Page 16 of 75
Re: Rumours and Player Movement Discussions for 2014
Posted:
Sat Nov 02, 2013 7:21 pmby dogs01
Mr Fuller wrote:Big Phil wrote:Sam Gray going to be Rookied by Port Power, meaning the Eagles are likely to miss out on a good recruit...
And this is the problem with the eagles. There have been quite a few occasions over the years where we have targeted a recruit, got close to sign him, only to see him snapped up by the AFL in the draft leaving us with........nothing.
We should not have been targeting Gray. Yes he is a great player but it was more than likely he was AFL bound. Meanwhile, other really good Port players who are good at SANFL but probably not good enough for AFL (e.g. Kirkwood) have been targeted by other clubs and will be signed. So we miss out yet again. Who is your Plan B eagles? No excuses.
From what I've heard kirkwood was very close to signing with eagles but it looks like sturt have pipped eagles right on the line.
Re: Rumours and Player Movement Discussions for 2014
Posted:
Sat Nov 02, 2013 8:48 pmby Blackwhite
If the rumours are indeed true regarding Beard and Kirkwood to Sturt, when will an announcement be made?
Re: Rumours and Player Movement Discussions for 2014
Posted:
Sat Nov 02, 2013 9:59 pmby ferret
Eagles still scratching their head about how Sturt outbid them for Beard and Kirkwood, thought they were signed, sealed and delivered.
Panic will see them desperately try to sign Boyd.
Re: Rumours and Player Movement Discussions for 2014
Posted:
Sat Nov 02, 2013 10:15 pmby dedja
Will they be paying them with Monopoly money?
Re: Rumours and Player Movement Discussions for 2014
Posted:
Sun Nov 03, 2013 9:44 amby Mr Fuller
ferret wrote:Eagles still scratching their head about how Sturt outbid them for Beard and Kirkwood, thought they were signed, sealed and delivered.
Panic will see them desperately try to sign Boyd.
Well maybe if they'd made those guys their number 1 targets from the beginning instead of going after Gray then they might have got them.
Re: Rumours and Player Movement Discussions for 2014
Posted:
Sun Nov 03, 2013 11:40 amby SANFLnut
They signed at Sturt for less than Eagles offered financially. Were more impressed by Sturts overall package including their vision for the next couple of years. James Watt on board with them too. Beard and Kirkwood considered to be leaders of the young pack at Magpies, wonder if some others might follow of their accord once the Blues are endorsed by these guys. IMHO these two represent the most valuable Maggies to pinch. West have been very quiet so far but need to recruit big time to replace our losses, much less go forward.
Re: Rumours and Player Movement Discussions for 2014
Posted:
Sun Nov 03, 2013 11:59 amby ferret
What was the vision.......a permanent fence around Unley oval and fulltime poo pickeruper!!!!!!!!
Eagles appear to be better placed financially, with a great crop of juniors and a proven coach.
Re: Rumours and Player Movement Discussions for 2014
Posted:
Sun Nov 03, 2013 12:34 pmby beenreal
Groucho wrote:Big Phil wrote:Sam Gray going to be Rookied by Port Power, meaning the Eagles are likely to miss out on a good recruit...
They have to actually draft him! I don't trust them. They promise to draft Gray so he doesn't sign with Eagles or any other SANFL team and then the Power don't draft him and he has to play for the Power Magpies Reserves. Surprise!
This is Port were talking about, they have lots of runs on the trust scoreboard don't they.
Didn't your club model itself on (copy) Port Adelaide just to learn how to achieve some (ultimately short-term) success?
I'll take 36 Premierships over cliche's about "trust" any day.
Re: Rumours and Player Movement Discussions for 2014
Posted:
Sun Nov 03, 2013 1:21 pmby Groucho
I thought it was only 34 as the last 2 premierships were won by the Port Adelaide
Magpies Football Club.
