2012 Reports & Tribunal Discussion

[smac]

According to SANFL twat, he was found not guilty.

[Big Phil]

According to SANFL twat, he was found not guilty.

Yeah, just saw that, thanks...

Adam Cockshell was initially offered a 2 week ban but fought it at the tribunal and is now free to play this week...

Ben Kane also fought his 1 match suspension and is free to play for the Double Blues against his brother's Eagles side on Sunday...

[Big Phil]

Anyone know whether Adam Cockshell was suspended from the North v Port game on Sunday?

I don't think the SANFL publish results from their Reserves tribunal hearings?

They dont BP, thats why I asked about the 2 Centrals lads last week

Yeah, I should have remembered that Jim, sorry mate...

That being said, as smac pointed out, they have published the outcome on Cockshell, but probably more because he is a regular League player.

https://twitter.com/intent/user?screen_name=SANFLnews

[Jim05]

James Gowans escapes with a reprimand for striking.

[Big Phil]

James Gowans escapes with a reprimand for striking.

Yeah, watched the replay of the Maggies v Dogs game last night...

Would have been for the little jab to the bread basket of Port's Brad Mercer, for which he got a 50m penalty...

Interresting to know whether Mercer's big hit on Waldhuter might have been loooked at?

Also, interested whether the IRP looked at an off the ball hit on Kyle Jenner by Port skipper James Meiklejohn as well as the Port skipper dumping Jenner in a dangerous 'sling' tackle?

None of the incidents mentioned above didn't look good on the replay...

[sjt]

James Gowans escapes with a reprimand for striking.

Yeah, watched the replay of the Maggies v Dogs game last night...

Would have been for the little jab to the bread basket of Port's Brad Mercer, for which he got a 50m penalty...

Interresting to know whether Mercer's big hot on Waldhuter might have been loooked at?

Also, interested whether the IRP looked at an off the ball hit on Kyle Jenner by Port skipper James Meiklejohn as well as the Port skipper dumping Jenner in a dangerous 'sling' tackle?

None of the incidents mentioned above didn't look good on the replay...

You sure you were watching football BP?

[Big Phil]

Interresting to know whether Mercer's big hot on Waldhuter might have been loooked at?

You sure you were watching football BP?

Umm, yes

The 'I' and 'O' button are next to each other on the keyboard

That's my excuse, anyway

[SDK]

Gowans a reprimand !!!????? With his reputationn ?
My verdict ..... crucifiction !!!!! Nail some sense into him !

[sjt]

Gowans a reprimand !!!????? With his reputationn ?
My verdict ..... crucifiction !!!!! Nail some sense into him !

What's his reputation? From memory been suspended for about three or four games over 12 years.

[Brodlach]

Anyone have any idea about the reports on the weekend, nothing on tha SANFL site. There were three from Prospect

[Jim05]

Anyone have any idea about the reports on the weekend, nothing on tha SANFL site. There were three from Prospect

3 from the Parade aswell.

[Hodges 153!]

Anyone have any idea about the reports on the weekend, nothing on tha SANFL site. There were three from Prospect

3 from the Parade aswell.

Only one (Clayton) according to yesterday's paper?

[Brodlach]

Ty Alen has accepted his one match ban.

Thompson and Tippet fighting their one match bans.

Bricknell fighting his reprimand.

[Big Phil]

Ty Alen has accepted his one match ban.

Thompson and Tippet fighting their one match bans.

Bricknell fighting his reprimand.

The Press Release I got from the SANFL said Ty Allen recieved a preimand, not suspension?

Surprise that Port's Jeremy Clayton or James Meiklejohn at least get reprimands for their respective dangerous tackles...

TRIBUNAL REPORTS
Glenelg’s Ty Allen has accepted a reprimand from the Incident Review Panel for a striking charge.

North’s Kriston Thompson will front the Tribunal at 5.50 tonight to challenge a one match suspension issued by the Incident Review Panel for a striking charge.

Port’s Daniel Kulikowski will front the Tribunal at 6.15 tonight to challenge a reprimand handed down by the Incident Review Panel for a forceful front on contact charge. The charge dates back to Round 11. Hospitalisation has delayed his Tribunal appearance.

West’s Joel Tippett will front the Tribunal at 6.30 tonight to challenge a one match suspension handed down by the Incident Review Panel for a striking charge.

West’s Scott Bricknell will front the Tribunal at 6.40 tonight to challenge a reprimand issued by the Incident Review Panel for a striking charge.

[Brodlach]

My message had one week but that has since been changed and it didnt mention Daniel Kulikowski at all

[Wedgie]

Reprimands wouldnt get challenged too often!

[Brodlach]

Reprimands wouldnt get challenged too often!

Lost his appeal and will now miss a game


WTF were they thinking

[dedja]

LOL, that's gold ...

[Pseudo]

Reprimands wouldnt get challenged too often!

Lost his appeal and will now miss a game


WTF were they thinking

Didn't want to jeopardise those Magarey Medal chances....

[Big Phil]

Results are in from the SANFL tribunal, as eluded to above:

West's Scott Bricknell - 1 week suspension
West's Joel Tippett - 1 week suspension
North's Kriston Thompson - 2 week suspension