2012 Reports & Tribunal Discussion

[CENTURION]

http://www.adelaidenow.com.au/sport/afl/jericho-to-front-tribunal-over-tweet/story-e6freckc-1226459960914

Why does the link refer to ...../sport/afl/......

If it doesn't involve that competition, shouldn't it be .../sport/AUSTRALIAN RULES FOOTBALL... or .../sport/SANFL...

Phuken hate this game being refered to as afl.

good point!

[Long live SAnFL]

5 weeks for Chris Kane reduced to 4 with early plea. Are we playing netball these days. This is an f'n joke. It was a decent bump. Geeezzzz what is the SANFL up to. Anyone would think they don't want the Eagles to make the finals...

You must be kidding if you think what Kane did to Gallagher was a decent bump? We all love tough, hard and uncompromising play but what most (including the tribunal) saw was a sniper act with only one intent. Any wonder why the Norwood players remonstrated at the time and then did not shake hands with Kane after the game? If you seriously think the SANFL does not want the Eagles to make the finals simply because they suspend your players for gutless acts then the joke is on you.

[CENTURION]

what is happening to me? I agree with a Norwood supporter!

Kane's action was one of stupidity & one he will regret forever.

[holden78]

what is happening to me? I agree with a Norwood supporter!

Kane's action was one of stupidity & one he will regret forever.

Get your hand off it old chap

[CENTURION]

what is happening to me? I agree with a Norwood supporter!

Kane's action was one of stupidity & one he will regret forever.

Get your hand off it old chap

yep, you're right. It was excellent & I hope he does it again?

[hawkseye]

Kane should have got off just because he got Gallagher!!

[Booney]

5 weeks for Chris Kane reduced to 4 with early plea. Are we playing netball these days. This is an f'n joke. It was a decent bump. Geeezzzz what is the SANFL up to. Anyone would think they don't want the Eagles to make the finals...

You argued the Parry incident and now the Kane incident.

It's not Netball, nor is it UFC.

[CENTURION]

you don't dong people when they can't defend themselves. simple.

[CENTURION]

Are We sooking about Boydy? No, He did it, it's all his fault.

[Brodlach]

From the SANFL site on how they came to the 4 matches.

Chris Kane (Eagles) *

Charge: Charging

Conduct – Intentional
Impact – High
Contact – High

Level 5 Charging – 550 Points

- 10% Loading for 1 Match ban in Round 1 2012
- 25% Deduction for Guilty Plea
- 12.5 Carried over from offense in Round 1 2012

Total – 466.25

Verdict: Guilty (4 matches

[fish]

Is there any footage available of the Kane incident?

[Jim05]

Is there any footage available of the Kane incident?

Watch the recovery session. Its around the 19 minute mark

[SDK]

A fair decision and a suitable punishment.
I also agree with another public comment that Kane should go play country football. The Eagles are a well respected club and can well do without an arsehole like that. Can this guy play football anyway ? You don't get too many good players that are rejected by Glenelg !

[on the rails]

A fair decision and a suitable punishment.
I also agree with another public comment that Kane should go play country football. The Eagles are a well respected club and can well do without an arsehole like that. Can this guy play football anyway ? You don't get too many good players that are rejected by Glenelg !

Spoken by a supporter who follows a team who has in the past included such clean players as Wynne, Balme, Pike, Kelly and McIntosh. You can't possibly be serious with hanging this bloke for one bad bump that a lot of players have been done for in the past and no doubt will again in future? He got what he deserved so why single him out as an arsehole? Personally Parry's elbow to Mayes head 2 rounds ago was worse and he also got 4. What little useless advice have you got for him - whoops sorry forgot Mayes plays for North and is not one of your precious little Redlegs so that makes it alright I suppose in Parry's case?

[Pseudo]

You don't get too many good players that are rejected by Glenelg !

Yeah, Glenelg only sacked Jim West because he was a shambles...

[on the rails]

You don't get too many good players that are rejected by Glenelg !

Yeah, Glenelg only sacked Jim West because he was a shambles...

W. Phillis anyone?

[Aerie]

We had 3 ex-Glenelg win premierships last year! Kane has done pretty well this year IMO.

[eaglehaslanded]

5 weeks for Chris Kane reduced to 4 with early plea. Are we playing netball these days. This is an f'n joke. It was a decent bump. Geeezzzz what is the SANFL up to. Anyone would think they don't want the Eagles to make the finals...

You argued the Parry incident and now the Kane incident.

It's not Netball, nor is it UFC.

Point me to a post where I argued the Parry incident. On the contrary I had noted that he was lucky to only get 4.

[holden78]

G. McIntosh, but how they forget

[JK]

G. McIntosh, but how they forget

Not even the most one-eyed Norwood supporter would argue with most of the suspensions he received, so what's your point?