James Allan

[DOC]

Has he got enough votes to win four?

[Ian]

Doubt it yet

[holden78]

Has he got enough votes to win four?

If he wins again they should give him the medal and that should be the last one. From next year it then must be called something else, maybe a medal voted on by players and coaches only. Enough already

[Sheik Yerbouti]

Maybe have it like the under 6's where everybody gets one?

[robranisgod]

Has he got enough votes to win four?

If he wins again they should give him the medal and that should be the last one. From next year it then must be called something else, maybe a medal voted on by players and coaches only. Enough already

There is already the R O Shearman medal as voted by the members of the 200 club (i.e. ex players who have played 200 games) and guess what, James Allan has won the last five. You can query umpires as much as you like but I think the majority of supporters respect the opinion of players who have played 200 league games. They generally know what they are talking about.

[Wedgie]

Has he got enough votes to win four?

If he wins again they should give him the medal and that should be the last one. From next year it then must be called something else, maybe a medal voted on by players and coaches only. Enough already

There is already the R O Shearman medal as voted by the members of the 200 club (i.e. ex players who have played 200 games) and guess what, James Allan has won the last five. You can query umpires as much as you like but I think the majority of supporters respect the opinion of players who have played 200 league games. They generally know what they are talking about.

They did stuff up by giving one to Archard, Allan should have won that year too, if he hasn't broken his arm he would have won a Liston too.

[Big Phil]

North think Jimmy is a 50/50 chance of staying in SA for 2013...

From Localfootysa:

http://www.adelaidenow.com.au/sport/afl ... 6441652680

[Ian]

North think Jimmy is a 50/50 chance of staying in SA for 2013...

From Localfootysa:

http://www.adelaidenow.com.au/sport/afl ... 6441652680

So does his cleaner

[o five]

I have a feeling that if North show some improvement and play finals this year, he will stay for another season.