Round 6 - West Adel v Panthers @ Richmond - 2.10pm Sat 7/5/1

[bloods08]

Magarey Medal favourite Chris Schmidt is a huge loss

But I thought Eagleton had already won it.

[CENTURION]

Magarey Medal favourite Chris Schmidt is a huge loss

But I thought Eagleton had already won it.

He has handed it over to Paul Thomas.

[The Sleeping Giant]

Jumped off Boyd centurion?

[CENTURION]

Jumped off Boyd centurion?

have you seen His shoulder?

[Mark_Beswick]

I'll jump on the Thomas bandwagon then

[Big Phil]

I'll jump on the Thomas bandwagon then

Just to continue the slightly off topic discussion - IF he keeps his form up shown so far and remains injury free, Eagles Skipper Mark Mackenzie has to a be HUGE change for the MM?

Anyway, back on topic, good luck to Brad Eagle for West if he makes his debut, have heard this kid can play.

[JK]

Magarey Medal favourite Chris Schmidt is a huge loss

But I thought Eagleton had already won it.

What, and deny James Allan his rightful place alongside Barrie Robran .. The Rooster fans would be mortified if that didn't happen

[The Sleeping Giant]

Magarey Medal favourite Chris Schmidt is a huge loss

But I thought Eagleton had already won it.

What, and deny James Allan his rightful place alongside Barrie Robran .. The Rooster fans would be mortified if that didn't happen

Not really CP. You should just stick to agreeing with people, it suits you.

[saintal]

Irra out, forced to play for Sacred Heart. Good to see the egos of such colleges are still healthy

[JK]

Magarey Medal favourite Chris Schmidt is a huge loss

But I thought Eagleton had already won it.

What, and deny James Allan his rightful place alongside Barrie Robran .. The Rooster fans would be mortified if that didn't happen

Not really CP. You should just stick to agreeing with people, it suits you.

Bit early is it mate? That's fairly tame by your lofty standards

[The Sleeping Giant]

No one declared James Allan winner after 2 rounds. Nicotine demons starting to attack CP. Better?

[JK]

No one declared James Allan winner after 2 rounds. Nicotine demons starting to attack CP. Better?

They didn't really need to with all the man love for him, lol and no not at all (just had one), Im sure you can do better if you put your mind to it big fella

[Wedgie]

Remain on topic please gents.

I think the Bloods will strike back angrily and demolish the Panthers.

[JK]

Remain on topic please gents.

I think the Bloods will strike back angrily and demolish the Panthers.

Apologies mate, just a little friendly banter to start the day .. I think the Bloods will win, but I wouldn't be shocked if South got up .. I'll go Westies by 23 points.

[The Sleeping Giant]

I'd be shocked if South won. If West are genuine contenders, 36+

[whufc]

I'd be shocked if South won. If West are genuine contenders, 36+

WOW

I actually agree with TSG, if West are serious about this year they will win this one and win well.

[heater31]

Irra out, forced to play for Sacred Heart. Good to see the egos of such colleges are still healthy

Once again I fail to see what gains are made here

SHC are potentially hindering development, the player is missing out on improving and showcasing his skills and the club miss out on a league standard player.

[on the rails]

Irra out, forced to play for Sacred Heart. Good to see the egos of such colleges are still healthy

Once again I fail to see what gains are made here

SHC are potentially hindering development, the player is missing out on improving and showcasing his skills and the club miss out on a league standard player.

Do you apply that same logic to the U16's and U18's comps - they promote development!

North have been dominate in both grades but are wobbling badly because of the ridiculous rule of having to have their best play college football ahead of SANFL football!

[wycbloods]

Irra out, forced to play for Sacred Heart. Good to see the egos of such colleges are still healthy

Once again I fail to see what gains are made here

SHC are potentially hindering development, the player is missing out on improving and showcasing his skills and the club miss out on a league standard player.

I don't agree with it but all kids and their families are made well aware of this when they go to these schools so if they don't like it go to a public school.

[Mark Dreher]

Irra out, forced to play for Sacred Heart. Good to see the egos of such colleges are still healthy

Once again I fail to see what gains are made here

SHC are potentially hindering development, the player is missing out on improving and showcasing his skills and the club miss out on a league standard player.

I don't agree with it but all kids and their families are made well aware of this when they go to these schools so if they don't like it go to a public school.

Is he on a scholarship with the school?