2012 Reports & Tribunal Discussion

[Brodlach]

Surprisingly Craig Parrys appeal has been dismissed and he will miss the next four games.

[Long live SAnFL]

Just made the Eagles task of trying to qualify for the finals a whole lot harder.

[holden78]

You lot are that soft, it's predictable! What was the injury ah that's right nothing. It's 2 weeks for a reckless action nothing more.
It's not the GAYFL even though Glenelg is in the comp

Good luck not judgement that he didn't break his jaw or cheekbone. So your happy with elbows to the head to only get 2 weeks hey?

The player is behind him so he hasn't lined him up for who he is. At his height he has rounded his arm, not raised it, and made contact high because the other player is smaller then him. Reckless action for certain but to be outed for 20% of the season is a disgrace at a semi pro level. SANFL has finally caught up to the weak over governed madness that is Gayfl! Proof is the Selwood brothers report incident, what a complete waste of time and just shows footy is only now a man's game some of the time; madness brought on by bureaucrats who are too smart to go into politics

[holden78]

You lot are that soft, it's predictable! What was the injury ah that's right nothing. It's 2 weeks for a reckless action nothing more.
It's not the GAYFL even though Glenelg is in the comp

Good luck not judgement that he didn't break his jaw or cheekbone. So your happy with elbows to the head to only get 2 weeks hey?

The player is behind him so he hasn't lined him up for who he is. At his height he has rounded his arm, not raised it, and made contact high because the other player is smaller then him. Reckless action for certain but to be outed for 20% of the season is a disgrace at a semi pro level. SANFL has finally caught up to the weak over governed madness that is Gayfl! Proof is the Selwood brothers report incident, what a complete waste of time and just shows footy is only now a man's game some of the time; madness brought on by bureaucrats who are too smart to go into politics

[CENTURION]

If he didn't have such a bad record, he wouldn't have got 20% of the season! He would have got what it deserved, probably 2 games. Maybe he has to get it through his thick head that he can't go around every weekend donging people.

[Dogwatcher]

What happened to the bloke who collided with Goodrem and was reported?

[Booney]

You lot are that soft, it's predictable! What was the injury ah that's right nothing. It's 2 weeks for a reckless action nothing more.
It's not the GAYFL even though Glenelg is in the comp

Good luck not judgement that he didn't break his jaw or cheekbone. So your happy with elbows to the head to only get 2 weeks hey?

The player is behind him so he hasn't lined him up for who he is. At his height he has rounded his arm, not raised it, and made contact high because the other player is smaller then him. Reckless action for certain but to be outed for 20% of the season is a disgrace at a semi pro level. SANFL has finally caught up to the weak over governed madness that is Gayfl! Proof is the Selwood brothers report incident, what a complete waste of time and just shows footy is only now a man's game some of the time; madness brought on by bureaucrats who are too smart to go into politics

Something in that for all of us.

[Brodlach]

What happened to the bloke who collided with Goodrem and was reported?

Wasnt reported, just a footy collision

[FlyingHigh]

Just made the Eagles task of trying to qualify for the finals a whole lot harder.

Yep, virtually gone from an emerging finals hope to just being happy to avoid the wooden spoon in a split second, Redden you'd think would have an extended run at the Power and using Greiger weakens a strong spot.
Also, if we do make it through, Parry would have only had one hit-out in 8 weeks.

[CENTURION]

Just made the Eagles task of trying to qualify for the finals a whole lot harder.

Yep, virtually gone from an emerging finals hope to just being happy to avoid the wooden spoon in a split second, Redden you'd think would have an extended run at the Power and using Greiger weakens a strong spot.
Also, if we do make it through, "Parry would have only had one hit-out in 8 weeks."
poor choice of words

[dedja]

What a Claudia ...

Shiffer for brains.

[FlyingHigh]

Just made the Eagles task of trying to qualify for the finals a whole lot harder.

Yep, virtually gone from an emerging finals hope to just being happy to avoid the wooden spoon in a split second, Redden you'd think would have an extended run at the Power and using Greiger weakens a strong spot.
Also, if we do make it through, "Parry would have only had one hit-out in 8 weeks."
poor choice of words

[Locky]

Does anyone know how the final 4 week ban was decided. He was offered 4 for an early plea, contested it, and still got 4?

Deserved 2-3 I think, but with a poor record, 4 about right.

[SDK]

He got the original 4 weeks plus death of first born.... by crucifiction.

[matt1]

He gave a 'guilty plea' to the charge of striking but contested the intentional aspect to try and get downgraded to reckless which would have apparently meant a reduction to 3 games instead of 4.

[holden78]

If Parry wasn't facing the player and was moving away, then his action could not have been intentional but reactionary! How this is not worth a downgraded result is a disgrace and if the Eagles had Collingwood's money and clout to push/threaten court action, well he would be looking at 2 games I'm certain. This stinks to high heaven as where is the injury to make it so bad, the player wasn't knocked out or anything else. Pathetic

[CENTURION]

If Parry wasn't facing the player and was moving away, then his action could not have been intentional but reactionary! How this is not worth a downgraded result is a disgrace and if the Eagles had Collingwood's money and clout to push/threaten court action, well he would be looking at 2 games I'm certain. This stinks to high heaven as where is the injury to make it so bad, the player wasn't knocked out or anything else. Pathetic

yet you are the only person who thinks he is innocent? Are you doing him?

[Brodlach]

If Parry wasn't facing the player and was moving away, then his action could not have been intentional but reactionary! How this is not worth a downgraded result is a disgrace and if the Eagles had Collingwood's money and clout to push/threaten court action, well he would be looking at 2 games I'm certain. This stinks to high heaven as where is the injury to make it so bad, the player wasn't knocked out or anything else. Pathetic

yet you are the only person who thinks he is innocent? Are you doing him?

More time to do him now if he is

[RustyCage]

If Parry wasn't facing the player and was moving away, then his action could not have been intentional but reactionary! How this is not worth a downgraded result is a disgrace and if the Eagles had Collingwood's money and clout to push/threaten court action, well he would be looking at 2 games I'm certain. This stinks to high heaven as where is the injury to make it so bad, the player wasn't knocked out or anything else. Pathetic

If Clayton was looking at one week for abusing the umpire, then Parry definitely deserved more than two such a dirty act

[RustyCage]

If Parry wasn't facing the player and was moving away

he was looking at him as contact was made. He knew what he was doing