Re: Rumours and Player Movement Discussions for 2014
Posted:
Sun Nov 03, 2013 4:34 pmby Mark_Beswick
Now they are a new PAFC with 0 Premierships
Re: Rumours and Player Movement Discussions for 2014
Posted:
Mon Nov 04, 2013 7:38 amby holden78
ferret wrote:Eagles still scratching their head about how Sturt outbid them for Beard and Kirkwood, thought they were signed, sealed and delivered.
Panic will see them desperately try to sign Boyd.
Panic doesn't always mean your decision is the wrong one, sometimes it's making up for a lack of planning but is the right choice all along!
Boyd is a top player in the SANFL without doubt, and our midfield loses us finals.... the last three!
Re: Rumours and Player Movement Discussions for 2014
Posted:
Mon Nov 04, 2013 7:44 amby Dogwatcher
beenreal wrote: Didn't your club model itself on (copy) Port Adelaide just to learn how to achieve some (ultimately short-term) success?
Is it some sort of shame to model a process from another club, one which has had success?
You're telling the story.
Short-term success? In the short term, 12 seasons of success which we enjoyed was a long period of time, was it not? Whether it is going to provide genuine long-term success over multiple decades, that's yet to be decided. I'd still be happy supporting that at SANFL level, rather than an Academy side.
Re: Rumours and Player Movement Discussions for 2014
Posted:
Mon Nov 04, 2013 9:04 amby ferret
For once I agree with you holden78, they must go after and secure Boyd but it does cause a bit of consternation when your best laid plans are scuttled. Just doing a few more character checks on Boyd. Eagles might also be trying to snaffle another SA player.
Re: Rumours and Player Movement Discussions for 2014
Posted:
Mon Nov 04, 2013 9:11 amby dedja
Post deleted in 10, 9, 8 ...
Re: Rumours and Player Movement Discussions for 2014
Posted:
Mon Nov 04, 2013 9:48 amby Booney
Groucho wrote:I thought it was only 34 as the last 2 premierships were won by the Port Adelaide
Magpies Football Club.
SANFL, Port Adelaide, 36 Cups.
Forever in our shadows, blow-in.
Re: Rumours and Player Movement Discussions for 2014
Posted:
Mon Nov 04, 2013 10:12 amby Ronnie
The next time Keith Thomas uses his already tired phrase of the "Port Adelaide community", i'll think of young men like Beard and Kirkwood. Wonder what the spin means to them.
Re: Rumours and Player Movement Discussions for 2014
Posted:
Mon Nov 04, 2013 10:43 amby SANFLnut
ferret wrote:What was the vision.......a permanent fence around Unley oval and fulltime poo pickeruper!!!!!!!!
Eagles appear to be better placed financially, with a great crop of juniors and a proven coach.
Think it was more to do with the group of young players around a similar age who are taking the club forward and showed improvement through the year. The Port boys have said they have liked the game style and way Sturt have gone about things against them this year. Obviously they don't agree with your assessment of the playing and coaching stocks.
Re: Rumours and Player Movement Discussions for 2014
Posted:
Mon Nov 04, 2013 12:09 pmby beenreal
Ronnie wrote:The next time Keith Thomas uses his already tired phrase of the "Port Adelaide community", i'll think of young men like Beard and Kirkwood. Wonder what the spin means to them.
Bottom line is with OUR AFL players coming home, there's only so many spots on the SANFL list. Some will stay at Alberton and reap the benefits, others will choose to move down to other options.
Re: Rumours and Player Movement Discussions for 2014
Posted:
Mon Nov 04, 2013 12:30 pmby Dogwatcher
I thought they were all staying....
Re: Rumours and Player Movement Discussions for 2014
Posted:
Mon Nov 04, 2013 12:33 pmby topsywaldron
beenreal wrote:Bottom line is with OUR AFL players coming home, there's only so many spots on the SANFL list. Some will stay at Alberton and reap the benefits, others will choose to move down to other options.
They might get to play at a successful club then.