Glenelg v West Adelaide Post Match Review

[Brodlach]

yep, whenever one of The Twins goes off the rails, He is dragged immediately, or He takes Himself off! Responsibility & accountability comes from the players themselves firstly, then the coach.

And thats what happened to MacCredie against North

[The Sleeping Giant]

Looking at todays paper, coach didnt think they did put thm in that situation

Collins must be feeling the pressure. When a coach starts to get under the pump, they start looking outside for something to blame.

His argument that West had the flow of play so they weren't the undisciplined side is hilarious. A couple of weeks ago against North they had "the flow" all day, yet still had 3 players suspended for undisciplined acts.

[mighty_tiger_79]

gotta remember collins played VFL for a team of thugs

[Blacky]

Clutching at straws if you think umpires make the difference in any game let alone a 8 goal hiding.

Start looking within West and you might have some success.

well one thing for sure is we wont sack our coach
one thing umps can do is change the flow of a game

[dedja]

Really, unless I'm mistaken you sacked a premiership coach in D.N. Kerley at the end of 1962 (losing the GF), after he took you to a flag in 1961 ... or am I dreaming?

[Blacky]

Really, unless I'm mistaken you sacked a premiership coach in D.N. Kerley at the end of 1962 (losing the GF), after he took you to a flag in 1961 ... or am I dreaming?

sacked him twice actually
get your facts right please
bays won 4 flags
2 of those coaches came from westies

[dedja]

LOL, so you won't sack your coach ... but only sometimes

[Tiger Couple]

West would have to be the most undisciplined side in the comp.

Ben Kane hit late gets 25m penalty
Push and shove with players coming from all directions umpire comes in another 25m penalty - I was to far away to know what this was for. Glenelg Goal from Goal line.
Players still pushing and shoving and Glenelg playerget throwen out of the pack - Clearly a free no matter who you support.Glenelg goal from Goal Line.
Ball finally makes it back to the middle and West ruckman gives away a free as he is still giving the umpire feedback.

I'm not sure too many could argue the umpires did anything wrong during this passage of mayhem.

Start of the 3rd qtr Todd Grima pushing and bumping with West player and West player grabs Todd Grima around the neck. What choice did the West player leave the Umpire with?

Cranston gets a free on wing Webb goes over the mark. 25m Penatly (maybe ticky touch) Webb stops Cranston and pushes him 50m Penatly for holding play up.

Will say the umpires over umpired the first qtr of the game paying way too many soft frees both ways that appeared to have the game being stopped every 30 seconds. I think Fila must get paid by the metres he gives away in a game though because I think he would give the most away out of all umpires.

[Tiger Couple]

Great to see a number of Tigers players step up this week and return to form. One win doesn't make up for everything, but hopefully we have started to play for each other and give a commited hard at it effort.

Sammy Rudolph best game since coming back from overseas, Todd Grima was outstanding up forward (the month in defence seems to have given him confidence) Ben Mules back to his best just to name a few. With the youngsters in Agnew, Curran and Trembath having a good day out hopefully we have turned the corner.

I just hope we continue to go long and strong and not go back to chipping it around crap that we have gone with most weeks. We have proved in our wins that we are hard to stop when we attack.