years.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/AFL_Tribun ... deductions

Reckon the "good record" deduction may apply after five years, unless there's a local variation

Yes, there is a local variation, with 7 years being the carry over period:

http://www.sanfl.com.au/league/reports/ ... e_reports/ (at the bottom of the list)

Ah, righto, thanks for that.

Interesting.

No worries...

Whilst the SANFL have adopted the points system, similar to that of the AFL, for this season, it is not exactly replicated and this is an example of that.

[Brucetiki]

Pumpa's 1st offence, Alltheway's ? offence?

Pumpa's 3rd offence, Alleway's 2nd offence

thugs, the pair of them

So who are the thugs in the SANFL? Eagleton of course, Allers, Pumpa, Parry, Grocke, Cicca, Chris Gowans (the evil twin), Clayton, Grima and half of the West team.

Have Westies been taking lessons from the New York Islanders!

[Dogwatcher]

Given what J & C have gotten away with over the years, I'll wear these suspensions.

[The Sleeping Giant]

Have Westies been taking lessons from the New York Islanders!

More like the Charlestown Chiefs.

Too bad the Gowans weren't triplets, or there wasn't another brother. Could have been something like this.

[CENTURION]

Have Westies been taking lessons from the New York Islanders!

More like the Charlestown Chiefs.

Too bad the Gowans weren't triplets, or there wasn't another brother. Could have been something like this.

Scary shit is, they DO have a 3rd brother! They keep him in the attic & feed him fishheads.

[The Sleeping Giant]

I'd heard rumours of a Rupert Gowans.

[CENTURION]

Jim Bob.

[Bunton]

I hear Craig Parry may be cited on further charges

[Big Phil]

From Localfootysa...

http://www.adelaidenow.com.au/sport/afl ... 6116848457

[wedgetail]

I hear Craig Parry may be cited on further charges

You need to see a chiropractor bunton to relign your spine because of the huge chip on your shoulder.
Move on with the angst about Parry!

[fish]

Stuart Bown (Norwood) and David Piasente (West) are both facing the SANFL Tribunal tonight on charges of striking...

[JK]

Stuart Bown (Norwood) and David Piasente (West) are both facing the SANFL Tribunal tonight on charges of striking...

Bowny got a game