Tony Dey

[Brodlach]

He did better than the arse clown that cost North a goal by not seeing our player bounce the ball!

That was a shocker of a descision, could have given the Eagles real mommentum going into the last quarter

[Groucho]

BUT YOU STILL WON!

Not the same as having Tony Dey.

[scoob]

BUT YOU STILL WON!

Not the same as having Tony Dey.

But your not blaming him for the loss

[Thunderstruck]

Umpiring was awful for both sides but Central clearly got the wrong end of the stick yesterday, which was also noted by a couple of westies fans sitting right next to me.

[Sky Pilot]

Look up the word cheat in the dictionary and you will find a picture of Tony Dey.
Why does he hate us? As soon as I saw in the Budget on Friday that he was umpiring I KNEW we were going to lose. He really screwed us today.

Centalink were outplayed by West thats why they lost.

Stop blaming the Umps and STOP behaving like a sore loser!!!!!

Hilarious!

[leftlegger]

As a neutral supporter.
I thought Centrals got the better of the umpiring.

And while we're at it. It amazes me how the Gowans twins are in the umpire's ears all day & giving out dirty little cheap shots hear & there, & getting away with it.
I've seen players from other clubs copping 25m penalties merely for muttering abuse at umpires while standing a mark.
Its unbelievable that they get away with monstering the umpires, their over the top whinging & swearing & continuing on with after the siren for the breaks.

Cant blame the Gowans boys though. They do what they do.
Its the Umpires fault. They should be on to them right from the start of the match to shut their shit down.

Yeah anyway thats how I see it.
you might think its bollocks

[scoob]

Umpiring was awful for both sides but Central clearly got the wrong end of the stick yesterday, which was also noted by a couple of westies fans sitting right next to me.

I sat with 3 Centrals guys who thought Westies got the wrong end of the stick.

[Doddy]

Completely agree that the umpiring did not cost Centrals the game nor gift it to Westies.

But it's hard to watch forum members suggest that Centrals got the better of the umpiring when it was a 26/16 count. And the Dogs got 4 in the last where they already had possession (eg. mark already taken, free kick signalled for interference etc.), and these tend to look like evener-uppers. There should be no talk of "playing in front" as the cause either, as with a similar number of scoring shots and inside 50's etc, you can't do that by being behind all day. Same last week, same suggestion made, similar stats and 23/9 against Centrals.

Anyway, we always say the umpiring is good when we don't notice it. Not the case yesterday I'd venture. For example "fighting continues" is not a reason for another and another and another 25m penalty - why on earth would that encourage half of those fighting to stop?

But I can't believe Tony Dey is a crook. Just not very good at his job perhaps.

[Blacky]

Must say I did like the 150 metre penalty

[RB]

Must say I did like the 150 metre penalty

Yeah what was with that? I've never seen so many 25s in a row.

[Big Phil]

Must say I did like the 150 metre penalty

Yeah what was with that? I've never seen so many 25s in a row.

I think it was a 25m penalty to begin with, then because the fight was still going, a further 2 x 50m penalties. So 125m all up...

[mighty_tiger_79]

that was a disgraceful decision the 150m free kick

[Dogwatcher]

that was a disgraceful decision the 150m free kick

I was astounded by that decision. Two teams fighting - notwithstanding the cause - and one team gets penalised. That was the worst decision of the day for mine.

[mighty_tiger_79]

that was a disgraceful decision the 150m free kick

I was astounded by that decision. Two teams fighting - notwithstanding the cause - and one team gets penalised. That was the worst decision of the day for mine.[/quote]


id say its one of the worst decisions ive seen all year, including the Rodan dive (perhaps Rodan wished he was in the Olympic team).

and i had no interest in the match at all, no financial bias just a neutral observer

[NO-MERCY]

Umpiring was awful for both sides but Central clearly got the wrong end of the stick yesterday, which was also noted by a couple of westies fans sitting right next to me.

I sat with 3 Centrals guys who thought Westies got the wrong end of the stick.

Yeah i thought the same.

[sjt]

that was a disgraceful decision the 150m free kick

The one in either the first or third quarter can't remember was pretty bad. West kicking to the Southern end got a free between half back and back pocket. Got a 25 metre I think because the ball wasn't given back on the full, and the man on the mark was taken back 50 metres. I thought the umpire was trying to be an AFL wannabe or just confused.
Also they should throw the ball up! There was about 7 recalls and there should have been more.

[Blacky]

that was a disgraceful decision the 150m free kick

watch the game on iview and you will see what happens
the way the gowans boy are mouthing off i dont blame the ump
by that stage of the game they had lost the plot
they do know how to spit the DUMMY

[jim5112]

Look up the word cheat in the dictionary and you will find a picture of Tony Dey.
Why does he hate us? As soon as I saw in the Budget on Friday that he was umpiring I KNEW we were going to lose. He really screwed us today.

Centalink were outplayed by West thats why they lost.

Stop blaming the Umps and STOP behaving like a sore loser!!!!!

Perhaps you should stop behaving like an IGNORANT PIG!

[cennals05]

that was a disgraceful decision the 150m free kick

watch the game on iview and you will see what happens
the way the gowans boy are mouthing off i dont blame the ump
by that stage of the game they had lost the plot
they do know how to spit the DUMMY

That was right after the West player stomped on a Centrals players head. The Central players were going crazy at the umpire and I don't blame them. At least Obst was facing Tippett when he hit him unlike your gutless player, stomping on someone's head.

[Jimmy]

Look up the word cheat in the dictionary and you will find a picture of Tony Dey.
Why does he hate us? As soon as I saw in the Budget on Friday that he was umpiring I KNEW we were going to lose. He really screwed us today.

Wtf Westies had a good Dey play in front you get the frees isn't that what you have been saying for a while guess what we won

I'm no grammar nazi, but ffs, at least put a comma in there